Manchester United Banter Archive January 04 2018

 

Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.


04 Jan 2018 21:50:46
Hope everyone had a nice Christmas and New Year! Not a transfer rumour but a question regarding Mourinhos future, I know he has said he is happy to stay but I was just curious to what capacity United would look to extend his contract? Thanks in advance.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - I don’t understand the question.}

04 Jan 2018 22:12:59
Hi ed002, I know you said in your opinion if Mr Mourinho was offered an early exit in the summer he might be inclined to take it. Given his recent media statement regarding wanting to stay/ extend do you still think he wouldn't mind an early exit from his existing deal.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - He knows know that the interested sides have other targets. I would not pay any heed to what he says.}

04 Jan 2018 22:17:05
Thanks for the quick reply. A 4 year loyal reader.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 22:41:21
I say give him the deal and back him. Otherwise we are just playing around. Who else is there right now?

Agree3 Disagree0

05 Jan 2018 02:26:31
Surely you earn deals. Has Mourinho earned a new contract, for me - absolutely not. Does he want a new contract, doesn't look like it again to me. He gives off the appearance of a man having promised something many moons ago and now feeling obligated to fulfill it, despite regretting the day he made the oath over an expensive bottle of red.

Agree2 Disagree5

05 Jan 2018 07:23:46
Jose seems to be giving off 2 differing signals with his words atm, 1) he wants to stay for many years and 2) he is laying foundations for future managers suggesting he won’t be here long.
I am happy at José and his words of late, they suggest commitment and longer term planning, maybe he has had backing and promises from the board but does he deserve a new deal, it’s a tough one, he has brought us to a point where we are much improved in terms of league position, points, goals than at any time since Fergie left, any other season we would be in a real title fight but this isn’t a regular season, I think we need to step back and say well done pep and city, I said he'd not do it playing that way in the prem, I was very wrong, so I think Jose gets some unfair stick as what more can he do in terms of league position.
The sticking point seems to be the same as over the last 3 managers, they do not play the United way, we see glimpses of it but Jose is to pragmatic to let it play out a full 90 mins, but it begs the question who else is there out there atm?
Isn’t it true we are making strides forward and maybe just maybe sticking not twisting this time and building with more financial backing will be the way for us to get back to the top.
Jose moans but he is a great deflector. I believe he lives in a serviced apartment in the Lowry with a personal chef, a far cry from him living out of a suitcase in a hotel. Jose is the type who needs to feel wanted and valued, I think we should be more grateful for where he has brought us or maybe he will throw his toys out the pram, we knew this trait in him pre signing him.
On the other hand 4/ 5 years since Fergie left and we’ve not seen this united tradition of playing good football and I don’t think we will see this style under Jose, not for long periods anyway.
Fergie was the ideal, bought into our traditions, played the right way and had that abrasive us v them mentality, a mix of Jose and pep perhaps, there is nobody like that now, and unfortunately Jose’s job is to to win and get us back to the top, he’s won trophies and he’s improved us, so I guess he is doing his job well.
It’ll all play out this season/ summer but when push comes to shove I hope we stick by him and he by us and keep some stability at the club backing a proven winner.

Agree5 Disagree1

05 Jan 2018 07:56:04
Good post Welsh, I can’t warm to Jose but you lay out the position pretty accurately.

Agree0 Disagree0

05 Jan 2018 08:31:33
Totally agree Welsh - this is a freak season and without city being frankly ridiculous we would be challenging for the title which considering where we have been sin SAF left is astounding.

Agree0 Disagree0

05 Jan 2018 09:06:14
The point on stability cannot he underestimated. We need crave it as a club and our player recruitment of recent years shows just what a mess we have been. Jose wins things. Back him and enjoy the ride and we might just see some more consistent and enjoyable footy. To be honest, this season has been pretty decent in my opinion and we are travelling in the right direction albeit slowly.

Agree2 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 15:21:29
Chaps,

Hypothetical question: If Wilshere doesn't sort his contract at Arsenal, is he worth a punt on a free? Or is he simply another crock on our books?

Believable2 Unbelievable11

04 Jan 2018 15:42:39
With the lack of depth we have in midfield at the moment and the fact that Fellaini and Carrick will likely leave this summer I would consider it. Quality player on a free, if he's fit he is another option, if not then he is only costing wages. Plus helps to keep the number of British players in our squad up.

