Manchester United Rumours Member Posts


Schnauzer's Profile

Current Avatar:
Schnauzer's Avatar
Correct Score Competition:

Not entered
Correct Score Competition
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing

Current Profile Picture:
Click to view larger image
Schnauzer's Profile Picture

Team: Manchester United

Where from: England

Favourite player: Rio

Best team moment: 99


Timezone: (GMT -6:00) Central Time

Schnauzer's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Schnauzer's Posts



To Schnauzer's last 5 banter posts


To Schnauzer's last 5 rumour replies


To Schnauzer's last 5 banter replies


Schnauzer has no Rumours Posts



Schnauzer's banter posts with other poster's replies to Schnauzer's banter posts


02 Jul 2018 09:27:09
Saw the thread about giggs as manager and wondered what people's thoughts are on how much it matters for uniteds boss being someone of integrety or a person of good character? . Not asking for the boards view but your view.

Should the bosses personal life ie bedding his brothers missus matter?

Should/ shouldn't John Terry been dropped/ lost captaincy for England for bedding bridges missus?

Charlton didn't want Jose for non footballing reasons, just how he conducts himself is he right or is that an old fashioned view?

Curious for thoughts.

1.) 02 Jul 2018 10:04:42
Good questions mate. Usually when it comes to a player my view is I don’t give a damn what they do off the pitch as long as they are performing on it. In some ways I would apply that to the manager but I think it depends how on an individual’s perception of an integrous/ good person.

In some people’s eyes, Jose would not be a man who conducts himself with integrity (sir bobby’s view), whilst in others he does. If Giggs were to get the job I wouldn’t discount him based on his adultering past. Of course that’s not to say I condone adultery!

There are a few things where I would object. And they are obviously racism, sexism and homophobia. We as a club are a massive worldwide brand with a huge influence on millions upon millions of people. To have a manager that displays any of these traits would tarnish our reputation. I remember ed001 saying that sarri has said a few homophobic and sexist comments here and there. Perhaps it is culturally different in Italy, but I would have issues with him being manager based on those sorts of things.

Someone that likes the media games and causing angst for other managers on the touch line is fine for me. I like to see a bit of bite and a fiery side to my manager when he is on the touch line or the media room.

2.) 02 Jul 2018 10:40:08
Yes a manager's personal life needs to be considered. They are responsible for managing many complex personalities and are more of a representative of the club, (press conferences etc) . If they are up to no good, or have a low moral compass then that can effect the people beneath them and also bring the club into disrepute. With Giggs in particular his unfortunate decision making becoming public highlights what he is capable of, nobody knows what else he has done but unfortunately for him the suspicion is always there and the stain on his character will be permanent.

Everybody makes mistakes and there will be mitigating circumstances, but then there are roles outside of public scrutiny. If you want a high profile job then you need to ensure your public image is as clean as possible nowadays if you intend to make it.

Players are different as they aren't as important. Don't know much about Terry's case but I'm sure I read that the woman in question was the ex-girlfriend not current girlfriend of Bridge, BIG difference, still not ideal but on the face of it nowhere near as bad as Giggs situation.

We see that the team often reflects their manager. Our performances are erratic consistency wise, negative, several players seem to lack full commitment to the cause and everything seems to have a temporary feel to it for me. This is similar to Mourinho's current media persona and the impression he has given me since his tenure commenced!

3.) 02 Jul 2018 13:03:36
At least the players would know where Giggs was on match day.

4.) 02 Jul 2018 13:11:02
To be honest I think we will have to wait and see how he does, it just guess work if you haven't worked with him .
He is expected to do well tho but only time will tell.

5.) 02 Jul 2018 15:16:54
Players and managers are very different in their roles and what it means to be in that role.

Managers aren't just employees, they are the leader and key figure head of the organisation. They are the role model for those they manage and as such they set the standard of what should be expected.

Therefore, a deplorable human being in a role like that sets a pretty low bar for the players and sends out a poor message to fans and supporters around the globe.

I love Giggs, he was a fantastic player for us and has given me some wonderful memories of watching my club.

However, I don't think we will make a great manager. He might talk a good game, and it is easy to say that he suggested this player or that player, or he would do things differently. But it's all talk and no action. He needs to go out there and show he can do it differently and be a success as a manager.

The ghosts of his past will likely haunt him throughout his career as a manager. Imagine what would he say if he was managing a group of players and a situation like the one between John Terry and Wayne Bridge pops up. How is he supposed to handle that? How can he solve that issue without being a massive hypocrite? Can he console the player who has been wronged when that player knows that Giggs himself has done that to his own brother? An issue like that can tear apart a dressing room and Giggs would have no higher ground to stand and bring that dressing room back together.

6.) 02 Jul 2018 16:00:48
He would probably say been there done that here's some advice .



28 Jun 2018 09:17:38
Realistically we will be playing 4-2-3-1 for most of next season with Fred and matic as the 2 and pogba Central in the 3 Above.

