Manchester United Rumours Member Posts

 

Nathaniel's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
Correct Score Competition:

Not entered
Correct Score Competition
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing


No Profile Picture uploaded

Team:


Where from:


Favourite player:


Best team moment:


Interests:


Timezone:




Nathaniel's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Nathaniel's Posts

 

 

To Nathaniel's last 5 rumours posts

 

To Nathaniel's last 5 banter posts

 

To Nathaniel's last 5 rumour replies

 

To Nathaniel's last 5 banter replies

 

Nathaniel's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Nathaniel's rumours posts

 

25 May 2016 13:49:50
Eds, was wondering if United were going to go back in for Andre Gomes this summer? Ed002 told us that he was one of the players who we stepped back on in Jan due to fan unrest. Wouldn't surprise me if Jose was a fan and we all know the links with Mendes there.

Nathaniel

{Ed004's Note - I think he's looking likely to head to Juve}


1.) 25 May 2016 23:54:20
I like the juventus connection as he'd be a great replacement for an old trafford bound pogba! The dream is alive.


 

 

08 Mar 2016 23:20:27
linking us with Nikola Maksimovic from Torino. Serbian international centreback. Anyone know anything about him?

Nathaniel

 

 

29 Aug 2015 20:21:42
Chicharito supposedly been told he can leave. Surely the club would have someone lined up if this was the case?

Nathaniel

1.) 30 Aug 2015 00:07:38
Totenham or West Ham most likely they were the clubs interested


 

 

18 Aug 2015 21:58:46
Rumours late this evening that Chelsea are trying to hijack Pedro. Have you heard anything eds?

Nathaniel

{Ed004's Note - I expect the club to complete a deal for Pedro in the coming days}


 

 

17 Jul 2015 23:07:26
Eds what do you know of the news that United are apparently set to trigger Pedro's release clause?

Nathaniel

{Ed007's Note - Unless there's been a massive change of plan in the last day or two I'd say it's bollocks. The last thing I know was that Utd were approached and asked if they were interested in the player a while back and they weren't.}


1.) 17 Jul 2015 23:42:06
Thanks for the detailed answer Ed! Pedro was a player i thought had a outside chance of coming in, ill erase that thought now


 

 

 

Nathaniel's banter posts with other poster's replies to Nathaniel's banter posts

 

01 Jun 2016 22:11:49
What does everyone expect from Memphis next season?

Lots of people (me included) get wound up looking towards what new players we could buy this summer, sometimes forgetting the players we have who with a new manager's belief could improve on the pitch.

Could he potentially benefit from being one of the few internationals not going to the Euros and getting a full pre-season with Jose.

One of the things we all disliked about LvG was his insistence on playing people out of position. Is it possible to fit Memphis in the team without doing so? (If Martial is our first choice LW)

Personally, I still believe in the lad and believe that in the right system he could flourish.

Nathaniel

1.) 01 Jun 2016 23:43:38
He will come good next year, he has enough qualities to make it as a good footballer.


2.) 02 Jun 2016 00:05:53
I believe in him too as a potential great but and there is a big but he must learn to play for the team by doing his defensive duties too when needed. If he doesn't I can't see Mourinho retaining him.


3.) 02 Jun 2016 00:06:58
Hi mate,

I agree that Depay would most likely flourish under Jose, but sbout this concept of Martial being a lw i slightly disagree. Whilst i think Martial can play there brilliantly, he is a striker, an expensive one.

I would prefer to try depay on lw again and see if he improves and play Martial and Rashford in rotation for striker with rw like griezman or someone like him coming in, and if all else fails then we can play Martial lw again worse comes to worse.

Cypriotenglish.


4.) 02 Jun 2016 01:20:20
He needs the rolls Royce and g wagon taken away and stored in a garage after taking delivery of a team chevrolet. He needs some black boots from under armour and just knuckle down. I think he will be better and more direct next season with a bit of guidance.


5.) 02 Jun 2016 07:41:58
I believe he could well be a revelation under Mourhino.
In reality, I think we might never know as I fear there is a real danger that he'll be shown the door.


6.) 02 Jun 2016 13:55:59
Martial looks like he can play a Ronaldo type role. Which can give you all kind of options through the middle if he's not greedy which he isn't. I also worry for depay who if we lose I would expect to be a world beater in a couple of seasons.


7.) 02 Jun 2016 18:20:14
I think we will sell him after one more season, does not have the pace and flatters to deceive because he is muscular and has all those tatoos.

I have been very vocal saying he has been utter sh. t and i think he will be no different under Jose.

Jose will buy a striker and a right winger and Martial will play left wing. Him and Shaw should be fun to watch.


 

 

23 Sep 2015 14:52:00
I saw a massive thread down the page about LvG not trusting youth in the league cup.

He said he's not going to use Wilson and Lingard tonight and they're getting a rest day.

Maybe he's going to use one of them/both of them at some point vs Sunderland on Saturday. Ipswich are in decent form and will be a lot more up for it than Sunderland.