Agree6 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 15:55:56
Definite yes - can play and has a nasty streak in him too which I always appreciate.

Agree5 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 16:24:50
Has a nasty side but is unfortunately made of glass. Given we need 2-3 players and funds could be an issue I wouldn't rule it out. But i'd prefer to avoid crocks.

Agree4 Disagree1

04 Jan 2018 16:55:01
Yes let's sign wilshere and bale while we are at it, it would be like collecting set of pokemon cards, we already have the injury prone defenders those 2 will make it injury prone midfielder and winger all we need after that is a injury prone striker that would complete the set.

Agree4 Disagree5

04 Jan 2018 16:59:26
A fit jack wilshere is A very good player so yes if he was to stay fit .
Unfortunately like bale history tells us he probably will not.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 17:28:40
He'll probably go to Man City? Guadiola likes him and he's english and probably the best english midfielder we currently have on the ball.

Agree2 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 17:42:40
Got slated for this a few months back. Sign him up, when fits he’s great.

Agree4 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 17:58:26
Really good player before his long injuries. Always has his head up was telling my kids to watch him last night he always has his head up even running with the ball. If he plays at the level he did last night between now and the end of the season and proves himself then yes he would be an unbelievably good player to get for no transfer fee.
Highly doubtful and improbable He is an arsenal lad and if they were to lose ozil sanchez and one of their own Wilshere on free's and don't get cl football then Wenger should be run out of town.

Agree2 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 18:14:34
I don't know about injury prone but Nile Rangers now on a free.

Agree2 Disagree1

04 Jan 2018 22:25:25
Years ago, when Sydney was defending Cleverly every week, I used the discuss Wilshere with Stoner, an Arsenal fan. I like be Jack, I think he has incredible natural talent but sadly he doesn’t look after himself and he’s always injured. It’s like having a Ferrari that’s always in the garage. I love him but he’s never fit.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 23:22:24
As is his accompanying ankle monitor - 2 for 1 - Bargain.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 14:16:52
If we are looking for a DM that can also add to attacks, that knows the premier league and has performed well in Europe to take some of the pressure off Matic how about Steven N'Zonzi?

We need to play a midfield 3 with Pogba on the left.

I would then make arsenal a good offer for Ozil to add some creativity.

How about offering arsenal miki in exchange for Ozil? Miki is a Wenger type player.

We need a back up LB and RB, but I don't see the quality we would want being available. I don't want rose. What is the point in having 2 injury prone lb's?

Believable1 Unbelievable4

04 Jan 2018 14:48:54
I don't see why we need ozil. Good player, but we have pogba for creativity once we have a third midfielder to unleash him, so ozil becomes unnecessary.

Far better to get a cm and a right forward imo.

Agree6 Disagree5

04 Jan 2018 16:04:10
I think you need balance down the right. If the cm sits you don’t want to be predictable, I. e, the opposition know you are always going to attack down the left through pogba. Also having two creative players means you have cover.

Agree2 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 16:43:41
Well if ozil can be the third cm that works fine, but I can't see pogba and ozil being happy as being cover for each other.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 18:00:07
Agree red ozil could not play that 3rd central midfielder. He could easily play from right or left of the front 3 in a 433.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 18:01:03
How about pogba left, Matic or N’Zonzi centre and Ozil right, with pogba and Ozil switching position.

They are also available as squad depth in case one is banned or injured. That is what I meant by cover.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 18:37:28
Ken, would ozil as a right forward not just be another square peg?

Don't get me wrong, I'd happily have him, but just not sure how he fits in.

We'd need to change formation to get him and pogba on the pitch together.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 18:51:40
Not sure red d its where he has played the majority of his career.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 21:41:12
I thought he was central and predominantly a no 10.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 21:44:08
Quote from the man himself in October 2017:

Everyone knows my favourite position is the playmaker, the No.10, at the moment the coach plays me on the right and it’s a thing I need to accept and to show my quality in that position.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 22:49:11
N’zonzi is nowhere near The quality we need. We’ve bought enough tosh these last few years.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 23:32:10
I suggest you do some research Eric, N’Zonzi has been a revelation in Spain. His passing stats are up there, so much so that last season the only players with better passing stats in Europe were Verratti, Thiago Alcantara, Julian Weigl and David Alaba had better stats. Not bad company.

Aledgedly Barcelona, Juventus, arsenal and city were keen on him in the summer which lead to Sevilla increasing his buyout clause in a new contract.

