26 Sep 2013 19:22:06
Is moyes the right man for the job? {Ed007's Note - I've set a new poll up jred.

With the season well under way, do you think that Davie Moyes is the right man for the job?

Please take 2 mins to vote:

www.manchesterunitedrumours.co.uk/poll8.html


1.) 26 Sep 2013
The problem, which should have been obvious, is that Moyes is excellent at dealing with secondary talent, but not at the top level.

This is the difference between SAF and Moyes. SAF gets the best out of very good players. Moyes gets the best out of less good players. Also, they know this.

The problem explained.


2.) 26 Sep 2013
Oh, FFS the guys had 5 league and 1 cup game in charge. Sure he's made mistakes (IMHO) but which of us including SAF don't, particularly when you're in a new job/ situation.

How was SAF so much better at getting more from the players, after 5 games last season we'd lost 2 (same as Moyes) the difference is a draw against a Chelsea side who came to OT with the intention of not losing, rather than winning, the peacock was scared of us!

Why don't you do another stupid and massively premature poll for the "Moyse Out" persons asking who they'd like instead - Di Canio anyone?

Better still a poll asking them which club they will support if Moyse stays, because United fans they ain't if they don't get behind the team AND the manager.


3.) 27 Sep 2013
Well turns out Moyes has the best record of any manager in their debut season at United since Sir Matt Busby and we all know we haven't seen a start to the season as tough as this one in terms of fixtures for ages.


4.) 27 Sep 2013
Those out with a razor for Moyes's throat need to calm down a bit. Don't be in a haste to pass your judgement. History has shown that stability is the only way to prosperity. And for things to stabilize, we need to give him time.

I, personally would be content with a CL qualification for the next season. We can take it forward after that. It's not that we won the league in all the season when SAF was in charge. I remember those dark days when Keane was about to retire and we were in all sorts of disarray. We still rebuilt and won three titles in a row.

Keep the faith, folks. We will never die.


5.) 28 Sep 2013
Let's ember this isn't Moyes' team. We need a good shakeup. Roy Keane said after winning you need a shakeup to be successful again. A major one hasn't happened for years and complacency kicks in, as it did against City. Rooney spat his dummy out but look at his effort this season in trying to be the main man again. Granted he probably wants to leave but we need competition for the first 11 and we haven't really had 'true' competition for years! Especially in midfield!


6.) 28 Sep 2013
I think all of you guys have your heads in the clouds if you think Moyes is the right man for the job and all he needs is time. He is the wrong man for the job. Simple!


7.) 28 Sep 2013
. so that's where we're going wrong. Listening to the advice of the successful manager Roy Keane:-)


8.) 30 Sep 2013
30 Sep 2013 10:16:48
Alex ferguson got out at the right time some of the defenders are just not up to it. Whoever took the job on a hiding to nothing. As they say every dog has his day have united had theirs .


9.) 30 Sep 2013
30 Sep 2013 10:32:50
Personally, I don't know whether Moyse is the right man for the job, only time will tell but one thing is certain Moyse ain't going anywhere any time soon - so back him and the team if you are a supporter rather than a glory person!

One thing I was absolutely certain of after just one season, and for several more after that, was that Fergie wasn't the right man for the job! That proved totally right - NOT!