So signing fellaini makes a lot more sense then spending 30m+ on a replacement.

I would assume fellaini will be matics back up and herara will be Fred back up and you still have pogba you can bring back to play in the 2 plus you have mctominay and tfm as further back up.

So my priority signings are a left back and right wing. If there's money left after that it would be a cb and then another cm.

Just my thoughts

Good luck to all united fans home nations unless they are playing england.

1.) 28 Jun 2018 09:56:29
I've read the Fellaini debate with interest and I think it's more what his signing represents that has angered many posters rather than the player himself.

Whilst I'm not his biggest fan he's been a good professional and represented the Club well. His perceived limitations as a player are not his fault and he always given his best. He possess a unique talent and when used in the correct way he can sometimes be an effective player and an awkward opponent.

I think at the start of the window there was a sense of excitement and optimism with changes to the coaching staff which maybe hinted at a change of philosophy and offered the hope of more expansive football.

The re-signing of Fellaini suggests to some that a leopard doesn't readily change his spots and the pragmatic football is set to continue or certainly remain a viable option.

In a strange paradox I think it's been fantastic to watch an England team playing with some intensity and imagination. I don't think anybody envisaged a year ago that Jesse Lingard would be integral to England's World Cup aspirations. The use of only one defensive midfielder with two more attack minded players is something we're just not used to from an England team and certainly wouldn't have happened under Allardyce. The fact that we've got both Ali and Lingard in the team, two tenacious, technically gifted, intelligent midfielders who both make brilliant runs off the ball, finding space between the lines is so refreshing and exciting to watch. I hope we don't revert to type and continue to be brave throughout the knockout stages. The exciting football and good weather has brought a real buz to the country.

Maybe Jose should take a look at what's happening with England and take notice. We just need Rashford to light up the tournament now.

2.) 28 Jun 2018 10:08:28
read all the posts, read most of the paper/ betting site crap and nowhere can i see fellaini confirmed as signing for us on a new or extended contract!

if its definately confirmed then fair play but until it is.

3.) 28 Jun 2018 11:18:41
At left back we have a choice of young Shaw rojo or even blind however we have nobody that wants to hug the right touchline, beat the fullback on his outside and deliver a cross. Mata always cuts back in and Jesse Marcus and Anthony would all prefer to play elsewhere.
For me therefore if we were only to make 1 more signing this window it would be a right footed (ie not bale) wide player to attack the byline as opposed to cutting in and attacking the penalty area.

4.) 28 Jun 2018 20:11:13
For such a bad player he plays for a good club and international team?
Why is that.



13 Jun 2018 11:11:26
Quick question do united still have a link to Royal Antwerp?

We used to regularly send a couple of players there each season, not heard anything recently.

1.) 13 Jun 2018 12:44:53
I think that ended years ago.

2.) 13 Jun 2018 14:41:53
I was wondering about that the other day as well. It was all the rage a few years ago having these 'affiliations' but never tend to hear much about it now.

3.) 13 Jun 2018 16:39:02
Probably because most of them were a waste of time. Very few undiscovered talent was found and the players loaned out didn't really progress playing in the Belgian 2nd division.



05 Jun 2018 12:50:53
Lunchtime ramble, Question for all, what formation do you think Jose will go with next season?

Vast majority of last season we played 4-2-3-1 with a few dabbles with 4-3-3 particularly towards the end of the season.

Fred suits both systems as he could play as a 3 with matic and pogba or as a 2 with matic and pogba gets pushed into the middle of the attacking 3.

If rumours are to be believed and we are interested in either veratti or sms aswell as Fred that could maybe imply we are heading for 4-4-2 with a midfield diamond of matic, Fred, sms/ veratti and pogba. That would mean attacking fullbacks would be even more crucial to provide width though.

Lukaku with one of sanchez, martial or rashford up top.

Would love to get back to 2 up top personally.

1.) 05 Jun 2018 13:00:56
Jose has played something like 70% of all his games 4231 . I don't think he will change much.

{Ed004's Note - At the end of the season he was playing 433 quite frequently and there were a few games were Sanchez appeared to play off Lukaku with Pogba drifting to the left almost like a 4411 style formation}

2.) 05 Jun 2018 13:04:27
433 I think, Matic holding, Fred the link to Pogba furthest forward, front 3 of Bale, RedRom and Sanchez 😉.

{Ed004's Note - I am hoping for the same signings but I would like to see a 4-4-2/4-4-1-1. Bale behind Lukaku with Pogba and Sanchez covering the wide positions. Fred and Matic holding the fort.}

3.) 05 Jun 2018 13:12:21
Jose sets up not to lose, and if we don't sort out that defence it will be 2 holding midfielders.

4.) 05 Jun 2018 13:23:05
My only hope is that when we play 4-2-3-1, that Jose will play Pogba as the central attacking midfielder, and play two behind him, from Matic, Fred or Herrera. Keep Pogba further up the pitch. As for your question, I still think we will see either 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 most of the time.

