Manchester United Rumours Member Posts


DDG1's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing

No Profile Picture uploaded

Team: Manchester United

Where from: Ireland

Favourite player: Keane

Best team moment:



DDG1's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To DDG1's Posts



To DDG1's last 5 banter posts


To DDG1's last 5 rumour replies


To DDG1's last 5 banter replies


DDG1 has no Rumours Posts



DDG1's banter posts with other poster's replies to DDG1's banter posts


19 Jun 2019 19:05:59
I really don't think Mata's new deal makes any sense. 2 year deal with option for a further year? Good influence. Good pro. Sets an example. Nice guy.
BUT: too slow for right wing, not quite good enough for number 10 and not strong/ quick enough for centre mid. And he doesn't have the speedy slick passing of Silva (s) . Nor the killer through balls of De Bruyne. Compare him to Bernardo Silva who is Mr Perpetual Motion and he is static in comparison. I just don't see the logic in paying someone to stick around and write a nice blog whenever we lose. It's another decision based on sentiment. I don't see where he fits into the team or the style of play we're told ole wants to introduce. Maybe he'll play europa league and cameo appearances from bench in EPL but I don't get it.
I hope he scores 20 goals next season and shuts me up but I doubt it.


1.) 19 Jun 2019 19:41:07
He doesn’t have speedy slick passing or perpetual motion of Silva because our team doesn’t play that way.

The City system is quick one two passing and movement. Do we even have a system other than not trying very hard? What’s Mata supposed to do? Run around like a headless chicken as our team plod up the pitch? We already have Lingard for that job.

Mata was Chelsea player of the season as part of a midfield three that focused on moving the ball quickly. Jose came back, and Mata didn’t fit. There’s a reason Barcelona were looking at him, and it’s precisely for his experience and passing ability. In the right system, he can play an important role in the squad.

2.) 19 Jun 2019 19:42:49
Its pretty simple to be honest, we have just lost valencia, herrera and fellaini who are all experienced pros. You can dispute their quality absolutely but no one questioned their work ethic or attitude.

Add into the equation de gea, pogba, lukaku could be off. that's a huge amount of experience to lose in one season. Mata can be a useful squad player who isn't on massive wages by todays standards and won't cause an ounce of trouble for ole.

Completely reasonable move for the club to make, its just with the lack of progress with incoming transfers and the inability to keep key players at the club, every bit of news out of united at the moment is being treated with so much negativity.

3.) 19 Jun 2019 21:13:11
Agree with DSG.

Maya already knows he’s not first choice. He’s going to start 15-20 games a season, probably every cup game, Europa League, and fill in when players are injured or need a rest.

To find another player of his quality but younger we’d be paying £35m+.

He’s also a good egg, we need a good influence in the dressing room.

4.) 19 Jun 2019 21:15:42
We can’t sell everyone all in one go. Mata has experience and seems to have the right attitude so it makes sense to keep him on board. I may be wrong but he is intelligent and a good communicator so it wouldn’t surprise me if they have a coaching or ambassadorial role in mind for him long term.

5.) 20 Jun 2019 01:20:27
That would be a good move by the club I think Redman. Especially for young players coming into United from Europe and South America.

6.) 20 Jun 2019 06:58:07

Exactly, Spanish speaking, very marketable and can help attract in the future. Experience on the pitch. If we had the defence and midfield we could push up the pitch 10 yards bringing the team, defence, midfield and attack closer, less gap between the lines meaning Mata’s intricate skills would be easier to harness.

7.) 20 Jun 2019 07:59:17
Every single player we have would play better in a team that was playing better . That is what we need to improve.
But mata seems a nice guy.

8.) 20 Jun 2019 14:07:58
Red Man, I'm going to mark this in the diary. We agree 😁.



14 Jun 2019 20:19:21
If, as per media reports, we lose De Gea, Pogba and Lukaku as well as Herrera and possibly others we face a huge overhaul of playing staff this summer. Whether you agree with his appointment or not we have to back Ole and hope he is given scope to make the changes he deems necessary. We see the players once or twice a week but he sees them on the training pitch every day and should be able to make judgment calls about their ability and attitude after his few months in the job. As fans we have to trust his judgment and back his calls.
The signing of D James and the links to AWB and Longstaff hint at signing young, hungry British players with potential. If he can blend these with a couple of academy graduates such as Mason G and add a couple of more experienced signings we have to hope that he can eventually build a side capable of challenging for honours. This rebuild will take time and requires patience from the fans. It may get worse before it gets better as the new players settle in but we have to hope and believe (despite all evidence to the contrary) that there is a plan and that it will eventually bear fruit.
If we lose the aforementioned 'big' names then a signing like Saul Niguez, Rabiot, or Bruno Fernandes will be needed to signal intent and placate restless fans but I think he has to sign the right player at centre back to make the rest of the team come together. That will be the toughest task. I don't think maguire is the man to take on this mantle but maybe he could do well. Who knows? Koulibaly would inspire more confidence. Dias looks promising too. It'll be an interesting and probably frustrating summer but let's try to keep the faith. for a few months at least.