Nathaniel

1.) 23 Sep 2015 15:12:52
was the post about lvg not trusting youth or about the game tonight being the perfect chance to have a player like wilson on the bench and give him some minutes.

i would give wilson perreira etc a go in the cup before the EPL .
wilson hasn't made the 18 man squad for the league this season i would of though the game tonight would of been a good chance for him


2.) 23 Sep 2015 15:22:31
That would be my first thought too jred, but maybe the manager has a better idea than us having watched them in training etc?


3.) 23 Sep 2015 15:58:06
Or maybe he thinks Wilson isn't ready for the first team yet. There is a massive step between being the best at under 21 level and being good enough for a champions league teams first team.

As for Lingard I like him but I doubt he would ever be more than a squad player for us at best. I'd play Pereira ahead of him to be honest, as he has more potential.

Then let us remember a year ago LvG underestimated lower league opposition in this very competiton. I expect he will field a much stronger side this time round. We still haven't clicked in attack yet, that will only come with game time. So it might make sense to play the first team in this game.


4.) 23 Sep 2015 16:12:22
I watched him on Monday and he is still very raw. Imo he is not ready and is still some way off. I can only assume that the coaching staff concur with this opinion. Lindgard looked miles ahead of him to be fair. I think AP may well be involved.
I think lvg got burnt lat year by mk dons who are inferior to Ipswich so he won't take too many chances and rightly so imo this is a very important match.


5.) 23 Sep 2015 16:18:02
shap
then why not let him go out on loan.

we have the league , fa and EC who really cares about this cup .

we also have a massive month of football starting with wolfsburg on wed.
i would play kids give them a chance and if we get beat we get beat .

lets be honest maze gets stick for saying lvg can do no right but there is a good few who argue he can do no wrong .


6.) 23 Sep 2015 16:28:29
I think LVG was clear on the matter. Having just played in the U-21 game against Everton, they are not needed for tonight and can rest up for the remainder of this week. They will get their chance when the manager thinks they've earned it. To say he's not promoting youth is ridiculous given that Depay, Martial, and Shaw are now solid first team players. The policy is clearly oriented towards youth, although as much through acquisition as development.


7.) 23 Sep 2015 17:24:13
LVG was very clear on it Shawthing. But some people want to make a big deal about everything.

LVG not giving youth a chance, makes me laugh


8.) 23 Sep 2015 17:31:24
Normally I would think if the youth are good enough they will play, especially in games like this one. In fairness to LVG we have a long way to go in building up relationships with the first team players so it makes sense to keep them going and improve their understanding. I just worry about fitness, a lot of games in a short space of time, the injuries will mount up as niggles and aches are not given time to rest and he pushes them on the training pitch as well.

I also worry about the amount of chances the young players will get to build up their experience (not the £30m+ signings). LVG has shown a reluctance to drop players for poor form, so it really will be an injury crisis that allows the academy players to get a chance, just like it was last season with Blackett & McNair.


9.) 23 Sep 2015 18:56:12
Jred, fron what I've heard Wilson is reluctant to go on loan as he feels that it is the beginning of the end for youngsters.
For me though I think the writing was on the wall for Wilson when we spent an initial 36m on Martial. Who is a very similar type striker to Wilson and is the same age. They are both 6ft, strong and very quick and clinical finishers. If LvG rated Wilson that highly spending that sort of money on Martial makes no sense. But having seen both of them play for the first team I would agree that Martial looks the better prospect and is certainly more refined than Wilson currently.
Wilson needs a loan where he will play every week, probably in the championship to start with. I hope he makes it as I had high hopes for him. Its just starting to look like he will miss the mark.

As for why LvG hasn't sent him on loan I would imagine because we are very light on numbers. We only have Rooney Martial and Wilson who are strikers. Fellaini can play there if really needed but certainly isn't great. So if Wilson left on loan that would just leave us Rooney amd Martial, one hasn't scored in the league yet and the other is new to the league.

As for whether he should be on the bench for tonight? Well I would have thought 90 minutes of competitive football would be better for his development than 90 minutes of bench warming. Unless he was going to get at least 30 minutes tonight I would have let him play for the Under 21's too.


10.) 23 Sep 2015 22:08:43
Beast, how many young players are going to get extended opportunities to shine in any of the top teams? My guess is our average age is now approaching the lowest in the league.

As for the risk of injuries, while I don't disagree, look at Chelsea last year. They played a consistent team without too many changes.


11.) 23 Sep 2015 22:48:29
5th youngest average age Shawthing.


 

 

02 Sep 2015 11:09:44
Reports coming out of Spain this morning suggest that De Gea may sign a new contract to solidify his place at United before the Euros but would allow him to leave next summer for a certain fee.

Could this be true?

Nathaniel

{Ed002's Note - I explained the options. This is just speculation right now.}


 

 

01 Sep 2015 10:10:28
It's looking more and more likely that it was Real Madrid who messed up the De Gea transfer. I'm not saying that we handled the situation well, because we simply didn't. However it was inevitable that it was going to end messy when dealing with Madrid. They deliberately left their opening bid until the last day to make themselves look they pulled off a late victory. Moreover, the Spanish authorities are now saying that it was Real Madrid who were late with the paper work.

