Manchester United Banter Archive October 09 2018

09 Oct 2018 14:40:24
With Monaco potentially sacking Louis litt (Jardim) would he be an option to replace mourinho should he leave?

09 Oct 2018 15:24:45
Would love jardim I think he’s a very good manager. Near on impossible job with his best players being sold every year for big profits. He beat PSG to the title a few years ago so has trophy credentials.

09 Oct 2018 15:34:27
wouldnt mind seeing the 4-4-2 formation at old trafford.

09 Oct 2018 15:23:51
Any of the Ed's know if Jardim is getting sacked? And i think he would be an excellent replacement, makes sense especially if Monaco get rid of him as French media is reporting. But we'd need a DOF if he was to come in.

{Ed002's Note - You are on the wrong page, this is the Manchester United page.}

10 Oct 2018 08:22:31
I’d like him so that when he turns out useless you lot will stop banging on about him.

10 Oct 2018 15:06:25
You're that sure FZZ? Stupidest thing i've ever seen on this page, want a possible manager to fail at the club so we stop banging on about him, makes sense.

10 Oct 2018 17:51:10
I would love to see the Prem get Lit Up!

10 Oct 2018 18:27:54
Think you missed the point scholes as usual. And ill spell it out for you, he's over rated. There you go.

He has won nothing, and his current side sit 18th in the table. You think we are going to go for a manager like this?

10 Oct 2018 19:26:02
Think you need to look up jardim again FZZ. He won Ligue 1 2 years ago. Against the financial might of PSG that was an incredible experience. He also knocked out pep’s city in the champions league and reached the semis. He is a very talented young manager. Is it a risk to appoint him on the back of a poor season? Sure. But we’ve been down the experienced route of a manager with trophy credentials. Jardim would most probably get more out of the attacking player. One final point, Klopp in his final season almost got Dortmund relegated. Yet he walked into the Liverpool job and has done a very good job since being there. I doubt Liverpool had reservations that Klopp was a poor manager because of 1 poor season. Let’s not be a prisoner of the moment and forget about the good that jardim has done. Jardim is very highly rated and would be a great fit for united, provided he has a good director of football to work with.

10 Oct 2018 21:26:06
Park,

Yes he won against the "might" of PSG that just got played off the park by Liverpool. Liverpool are in the same league as little and lonely Leicester.
Let me ask you who had the better achievement, Ranieri or Jardim? Shall we go for Claudio as well?

They beat city on away goals drew 6-6. Klopp finished 7th Park, no achievement no, but its not close to being relegated.

10 Oct 2018 22:25:10
FZZ compare the financial backing of Monaco and PSG. There front three alone costs more than monaco’s Whole squad. Liverpool as well are on a different level in terms of stature of club than Monaco. Not sure how you can even compare the two. It’s apples and oranges really. Just a bit of snobbery tbh looking down on winning the French league with a team that is not PSG.

And of course I don’t want Ranieri, nor am I taking away from him his miracle of a title win at Leicester. I’m not basing my opinion on jardim purely winning the league. There is so much more to him which makes him an attractive fit for united. He plays attractive football and has a track record of developing young talent (James, Bernardo Silva, martial, mbappe, Mendy and so on) . Is this not in keeping with the traditions of our club? Do we not aim to promote from within and develop potential into work class talent? Jardim ticks a lot of boxes for the sort of manager we should be employing at our club. He is young enough to imprint his philosophy on the club as well as to grow and be moulded by the values and traditions of united. Yes he has had a poor season this year, but I seem to remember we hired a certain manager off the back of a terrible season. Not sure why the idea of jardim is so outrageous to you.

11 Oct 2018 01:08:12
Says i've missed the point but goes on to say he's won nothing. Brilliant.

09 Oct 2018 09:32:06
Is Herrera career at Manchester United over?

Why he ins't playing more regularly?

With so many players under performing why not use more of Fred, Pereira and Herrera?

If he leaves I hope he finds a great club, he's very professional and cool guy.

09 Oct 2018 09:42:54
Herrera is a squad player so is used accordingly I guess. The lad gives his all when he does play and seem to love the club and we do need players of that kind, it’s not all about big names as Pogba has proven, I known hich one i'd prefer in my team, but that’s how far we are away, Herrera probably is a very good squad player yet he’s more effective than our so called star names.

09 Oct 2018 10:06:57
He has been injured in recent weeks and so that is why he has not figured.

A squad player but if fit should probably get more game time while Matic is so poor.

09 Oct 2018 12:15:42
I’ve always felt Herrera is a more consistent performer than many of our other midfield players, but he’s under 6ft, so can't expect him to be first choice. I think Fred will find himself in the same predicament.

09 Oct 2018 19:05:07
Although we don’t know the reasons it is concerning that we spend over £50M on a midfielder in the summer and then he seems to spend a large amount of time on the bench.

I thought in recent games his speed and energy was much needed in the midfield. I was crying out for him against Valencia.

Don’t know how we expect players to bed in when we don’t give them game time.

Just very frustrating feel that Dalot and Fred could both play more with how poor we have been playing.

09 Oct 2018 19:56:53
Danny, Herrera if exactly 6ft. Smlow Motion; I'd love to see a midfield of Fred, Pereira and Herrera. Plenty of pass and move with those three.

09 Oct 2018 20:35:51
That’s only in heels, he’s 5 11 in his flats.

09 Oct 2018 20:35:51
That’s only in heels, he’s 5 11 in his flats.