I accept he may not be everyone’s cup of tea, but I think he would be an upgrade on the wig who wants to jump ship. If not him who do you see as a viable solution in a José team?

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 12:13:58
Any substance to United and Jose in talks to extend his deal at United Ed?

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - I have no idea, sorry.}

04 Jan 2018 14:52:02
No worries Ed, thanks.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 11:53:47
Nice and simple:

Let's assume he's attainable.

Aubameyang (13 League Goals in 15 Starts this season) but having issue's with Dortmund

Would you take him for us?

Believable0 Unbelievable3

{Ed004's Note - No we don't need a striker and his finishing is very erratic}

04 Jan 2018 12:19:17
Nope, he causes a few issues off the pitch and as Ed004 has said he is very erratic and we don't really need a striker and certainly not one who likes to play on the shoulder and run in behind as we have Martial and Rashford who like to do that and Jose doesn't like to play them as strikers.

Agree2 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 12:27:02
Cheers for the reply Ed.

Does he not play off the wing as a wide forward tho?

He's lightening quick and think he'd be a better option than Rash or Jesse behind Lukaku (I only mention Rash as I think he's destined to play as a number 9)

His record last 3 seasons is quality - 21 in 23 this season, 40 in 46 last year and 39 in 49 season before that.

I personally think he's a better option than what we have and would improve our squad, who else is banging in goals at that rate for us.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed004's Note - Mkhitaryan also produced figures as impressive as Aubameyangs at Dortmund and he has struggled massively here. If Lukaku had not been signed I would probably be all for signing him but there is no point signing another striker to play him out wide. Aubameyang has been Dortmunds main striker since Lewandowski left}

04 Jan 2018 12:50:17
No hrs got an attitude like an x factor winner. We need less divas and shirkers.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 14:00:39
Over the last few seasons I've learnt one thing that never buy a player from Dortmund. There's a 90% chance he'll fail at your club. They've got a particular style of play which suits these players and these guys just don't make the cut once they go somewhere else. From Sahin to Mkhitaryan there are plenty of examples. Moreover Dortmund's twitter game is lit. Their announcements of their players leaving just gives you the chuckles.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 13:23:14
or just play Martial as a CF and buy a winger.

Agree3 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 14:37:52
Its a good point sailor I'm trying to think of someone who's left Dortmund in the last 5 seasons and done well elsewhere. Even the guy managed them hasn't as well as several players.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 15:08:23
Great point Sailor. It's like some sort of curse their players have once they leave, I remember when we signed Kagawa I was delighted and thought he'd bring a whole new dynamic to our team but again never worked out.

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 15:45:44
Hummels and Lewandowski are about the only ones. Gotze, Sahin, Kagawa, Mkhitaryan have all struggled. It's hard to judge Gundogan as he just hasn't been fit long enough to work out if he can have a similar impact as to what he had at Dortmund.

There might be a pattern where No.10's leaving Dortmund struggle.

Agree2 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 09:15:48
Rumours this morning that Jose is unhappy and jetting to and from London whilst still living in a hotel in Manchester. Interestingly, Guardiola has bought an apartment in Manchester, not sure where his family are but I would have thought an apartment was a better bet than a soulless hotel.

Love him or loathe him it seems things are progressing, Jose unhappy with our investment, owners unhappy with his comments, Jose not happy in Manchester. I guess a good run of a few wins might make everything seem different but there does seem to be a public game of chess being played right now.

I still think we will finish 2nd (sorry Stand) with a chance of a Cup and with the right investment will continue to progress. However I do wish all the noise and hullabaloo would go away and Jose would lighten up a tad.

Believable13 Unbelievable3

04 Jan 2018 09:49:43
Tony, This is one of the reasons I was never sold on Mourinho. He brings the circus with him everywhere he goes. He is constantly posturing and looking for fights.
Things are now starting to come to a head. I could understand him living in the hotel to start with, even this season. If his family aren’t going to join him as his kids are settled and in education then I understand why he wouldn’t want to buy a place. It makes financial sense. However, I also agree that it must be tiring and straining on him to not be with his family and to not have a place of his own. I can see why that would make him unhappy.
Jose also has one of the biggests ego’s in world football, and the idea that not every member of the board wanted him will surely grate on him. Maybe because of that he feels he isn’t getting the backing he feels he deserves. Even though he has spent 295 - 310m in 18 months.
He has an ongoing feud with Pep which I’m sure is eating him up inside with how well Pep and City are doing at the moment. I expect a lot of the tension in his press conferences possibly comes from his view that the press “love” Pep. Sort of the friends of his enemy are also his enemies.
I think we are seeing the beginning of the end with Jose sadly, as even though I was never a fan of signing him and can still appreciate what he has done for us.
For me though things are starting to turn a bit sour.