5.) 05 Jun 2018 14:20:41
I think we can forget about Bale now Zidane has left, I cannot see a new manager wanting to sell the MOTM from the champions league in his first window lol.



23 May 2018 15:53:53
Anyone think united and city should have a joint 3rd kit yellow and black stripes to show a city united or is that OTT? All profits could go to Manchester charities

Just a thought.

1.) 23 May 2018 18:54:20
Crazy thought but i get your sentiment.

2.) 23 May 2018 18:54:50
I think that is a tremendous idea, sadly it won’t be taken up but I would buy and wear one.

3.) 23 May 2018 19:52:43
I think its a fantastic idea.

4.) 23 May 2018 21:02:12
What the boys said.

5.) 23 May 2018 21:13:52
Get it done . Brilliant idea 😆😆🐝🐝.

6.) 23 May 2018 21:46:26
Brilliant idea, must be someone that idea can be forwarded too, I’d buy that shirt.

7.) 23 May 2018 23:33:45
Nice sentiment.




Schnauzer's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

14 Jun 2018 08:59:47
Reading between the lines of martials agent it seems clear to me, martial wants reasuurences he is in Joses plans, seeing Jose wouldn't and shouldn't give guarantees to any player, they are angling for a large contract which would at least indicate he is going to be a first team regular not a bit part player like the end of the season.

The fact martials agent has made public comments to me would suggest martial wants to stay, so they are trying to force the issue, if he didn't want to stay why would the agent make public comments? He would just be trying to find martial a new club, making public comments wouldn't help in getting a new club, it's not like putting an add in the messenger, there's only very few clubs who could afford martial and I would assume very few clubs martial would want to go to.

Just my thoughts.



Click To View This Thread

06 Jun 2018 12:40:36
How the conversation should go.
Levy - is martial for sale?
Woody - no
Levy - maybe Toby in a straight swap.

Woody - kiss my hairy meatballs. Its either 40m for Toby or its Shaw and 15m.

Levy - what about 50m for martial

Woody - are you talking about his wages or a transfer fee? In this market he is worth 70m easy and we don't want to sell so that's 110m for martial

Levy - We won't pay more than 50m for a player.

Woody - not my problem, 50m and Eriksen and we might talk. I'm busy conducting real business so no fannying around. You got till Monday, after that you're on call divert to my fax machine.



Click To View This Thread

20 Mar 2018 15:40:33
Eric - When have united ever not paid over the odds?

I would say most people rate martial as a good player with potential to be even better. Wouldn't class that as overrated.

Even if you don't think he has potential to go to the next level he surely must be way down your list of united problems?
And surely he has been our best left sided attacker this season? So even if you think he hasn't been good enough often enough there's been plenty worse?

Your point about Jose I agree with. The board back him or sack him.

Anyways here's to next season quadruple.



Click To View This Thread

19 Mar 2018 10:41:25
If martial can't make it at united our coaching staff aren't fit for purpose. I agree martial is not a winger and should be playing as a striker eventually.



Click To View This Thread

13 Feb 2018 12:01:58
3-2-3-2 next seasons formation fits every one in perfectly martial upfront with lukaku. Sanchez on the left pogba middle. Matic holding with someone who will help him and stay put. Bailly can hold the hands of the 2 either side of him and tell them to stop doing shite things like score og's or dive. Sorted for 18/ 19 just need 3 signings a cb a holding midfielder akin to a 25 year old Carrick and a right-sided player akin to a Beckham with crossing ability or a right sided giggs.




Schnauzer's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

12 Jul 2018 11:40:21
Beast - can't disagree with most of what you say.

I would say it's been a positive tournament for england

We got as far as we should of for me and meeting expectations is over achieving for England.

Hopefully the winter break will help us in the future. The drop off in the second half was scary and my one criticism of Southgate was that he didn't inject some more pace and freshness earlier. I would of Brought Loftus cheek and rashford on at around the 60th min mark.

But Southgate is learning and did well on the whole.



Click To View This Thread

09 Jul 2018 14:12:48
Shappy, can't disagree the 3-2-3-2 would win nothing but would be fun, was said more in jest.

Being more serious I would love to get back to having 2 up top and and I agree 3-5-2 and 4-4-2diamond would suit what we currently have.



Click To View This Thread

09 Jul 2018 13:11:04
Park- agreed its unlikely. Looks nice on paper but in reality I think it probably wouldn't work at all.

It's a nice split though you 5 defend you 5 attack its easy this managing lark.



Click To View This Thread

09 Jul 2018 12:22:32
If you wanted to get the pulses racing why not a 3-2-3-2.

Lindelof bailly rojo

Fred herrera

Sanchez pogba martial

Lukaku rashord.



Click To View This Thread

15 Jun 2018 23:13:07
You rascal.