27 Feb 2018 14:47:55
Had a quick read of the round up below from tris.

Re the PL all stars game - North VS South?

Obviously us as united fans would pit for the North but who would your 11 be?

DDG
Walker
Bailly
Laporte
Shaw
Matic
Silva
De Bruyne
Salah
Sanchez
Aguero

Bench?
Ederson, Otamendi, Valencia, Pogba, Martial, Firmino, Lingard

Would probably be mine

Thoughts?

{Ed001's Note - Shaw? He can't get a game for United, how can he be first choice in an All Star team? What about someone like Baines or even Ward of Burnley? I know they have both had injury problems this year, but they were first choice and their teams look much better when they play.

Thanks for reading the round up by the way.}


1.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 15:21:22
De Gea
Walker
Bailly
Kompany
Mendy
Matic
De Bruyne
Pogba
Salah
Aguero
Sanchez.


2.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 15:55:51
I'm amazed that there is 9 United players in the whole squad. Red tinted glasses on.
If it was based on current form surely sterling gets a nod over Sanchez, heck even firmino.
Baines over Shaw when fit, even Robertson on current formis good.
And company over 1 of the centre backs and have van dijk on bench at least. And mane on bench over lingard.


3.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 16:22:51
If your going to do something like this then the only fiat way to do it is to restrict it to no more than two players from any one side.

Other wise it's just a United/ City/ Liverpool XI Vs Chelsea/ Arsenal/ Spurs XI.

No more than two players from anyone side makes it interesting as well as a genuine North Vs South competition.


4.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 16:32:17
Sane Aguero Salah
Pogba Matic De Bruyne
Walker Otomendi Bailly Mendy
De Gea

might be a pretty good team.


5.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 18:25:18
Fernandinho is twice the player of Matic, he is a major cog in the City set-up. I think you have this wrong in your teams.

Pogba doesn't deserve to be in the team either on form (maybe undeserved media hype), I think Gana has been better than him. I'd personally have Kompany in their over Otamendi, just to have an organiser with experience and brains.


6.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 18:54:15
De Gea

Mendy
Kompany
Bailly
Walker

Fernandinho
De Bruyne
Silva

Salah
Aguero
Sanchez

Bench Ederson, VVD, Tony V, Pogba, Sane, Firmino, Jesus

Amazing how many people don’t have D Silva, he’s top draw.


7.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 19:00:16
Ddg walker bailly kompany mendy
Matic kdb silva
Salah aguero sane

V

Lloris
Azpi alderwield vertonghan rose
Kante dembele
Willian erickson hazzard
Kane

You could name 2 decent sides for each region really easily.


8.) 27 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 20:35:43
See a few people saying Mendy at lb. How many games has he played this season?


9.) 28 Feb 2018
27 Feb 2018 22:51:25
Did someone say Robertson? Good to see LSD having a bit of a revival with posters. And Van Djik? He has defensive awareness as if he's on LSD, paying £75 million for him, i'd say the owners were on LSD too.


10.) 28 Feb 2018
28 Feb 2018 09:32:37
Why is bailly in every team?