Agree12 Disagree3

04 Jan 2018 11:33:28
If your board do not support you or have less ambition then it will be a problem

Perhaps the board will get rid, much to the delight of some, and appoint someone with less ambition who won’t push or ask for money.

Perhaps the friction is due to differing levels of ambition and if that is the case we should be very concerned. If Jose leaves I won’t believe any family type reasons but would be concerned that it does confirm our concerns about our own boards ambition.

I do not blame Jose for pushing, he isn’t a long term appointment, he comes in and wants to win, needs support to do it. For too long we have drifted never really making a concerted effort to knock Barcelona or Madrid off their perch, just the Scousers.

The board need to back Jose or answer what their real goals and ambitions are.

Agree5 Disagree14

04 Jan 2018 11:40:25
Jose has been backed, but some of his signings don't suit his system/ have been poor and inconsistency compared to Pep.

Agree6 Disagree8

04 Jan 2018 12:06:26
Couldn't agree more Redman. We bought 3 players and he desperately wanted a winger and left back. But the owners and their puppet, Woodward, argued over prices.
The owners are more interested in money than keeping the football side up to scratch.
I'm not a big mourinho fan. But if his ambition is not matched by the owners, then God help us.

Agree3 Disagree4

04 Jan 2018 12:14:39
Red Man, Only Pep at City has spent more money in the same time frame than Jose has, ever in world football. Being the second most financially backed manager of all time hardly sounds like he isn't being backed does it?

For me the timing is off.
January is notorious for being a tough window to buy in. Very few January signings do well and even fewer make a difference immediately. In the last 25 years only Evra and Vidic have really done well for us out of our January signings and both took until the start of the next season to truly start to do well. The league is in reality gone which leaves the UCL and the FA cup as our best hopes of winning something this season. Even if we ignore the fact that most January signings don’t do well until the following season we also have to contend with most potential top signings will be cup tied for at least one of these competitions.

So why pick a fight with the board now? If he’s lucky the board will give in and he will spend a January premium signing an at best above average player who is unlikely to make any difference to this season. If he was picking this fight in the build up to the summer transfer window I could understand it more, to do so now doesn’t make much sense.

For me it feels more like he is just putting it out there that he isn’t very happy at our club, and to do so just as we approach a transfer window when his agent will likely be meeting with many of the people in charge of those other top clubs seems like he is fishing for interest.

I know you're an ardent supporter of Jose, but does a leopard change its spots?
Jose has always looked out for himself, case in point when winning the Europa league with us last summer he tried to make it all about HIM winning a “treble” rather than OUR club winning the one trophy missing from our set, or the players turning a poor season into a winning one.

If Jose is picking a fight with the board it is because it is in Jose’s interest and not the clubs or the fans. Yes the Glazers have allowed the club to slide with a lack of investment, but under Jose and to an extent under LvG the owners have backed the managers with many signings including breaking the club record signing 3 potentially 4 times (if we end up paying the 15m in add ons in Lukaku’s contract) and the world transfer record once.

Agree13 Disagree3

04 Jan 2018 12:46:30
Shappy

Actually I am not Jose’s biggest fan, I wanted Pep after Lvg but I wanted someone with burning ambition, someone who wants the club to be at the very top not just competing

If Jose wants to put us at the top of world football he might do it for himself but so what if it gets us there. I have had to go into businesses to introduce a step change with the aim of making them the best in class. I was driven by my own ambition to get them there but so what if it got them there

Too many maintain this fancy ideal about how nice managers should be and how much money we spend, whilst Madrid and Barcelona win European cups. We finally get a manager who is probably more driven than SAF to win those trophies but could replace him with someone less ambitious and less demanding yet will keep a few happy with pretty football

When we don’t win the European cup for years, again, there can be no complaints.

Agree4 Disagree10

04 Jan 2018 12:46:54
Shappy, could it he is aware of that he is aware of the issues facing new signings and with the league all but gone wants to get some of his summer targets in now so they have a bedding in period with less pressure than normal as realistically we are not expected to challenge for the Champions League this year.

