08 Jun 2015 13:59:06
dunno why everyone is hyping up vidal yes he is a good player and has experience in the champions league but was a liability for juve i'd much prefer marchiesio.

also as a striker why not try and get icardi or immobile they are cheaper options and younger with a lot of potential


1.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 14:25:54
Icardi is unavailable for transfer (which the Ed has stated countless times) and as for Immobile, well, he is just pure rotten.


2.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 14:41:30
I'd also prefer an established Striker to come in and give Wilson who is even younger and has even more potential then those two a chance in the first team squad.


3.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 14:47:31
I'm guessing you're basing this off of one game against one of the best teams ever ay Gaz?


4.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 15:36:25
What I liked about Vidal in the Barcelona game was that he got stuck in. He made it harder for the opponents to dwell on the ball, and contributed to what was a game that hung in the balance until Barca's second. In the end the difference in the teams was Barca's formidable front three.

Going back to the second game against RM I thought he, rather than Pogba, was the midfield driving force.

If he played with that heart and tenaciousness in the EPL he would be an asset, and compared to the lesser quality of opposition would almost certainly shine. We could use him.


5.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 16:01:37
vidal was a liability because of the amount of challenges he was making whilst being on a yellow, but how many players in our current squad are willing to make all the challenges vidal made?

we are crying out for a midfielder that likes to do what vidal does not one of our midfielder's do the dirty stuff and are willing to make challenges often enough.

its all well and good having a nice bunch of nice playing players, but vidal would add a bit of grit and steal that we need when we come across teams more physical.


6.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 16:32:50
immobile is a very good player with a lot of potential aswell -JMB

I think wilson as good as it is to train with the first team should maybe get loaned to a prem team to get regualer games in the prem but agree he has a lot to give united - Ports

No i'm basing this on the fact that he had a job to do for juve and he didn't do it and every time I've watched them he has chased around after the ball. much better centre midfeilders out there that can do just as good a job as him and be cheaper. Schneiderlin for one would do better and would be cheaper to. or the likes of Clement Grenier, Ezequiel Cirigliano, Younes Belhanda, Victor Wanyama.

what you also have to realise is we are going to need atleast 2 centre mids as currently we look lost without carrick


7.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 16:47:12
i agree that we need a player willing to put his body on the line but if he had been sent off juve would have been ruined. There was a couple where i think the ref was lenient on him aswell. I just feel there are a lot of players that can do that job without the massive pricetag and wages

remember roy keane came from ireland and cost us pennies so we don't need to spend in excess of 30-40 million for vidal when we could spend 20 and get someone that is able to to that job


8.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 17:50:33
Roy Keane cost us a British record transfer fee when we signed him. hardly pennies


9.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 19:20:40
But at 3.25 million he gave most of his career to united. Vidal isn't worth breaking our new transfer record for and we will only get him for 3 or 4 years max. Getting a younger player that can do the same job woulf be more beneficial


10.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 19:51:47
Haha that is pure gold, Keane costing pennies and coming from Ireland? Signed from Forest mate


11.) 08 Jun 2015
08 Jun 2015 20:59:28
What are you talking about gaz? Roy Keane cost an arm and a leg at the time. Record fee we paid for him.


12.) 09 Jun 2015
09 Jun 2015 10:31:56
alright guys chill out :-)

all i'm saying is that we shouldn't pay 30-40 million for a player that will only give us 3 years or 4 years when there's players out there that can do that job just aswell and are younger.


13.) 09 Jun 2015
09 Jun 2015 12:27:23
If someone said to me you will win the league or champ league but have to pay 30 or 40 mil on 1 player every year and won't be able to use him again i say money well spent becasuse winning these competitions is how you grow and attract names.