1.) 14 Jun 2019 21:29:01
Ole Gonner.



10 Mar 2019 14:57:45
I'm a little bit worried about today. Fatigue could be a factor for both teams but Arsenal will be really up for it after the Cup game. It's a massive 6 pointer given Spurs' result yesterday. I think we can terrorise their defence with our pace but it might be a backs to the wall job for long periods. Here's hoping the Ole effect and positive vibes in the camp carry us on to another huge 3 points. Arsenal have an easy enough run in after today so it's vital we go for the win. C'mon United!




30 Jan 2019 11:28:14
We all love him as a person and he is a talented footballer but it's clear that Mata does not suit our style of play. His lack of pace and strength means he loses the ball too easily and slows down our play. He takes too many touches and though he is a decent passer he doesn't cut teams open the way Silva, De Bruyne and Pogba can with brilliant through balls. He has become a luxury we can't afford.
We need to play with the pace and interplay that has been so successful recently and that means Rashford, Martial, Lingard and Sanchez. Lukaku's touch isn't good enough for this style of football yet he remains an effective plan B. Mata offers little or nothing defensively and is now becoming a burden in our attack. He's a lovely man but not what's required now. At times he looks like a little boy who wandered onto a pitch with adults as he scampers after them but fails to keep up. I really like the guy but his time is up. I felt he and Perreira cost us dearly last night and their selection was a first black mark against Ole. Other factors were at play too. Rashford missing that early sitter clearly affected his confidence. Barnes and Wood were given too much freedom at times. The epic comeback was thrilling and brilliant but it should never have had to come to that. Lessons learned we hope.


1.) 30 Jan 2019 12:21:20
DDG1 - As the dust settles on a largely frustrating yet pulsating night at Old Trafford the post-mortem will undoubtedly begin. Some will say the bubble has finally bust, normal service resumed etc etc etc. Before the start of the game a draw would have been viewed as two points dropped, by the end of the game it was a point gained. It was tough to take considering our recent resurgence but I think it perhaps emphasise's what we already know about this team.

Ole took a calculated risk and it backfired. When you take the energy, pace and intensity out of this Utd team it looks ordinary. To be fair I think Ole understands this. With big games coming thick and fast he tried to freshen things up and it didn't quite click.

Herrera and Lingard are the heartbeat of this team. They provide the energy and intensity and their role in Ole's new look Utd shouldn't be underestimated.

It was a mistake to rest both of them at the same time.

Pereira was ineffectual all night. He didn't seem to understand his role, he was sloppy in possession and struggled to effect the game. He was lucky not be hooked at HT.

Mata was similarly ineffective. He lacks pace in the transitions and the intensity to win the ball back. He clogs the midfield and doesn't provide the thrust or penetration that Lingard offers. In Mata's defence he played much better when he moved into Perreria's position in the second half. I think he's more suited to a midfield role in this team and certainly at home against lower placed opposition.

Lukaku was frustratingly static again and the temptation is always huge to hit the front too early when he plays.

We lacked fluidity and movement and Pogba struggled to influence the game without willing runners in front of him.

Our defensive fragility is still evident and whilst I believe Jones is a decent squad player we desperately need a left sided CB in order to take us to the next level.

The comeback was resounding and if we'd played a few minutes longer I think we'd have got a winner. We showed determination and resilience and it was a hard earned point in the end.

On a positive note I think Ole knows his best team. I think the Perreria inclusion was questionable but apparently he's been training well and deserved his chance. Martial was unfortunately injured so some changes were enforced. I think by playing Mata, Pereira and Lulaku it tipped the balance the wrong way and we definitely missed that energy, pace and penetration we've witnessed since Ole took over. Hopefully he'll learn from this and whilst rotation is important he must keep the balance.

This Utd team is at its best when it plays with energy, intensity and fluidity. Pogba needs movement and forward runners to allow him the opportunity to fully influence the game. Unfortunately Ole took all three key ingredients out of our game last night and it showed. We probably lack squad depth in these areas and this needs to be addressed in the summer.

We need to see a reaction of Sunday now. No need to panic just yet.

2.) 30 Jan 2019 16:56:54
Good post DLIB.



29 Sep 2018 17:23:20
The players are as much to blame as Jose but the buck stops with him. So many of them aren't putting in the effort. There is zero pressing or closing down. There is no urgency or clear attacking plan. Matic is ambling about the place in a slow jog and he's supposed to be our midfield leader. Everything is slow, lacking vision and apathetic. They look like they don't care. What was he thinking putting McTominay centre half? Bizarre. It's like something a spoilt child would do; you didn't buy me the centre back I wanted so look what I have to do now? I think it's broken now and Jose's position is untenable. He probably didn't get the support he wanted in terms of signings but he hasn't improved any of his players bar maybe Lingard who didn't make the squad today. He's succeeded in alienating a large portion of his players and slagged off too many of them publicly. It's become a complete mess. I can't see any way back from this. How many of our players would get into the Liverpool, City, Chelsea, Spurs team? Apart from De Gea not many if any. Root and branch restructuring required.