Agree2 Disagree3

04 Jan 2018 12:51:58
Just for the sake of an argument or opinion.

Who do you want as the manager if Mou was to leave at the end of the season?

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 12:57:23
Yes the club has spent a lot of money but as someone said above most signings don't fit the system. So are they Jose's signings? I don't see him signing square pegs.

Regards the owners to quote someone else its like the owners are trying to build a Ferrari but by buying cheap parts an then putting it out on the race track with a cautious driver to try and grab whatever prize pot he can.

And James Ducker of the telegraph says Jose an agent have been talking about a new contract for the last month.

Agree2 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 13:04:13
Its not just about the money that has been spent, look at the players that have been let go. To buy the best players, you pay the premium price and we have done that in the past 2 summers. But just look at the current squad and how many of them would you actually want to stay at the club. Smalling, Rojo, Shaw, Blind, Darmian? that's the entire defence that can be bettered. Move into the Midfield, If we leave out Pogba and Matic, clearly Fellaini wants to leave. Then you have an aging Carrick. Herrera who has gone backwards this season and then a youngster in McTominay. How can you think of competing with the best with these players? In the attack, yes we have Zlatan (injured), Lukaku, Martial and Rashford (I am not convinced on him), Mkhitaryan and Mata. Lukaku has lacked service because of the issues in MF and thus he has struggled. Martial although a better footballer than the other strikers is inconsistent but still makes things happen. Mkhitaryan, I really don’t know what went wrong with him and he wasn’t a Jose signing, he was already through the front doors, Jose just stamped it. So, even with the money spent you need to look at the quality of the players at your disposal before you start to compare yourself with that City squad and their football.

Agree3 Disagree6

04 Jan 2018 13:52:25
And I’ve now just heard on the radio we are talking to him about an extension. Who’d have thought?

Agree1 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 14:22:27
Very good posts redman, I am in agreement with you. Jose is our 4th manager since Fergie has left.

No matter what you think of Jose, there is certain common denominators here for me, it is the board and the players themselves.

The board have obviously made big mistakes in acquisitions and also in how they run certain elements of the club. There are also quite a few players who have been there for years now and who have consistently not produce a level of football that is required for a club like United.

The board need to give Jose what he wants and needs, because his history tells us that he will win a lot of trophies. And the players need to buck up their ideas and work harder because they are responsible for their own poor performances. We can't continuously blame each manager we have for we know whoever comes after Jose, if this doesn't work out, will also be blamed.

By the way, I think Jose's latest press conference was very good.

Agree3 Disagree8

04 Jan 2018 14:40:17
Another good point. How many of the current squad is actually good enough?

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 15:13:06
Red man, it all takes time though. Winning UCL titles are a combination of having a great team, timing and luck. If it all comes together then you have a great chance of winning it. First you have to build the team. You can’t go signing 18 players in one summer.
I always thought the mark of a good manager was their ability to get the best out of what they have.

When you’ve gone into those businesses to get them to the top did you sack all the staff overnight? Course not, I suspect you wouldn’t have been allowed. I’m sure you’ll have brought in a few new people, created new role and removed others. But the majority of it will have likely been getting the most out of what you had.

When Sir Alex built his first great team he didn’t just sell the whole team and bought new. He moved some on, he brought a few key players in and he promoted from within. Beyond that he he made sure he got the maximum out of what he had.

Jose is a great manager when it comes to winning things, yet his record with improving players is very patchy. That is one of the reasons he struggles with youngsters, he just isn’t that good at improving players so they stagnate and remain at the same level as when they step up into the first team.

I personally think this team is better than the one Sir Alex won his last title with, Sir Alex just got more out of it.

Real Madrid had a Galactico policy and thought they could buy titles, yet they won very little for it. Barcelona on the other hand focused on doing things their way, they brought young players up from the academy and they ended up with possibly the greatest team of all time. Man for man it might not have been better than Real Madrids, but on the pitch they were miles apart.

12daysofhermida, I doubt it. Mourinho doesn’t tend to think that far ahead. We didn’t make any signings last January when we were in a far worse position than this, unless the chance to sign one of our top targets at a non inflated price presents itself in January then I doubt we will make a signing. Surely Mourinho must be aware of that, he didn’t make these comments last year when our need was greater. So why now?