I think us United fans have got to hope that somehow it is resolved because if we end up keeping a player who had his heart set on a move it could be very disruptive. Madrid don't really lose anything because they have a top goalkeeper whom their fans love. If it comes to it and De Gea stays at Old Trafford we've got to hope he can regain focus and play again because a season with Romero in goal could be fatal.

Nathaniel

 

 

31 Aug 2015 13:59:52
Provided he plays a decent chunk of time this season, Adnan going to Dortmund could be great for him and us. They could turn him in to the player we all wanted him to become on our behalf. Just hope Ed doesn't do something stupid and agree to a view to buy option.

Nathaniel

 

 

 

Nathaniel's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

17 Jul 2018 12:56:27
If Jose was an adaptable, modest and inspiring manager he would realise that our squad is only 2 or 3 additions away from being up there with the very best.

However, his insistence on sticking with the only way of football he knows and picking fights with his players has left us with a needed squad overhaul in his eyes.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

02 Jul 2018 10:00:53
Danny Murphy had a point though. As did Kilbane. They're just doing their jobs.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

30 Jun 2018 13:01:02
Could understand why we would look to him, although I don't think he's proven himself worthy of the supposed price tag in the French league, as he is one of the rare left footed top forwards in Europe. If we wanted to play two narrow/ inside forwards (whatever they're called) off Lukaku he could actually play in the right channel. Could be seen as somewhat of an alternative to Bale in that respect.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

27 Jun 2018 13:03:30
Hardly a Fellaini fan but it is possible that the club see it as a more viable option to sell a more valuable player (Perhaps Herrera) and keep Fellaini on reduced wages to facilitate buying a young dynamic midfielder to be 4th in line in the midfield pecking order. Hopefully an attacking minded midfielder who we can play against lesser opposition and rest Matic.

Only caveat to this idea is why not just let Fellaini go as well and promote Andreas or McTom further up the pecking order.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

14 Jun 2018 14:53:35
Might be an unpopular opinion, especially with the football traditionalists, but this stuff doesn't bother me at all. It's the way the sport is going, it's the way some American sports have been for a while. What a player does on social media, on TV doesn't affect what he does on the pitch.

He's a massive basketball fan, he's doing what LeBron James did 8 years ago and just as every NBA team would have been better with LBJ every football team would be better with Griezmann.

Nathaniel

 

 

 

Nathaniel's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

21 Aug 2018 16:50:07
Mort does getting the best out of them include losing to each of the promoted teams and getting beat at home by the worst team in the league. Win 3 of those 4 last season and we're at 90 points.

It was those types of games where we looked absolutely devoid of creativity and fluidity which generated a lot of the negativity amongst the fan base toward Jose.

He always talks about how we train well and he sees what he wants to see in training and then it all disappears on matchday. The only matches where players look motivated to execute Jose's defensive tactics are the games against the top 6.

Perhaps the players get so fed up of preparing to park the bus and let a pub team dominate us that when they know they're in the starting XI they lose focus and aren't mentally prepared for the game. That all comes down to their belief in the manager and I just don't think it's there anymore.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

21 Aug 2018 16:50:07
Mort does getting the best out of them include losing to each of the promoted teams and getting beat at home by the worst team in the league. Win 3 of those 4 last season and we're at 90 points.

It was those types of games where we looked absolutely devoid of creativity and fluidity which generated a lot of the negativity amongst the fan base toward Jose.

He always talks about how we train well and he sees what he wants to see in training and then it all disappears on matchday. The only matches where players look motivated to execute Jose's defensive tactics are the games against the top 6.

Perhaps the players get so fed up of preparing to park the bus and let a pub team dominate us that when they know they're in the starting XI they lose focus and aren't mentally prepared for the game. That all comes down to their belief in the manager and I just don't think it's there anymore.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

10 Aug 2018 17:16:29
6-0 first half Maguire own goal hat trick followed by a Pogba hat trick in a 15 minute cameo. Jose will then precede to moan about Luke Shaw in his press conference.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

10 Aug 2018 11:27:22
We played some of our best football under the negative one with Blind at left back playing pretty much as a third centre back. That doesn't follow suit with the importance of the full backs.

Valencia gets a lot of stick but before his mid season injury and him being seriously overplayed he was one of our better performers.

Maybe I'm nuts and maybe my judgement is clouded but I believe the reason we started to look static, sluggish etc etc was because Jose gave up on our season when he realised he wasn't going to get the silverware he wanted.

Nathaniel

 

 

Click To View This Thread

08 Aug 2018 15:42:59
Perisic has played left wing exclusively for nearly 3 seasons.

Alderweireld was the clear first choice centre back. If we do sign him for whatever the cost it's good job Woodward. Cus Levy.

Can't remember specifically but it sounded on the sharkopod like Alex Sandro was Jose's pick for LB. If we pay 60m for him and he repeats last seasons form you would add him to the list of left backs Ashley Young has benched.

One of the Eds has said we've been chasing a right winger all summer. Maybe the one position where Woody has goofed up.

Nathaniel