1.) 29 Sep 2018 18:05:06
Zero effort closing down? No pressing? Come on DSG, do you think if the players were trained and instructed to press or stay close to their opponents they wouldn't?

Mourinho orders them to stand off and go on the counter.

Why do you think every team from Wolves to Derby to Tottenham all look like the all mighty Barcelona when we play them?

Are you trying to tell me that all these years Mourinho and his coaching haven't realized it or that they instructed the players to do so but the players refused or are you insinuating that it's the players' prerogative to press or not press during the game?

Are they not given tactical instructions based on opponent scouting by the coaching team before and during the game?

Why does the manager and his coaching team are on the touchline and have the ability to change personnel, formation or tactics in-game?


2.) 29 Sep 2018 18:19:24
It is like he wants to be sacked to get a payout.

He doesn't want to be here anyway so why have someone that isn't committed 100 percent

People have been debating if a new manager would change the way the players are working well just look at hazard. New manager and he is on fire.

It's only going to get worse.

I can't see where and when our next win will come from

The football is dated and slow and tbh it's getting tiring saying the same thing every week.

3.) 29 Sep 2018 18:32:42
There were 8 players behind the ball and no one pressing for most of the game. These players were good when they were at their previous clubs so I can't blame them anymore for their form. Lukaku was constantly among the top scorers when at everton and now he can't get score at all. The players are sent with the instruction of not conceding and it was working until other teams realized and they could break us even with a little pressure and we don't exactly have fast players for counter attack. Every match seems like we are playing against City or Liverpool, no team is afraid of us as they know that defence is the priority. It's just down to Jose from team selection to our playing style. These same players will look world class under some other manager.

4.) 29 Sep 2018 20:03:06

What on earth are you talking about? Clearly the coaches are not telling the players to saunter around the pitch and not bother to win the ball back.

It isn't a tactical issue of high press versus low press. The players are simply not putting the effort in.

Jose has lost the players, even the crowd today were quiet. Woody created this situation by not backing jose in market. But I can't see how Jose can come back from this.

5.) 29 Sep 2018 21:12:01
They are told to only mark when players are within certain territories.

Or is zonal marking for which Mourinho is fabled a new concept to you?

Players will fall back into a predefined shape and distance trying to constric their opposition attack without committing (pressing) and losing shape.

That's why when any of out players chases down, he suffers and stops because others don't. They are firmly rooted.

When ball is won, a worked out counter attack pattern ensues.

As for the pressing, ironically, Mourinho only tries that against big teams -

Sometimes I wonder if people only watch games for the sake of watching. SMH They are told to only mark when players are within certain territories.

Or is zonal marking for which Mourinho is fabled a new concept to you?

Players will fall back into a predefined shape and distance trying to constric their opposition attack without committing (pressing) and losing shape.

That's why when any of out players chases down, he suffers and stops because others don't. They are firmly rooted.

When ball is won, a worked out counter attack pattern ensues.

As for the pressing, ironically, Mourinho only tries that against big teams -

Sometimes I wonder if people only watch games for the sake of watching. SMH.

6.) 29 Sep 2018 21:47:29
Jose’s attitude is you can’t make mistakes if you don’t have the ball.
Says it all really that’s why they don’t high press.

7.) 29 Sep 2018 23:16:17
On the plus side you will probably get tonked by city and Chelsea then change manager in time to play and beat us 🤦🏻‍♂️.

8.) 30 Sep 2018 08:25:49
Lukaku has 19 goals in his last 17 games for Belgium it's almost like he is a decent player.




DDG1's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

26 Jan 2019 13:53:55
A bit up and down.




Click To View This Thread

26 Jan 2019 09:15:01
One hit wonder.




Click To View This Thread

Brazilian Anderson to sign for Basque-only Athletic Bilbao? Would be a first. {Ed044's Note - It would not be a first mate but it is unusual.}





DDG1's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

16 Mar 2019 08:31:56
Gaitan on a free transfer; how did we let one slip through our fingers? There’s always Sneijder.




Click To View This Thread

42 is the answer to the meaning of life, the universe and everything. SAF was more of a 442 man. LVG remains confused.




Click To View This Thread

1. Chelsea
2. Arsenal
3. Liverpool
4. City
6. Spurs
1. Burnley
2. Leicester
3. West Brom




Click To View This Thread

Thanks ed002




Click To View This Thread

I think Moyes will play it very safe tomorrow night and opt for a three man midfield of carrick (fletcher if carrick has to play cb) fellaini and giggs with Valencia and welbeck offering wide support to Rooney. Unfortunately I don't think he'll play kagawa. I'd love to see him throw januzaj on at some stage but he has barely used him in Europe. It wouldn't be the team I'd pick but Moyes will revert to type and be cautious.
Looking forward to it but realistically expecting a chastening experience over the two legs and a heavy aggregate defeat. Hope I'm wrong and we summon a magical performance out of somewhere. Unlikely though. Injuries at the back aren't helping things either.