Mort, we haven’t been buying cheap players under Mourinho. Mkhitaryan is the cheapest at 26m, while he was the Bundesliga player of the year. We only got him for 26m because he was in the final year of his contract otherwise he would likely have cost 30-40m. We aren’t buying cheap players these days.

Shan, all those players are internationals, and all for historically top international teams. Rojo has played in 3 international cup finals, Darmian plays for Italy and Blind for the Netherlands. Shaw was the most expensive teenager for a few years.
I actually don’t think there are that many great defenders anywhere in the world atm. Stones and Otamendi aren’t considered world class players, yet Pep has them playing like they are.

Wes Brown, Phil Neville, David May, John O’Shea. None of these guys were world class, yet Sir Alex got them doing a great job when called upon. Maybe Mourinho just isn’t that good a manager as to be able to lift players and get them playing better?

Hardly surprising Tony, maybe that was his game all along, he just wanted more money. Maybe we should increase the wage of the highest paid manager in the league. That way he might be able to afford to rent an apartment. Lol.

Raghav, I wouldn’t pretend to know who is best. For a start I would want to interview potential candidates as well as research them and their methods. Off the top of my head though I would consider Allegri, Sarri, Pochettino, Schmidt and Marcelino. Some young managers and a couple who aren’t. What is important though is that they understand our club and what is expected of a Manchester United manager.

Agree10 Disagree1

04 Jan 2018 15:17:24
Mort, was it 7 the other week that started a match that played under Fergie? I think Neville said it. That's 3 quarters of the squad. That's suggest that signings during moyes and LVG weren't good enough and we need more investment.

Agree1 Disagree4

04 Jan 2018 16:02:21
Shappy, what is cheap in the footballing world when it comes to man United. All relative to what the player can bring commercially. 26 million I would imagine is cheap for United but wouldn't be for say Bournemouth. There are different levels to what we can afford and what players we should be buying. They all come with different price tags when man United are trying to buy them.

Agree0 Disagree4

04 Jan 2018 16:06:36
Shappy i respect your opinion but being an international doesn't make you a better player. And how long was SAF at the helm of the club when he was developing the players? And yet Jose is being judged in 18 months? And the football has moved on now. Its a results oriented business, not a sport anymore. Pep hasn't developed the defenders you said, its only the fact that the others in front of them are playing so well that it papers over their dodgy defence. The only one that i say is playing better is Sterling. Then we have Lingard who is developing well under Jose. We need a few more windows to get the team sorted. A few have said that only City has spent more than us. Reminder that its only City that are ahead of us in the table.

Also someone said that Manager needs to get the best out of the available players. Does it cross your minds that may be he is doing that. How many of the players have a winning mentality in the current squad. Our squad lacks that final quality to be at the top. May be that's why our manager is calling out the owners to gdt that in.

Agree2 Disagree4

04 Jan 2018 16:38:47
Shan, this side has won three major trophies in the last 2 years. So I expect several of the players have a winning mentality. Besides isn't it supposed to be part of a managers job to create that mentality within a squad.

Agree5 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 17:52:33
But Shan. Jose doesn't develop players 😉.

Agree0 Disagree4

04 Jan 2018 18:04:33
Shappy darmian plays for the worst italy team seen for 80 years.
Blind plays for the worst Dutch team for 40 years not a great cv booster.

I take your point they are decent players of course they are but they have not excelled at united and they never will so move them on.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 20:06:59
Shappy

It does usually take time to win UCL titles, but we have a manager who has done it several times and didn’t take that long to get his team in shape. No one is suggesting 18 players in one summer, but we would be suggesting 3 or 4 of which several must be top level.

You said you thought the mark of a good manager was their ability to get the best out of what they have. The days of Brian Clough have gone, SAF is probably the last great motivator. However both only won 2 UCLs and how many chances did SAF have? Did he really get the best out of what he had, or if he was so good should he have been able to take the next step and dominated Europe?

SAF got more out of his final team for numerous reasons, not least momentum, fear and note City now have a far better team than SAF faced.

I note your comment about Madrid, but how many UCL titles overall and how many in recent years? They are aggressive and aim to dominate in Europe, have a mindset to win, we have just played at it.

What is expected of a Manchester United Manager? Winning, that’s what, nice football if they can but winning is the aim. You name people like Pochettino, who I like, but he hasn’t won anything. Right now the board need to look at Joses plans and decide if they want to support him. If they don’t why should he stay?

Agree0 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 21:07:33
Maybe Jose can't get anymore out some of these players. I have been on this site the last few years and have seen smalling slated over and over as not good enough and people expect Jose to get more out of him? I think we are can all agree that there are a few in this squad that aren't good enough and they will be sold once new faces are brought in.

I saw that people were applauding pep for what he did last season, implementing his style and not worrying about results and sorting his squad out. I hate to imagine the reaction if Jose did that, we finished lower than 6th and didn't win the league cup or Europa league. As some have said, it's a results business and Jose gets results.

So Jose has signed 7 players since he came to the club and it has come out that apparently bailly and mhktaryan weren't jose's signings. If that is the case then who is making these decisions? As far as I'm aware, we don't have a director of football which is the only other person I would expect to sign players apart from the manager, I may be wrong though.

On jose's demeanour, he is treated poorly by the press and media, of course he brings a lot of it on himself but I think there is a clear double standard with how he is treated compared to some of the other managers. For example, klopp screams in the linesmans face and instead of getting sent to the stands, is applauded for his passion, if you feel you are getting treated differently to the other managers, you are not going to waltz into your press conference and be happy.

Does anybody know roughly how much of their own money the glazers have put into the club and how much they have taken out as this will show the massive difference in our owners as city's have invested soo much of their own money on over the years already. They also don't mind overpaying on players if that is want pep wants. Apparently Jose really wanted perisic, then go get him, we aren't a selling club so don't worry about their sell on value later on

I saw someone say they want Allegri, he was suppose to be in charge this season from memory but that was obviously screwed up by the supporter base. If Jose is backed properly he will get results, as he has proved during his career.

Agree2 Disagree1

04 Jan 2018 21:29:53
Darv

Good points

Another question is how much money has been wasted on funding the borrowing and what we could have done with it, such as buying world class players?

Agree0 Disagree1

{Ed002's Note - You are kidding right?}

04 Jan 2018 22:08:11
Ed002

I am not sure what you mean? There are different estimates as to the cost of the borrowing, but interest, charges and restructuring of the borrowing, the bond issue over many years will come to a very substantial sum.

Agree0 Disagree1

{Ed002's Note - I guess you don’t understand how the money was used.}

04 Jan 2018 22:23:10
Do you mean the borrowing?

The Glazers used loans to buy the club, the majority were then secured against the club, initially interest payments of £60m a year. They refinanced with a bond issue on which they had to pay interest. I am not aware the borrowing was used for anything other than enabling the leveraged buy out.

Agree0 Disagree1

{Ed002's Note - you seem to be stuck on half a story.}

05 Jan 2018 08:05:31
Shappy:

Great post, I couldn't agree more with what you wrote.

I think Jose needs to get a little bit more out of the players and make average fringe/ squad players, capable of playing in the starting 11, if the need arises.

I would look at Allegri too, maybe because he stays out of the spotlight and his team does most of the talking and also because he was part of the plan, after LVG (not too sure, but I think he was supposed to come, had LVG stayed for the entire duration) .

With the team, I personally feel that we lack quality wingers. Obviously we need two, Rashford and Martial, even if they are inverted wingers in the current system, do not have the quality or consistency to play that role. Now, whether they can work on it or if it's more of temporary thing, I don't know.

Even if we can't invest in 2, we should definitely try and get 1. Only coz, we might be able to get the best out of Lukaku, for the remainder of the season.


Shan:

You mention that Jose is getting the max out of the players that he has and I think that might be true for certain players, but if that is the case, then isn't it better to ship them out and invest the money into new recruitments?

I firmly believe that Jose asking the board to back him up financially is a fair call. Perisic comes to mind and who knows, there might be a few more who were wanted by Jose and the board didn't sanction the money. Why they didn't sanction is another story altogether.

You're right, Otamendi and Stones aren't world class players, in fact, only Kompany, when fit, can be considered as a good defender in the City squad. The one thing Pep has done, is that he's got them playing the football that he wants to play and they are forced to play that way. I think that is where the fundamental problem is. Jose and United don't have an identity when it comes to the kind of football do they want to play. Do they play short passes, or are the hoofing the ball upfield, nobody knows. From what I see, tactics and game plans are decided on a game to game basis. That's good, teams need to prepare for each opposition, but, the identity shouldn't change.

Red Man:

I may be wrong here, but I think the reason why a lot of us posters talk about Pochettino is because we all admire the way his teams play. The movement, the drive, the continuity, the flow, is all good to watch. Maybe, we want a manager who plays football that is similar to that.

Seeing the Arsenal Vs Chelsea game I was thinking to myself, that if Arsenal can play that way against Chelsea, then why can't we? Arsenal don't have a better squad than us,
but they took the game to the Blues and should have won. Maybe, our team needs the belief, that they can win matches and trust their individual abilities.


Darv:

You're spot on, mate. I genuinely think Mou at times, is treated unfairly by the media and the press. Klopp, Conte, Pep all of them love to be on the sidelines and jump and up down as if the won the world cup everytime their team scores. For them, it might be their way of showing the passion they have, but Mou not jumping doesn't show that he isn't passionate.


Just to end things:

We are playing a mix type of football. We are good on days (Everton, I missed it, but I read we were good that day) and some days we are a pain to watch. Jose needs to give some of the players some creative freedom and should be backed by the club hierarchy, at least for the next couple of windows and then see what can do be done. because our team needs stability and a sense of direction.

Agree0 Disagree0

05 Jan 2018 06:40:09
Good Morning Ed

Unless all the financial analysts missed where the Glazers used the loans to invest in the business I don’t see how in any way the debt could be good for the club. The costs and interest etc would have been a massive burden over a long period as well. I can only assume you mean the other half of the story is the commercial acumen the owners brought to the club to increase its turnover?

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - No. The whole matter has been dealt with at very great length before. Why are you bringing this up now?}

05 Jan 2018 09:53:27
Well posted Raghav. I also think on similar lines where the players should be offloaded to fund new ones. But then again the likes of Smalling won't get too much in terms of their price while the players we look for are premium players and there lies the problem. We need funding from the Glazers and Mourinho is right in demanding it.

Agree0 Disagree0

05 Jan 2018 10:51:26
Agreed, a few of our players won't get too much, but then, over the last few years, haven't we been selling players for cheap anyway?

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 07:25:32
Ed 002. Any chance of a sharkopod? Sorry for bothering.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

{Ed002's Note - You have already had one.}

04 Jan 2018 09:03:48
Crap. Sorry, I tried finding it, but couldn't. You think you can share the link again? If that's okay?

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed002's Note - I have no idea about the link, sorry. Maybe someone else can help - I would have thought the search function would find it.}

04 Jan 2018 11:44:10
Search "Sharkopod" then scroll down until you get to a post from the 16th of November. Just listened to it again and Ed002 states several times; If Jose is coach in the summer.

Sharkopod 18

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 12:52:44
Perfect! Thanks a ton, mate!

I was scrolling through the search field. Crossed that date too. Must have missed it. Thank you, once again.

Agree0 Disagree0

Premier League Match Preview Thursday 4th January 2018

04 Jan 2018 05:45:18
{Ed's Note - we have posted a new article entitled, Premier League Match Preview Thursday 4th January 2018

Believable0 Unbelievable0

04 Jan 2018 01:06:48
Been laid up with a acl tear so going to comment on a few points.
Don't judge a player on assist, dear me . How many assist did kean get.
Maradona scored the best goal I have ever seen, who passed him the ball?
On the other hand Rooney had more assist than any other unitedcolayer in his last 3 season.
So do judge a player in assist.
2 . Don't judge a player on what he wins Kane is a great player even if he wins nothing .
3.scholess knows more than you.

Believable2 Unbelievable5

04 Jan 2018 05:58:03
Agreed with the first two. Third one I agree with him often, but he doesn't know more than me!

Hope you heal well mate.

Agree0 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 07:30:53
Jred who are the truly great players who won nothing all through their career?
It's not the only criteria to judge a player but it's an important criteria.

Agree4 Disagree0

04 Jan 2018 09:07:26
I thought Jose’s comments on Scholes earning less than Pogba were crass. Scholes had plenty of offers but as he has said many times his heart belonged to United and he never wanted to go anywhere else. He may or may not be a crap pundit but that comment from Jose sums him up: he lacks class and humility.

Agree4 Disagree2

04 Jan 2018 16:08:30
Yeah I didn't get that AJH. Maybe he is looking for a reaction. I'm sure scholes is very well off financially. But I don't know why he reached for that assumption. he was right to defend pogba but bringing that into it, I don't know why.

Agree1 Disagree1

04 Jan 2018 17:03:18
Hope your knee gets better soon mate.

Agree0 Disagree0