24 Feb 2012 18:33:01
Am a good fan of Pogba but am sick and tired of what i always hear about him day in and day out.I think is enough.Lets forget about him if he is not committed and give other starlets who are ready to render their service to the club.The likes of Pattruci,Lingard,the Keans and others are all good.They should be given the opportunity if they are only ready to be with the spirit of the red devil.Pogba is talented and there is no doubt about that.He should be released if he want to leave.All the same hope he will make a big U-turn one day after his depature.But the question is will you wellcome him if this happens?
Believable9
Unbelievable11
Have we all forgot about robbie brady,hes playing great on loan at hull and really wants to play 4 us not like some other youngsters.
Agree0
Disagree0
24 Feb 2012 18:18:05
{Ed022's note - brand new player profile on Nico Gaitan of Benfica that the likes of Manchester United have been linked with in recent times. www.player-profiles.co.uk - thanks all.}
Believable2
Unbelievable7
24 Feb 2012 17:45:46
People need to trust SAF on these matters regarding younger players, he sees these players each day. They will offer and negotiate whatever he's worth. If he's getting bad advice and leaves essentially because of money from somewhere else, then so be it.
It will be with regret but the great clubs remain others come and go. But no one had really heard of him before and we haven't paid out loads for him. If he's stays good and we can move on if not someone else will take his place. But again Italian clubs are generally not reliable (adjust where needed ed) on what they are supposed to pay players and clubs.
Alot of agents are aware of this so again the question's should be asked of the advice he is receiving, because a move at a young age (of someone who is clearly valued) away from a club like ours is certainly not in the players interest. Yet another example of how these agents need policing or regulating as its wrecking football now when it's go to this level. On the other hand who wouldn't at 18/19 have their head absolutely spinning at the prospect of (apparently) £22k-£35k a week. Again that's when you need good advice, normally your family is best, then ideally an agent working in "your" interests.
Supasub
Believable10
Unbelievable1
If i was a member of pogba's family I would tell him to move to Juve. We bought him as a 16 year old, so he has no real affection for the club; and we aren't playing him, when our midfield is screaming out for an exciting young talent like him. I'm sure fergie does know best, however if he really is as good as everyone says then it would be best for him to move to a good, resurgent club who are playing good football, where he will get played week in-week out, no matter what he's being paid.
Jaxer
Agree0
Disagree0
24 Feb 2012 00:56:55
On the subject of wingers if we sold nani for 25million who would you replace him with considering we have some funds aswell so say 40million on a winger
i would pick one of
Di maria
Bale
Hazard
Lavezzi
or cheaper option of Giovinco or Muniain
personally i think bale would be overpriced, hazard may also cost too much but i like the look of giovinco hes small and agile same as muniain and wouldnt break the bank
Believable2
Unbelievable10
Di maria we need aleft footed player, and he easily can skin 2 or 3 players and racks up alot of assists
Agree0
Disagree0
There is not a winger in the world that is worth £15 million more than Nani. He's our second most creative player and our third most important player IMO. When you look at our team nowadays, other than Rooney who else would worry opponents more than Nani? I think the idea of getting rid of Nani is ludicrous and unfounded as he is apparently set to sign a new long term deal.
#ags 19
Agree0
Disagree0
Yeah, despite Nani's inconsistencies, he's one of our most dangerous players, and can be a game changer. I think getting rid of him would be a mistake.
Ruudinthemood
Agree0
Disagree0
What about the lad from Ajax think he is serbian Sulejmani he impressed me over both games on the left wing and would be allot cheaper? {Ed002's Note - MOTD fever by the sounds of it.}
Agree0
Disagree0
God help us if nani is that important to us he is playing crap and offering nothing at the moment we cant keep carrying him
johndenton
Agree0
Disagree0
On last night's performance I think Young is a candidate for selling.
Agree0
Disagree0
Johndenton: unbelievable how short some memories are.
Nani carried the whole clubs last season until he was burned out.
I don't see any winger I'd trade Nani for.
Give him a proper central midfield that can play him through.
90% of the times he gets the ball and has two players in front of him an no one around to play a 1-2 with.
Use his pace and play him through like berbatov did with Chicharito yesterday a couple of times.
Jonny8
Agree0
Disagree0
Sell nani hed be good at rugby as everything goes over the bar.
Hes had that many bad games an we wait for 1 in 10 good games
15m be good for nani
Agree0
Disagree0
Some of you people are mad! @johndenton, playing crap at the moment? You do realise that he's only just come back from an injury, he's played two games since, surely even you know it takes a few games to gain match fitness again. Nani has been fantastic at times this season, usually when he's not performing that well the whole team isn't either. As for Ashley Young, he too recently had a long spell on the sidelines so give them time, they both both show plenty of talent week in week out.
SAF was talking about how football fans have changed over the years, he said they've become more impatient. Guess he was talkin about people like you!
Ozwald
Agree0
Disagree0
Not at all ed02 havent got MOTD fever at all. I was just impressed with him over the two games?? And lets be honest we havent got 25+mill to spend on one player, we are 400+mill in debt. Hence why Giggs and Scholes are still playing. We might 1 or 2 players but I bet they wont come to 20mill together. WE ARE SKINT!! MOTD fever my A***. I go to OT regularly and Nani, Young, Park arnt good enough. If we could get 25+mil for Nani then we should take it. 1 good game every 7/8 doesnt make him a good player. {Ed001's Note - that is what is meant by MOTD fever mate, seeing a player have a good game and suddenly starting to suggest them as a signing.}
Agree0
Disagree0
I would keep Nani, if he were to go then i would want Bale to come in. But i really like Nani and we all should realise how good he is for us.
RedDevil19
Agree0
Disagree0
I don't rate Nani, I never have, and although his contribution to assists and goals last year were good, I hold him responsibly for the team playing poor football when he's on the pitch because he's greedy.
Aside from my burning hatred, I think Young and Valencia are good and I think selling almost any player in our team (aside from maybe Rooney) if it gives us the opportunity to liven our squad up, and replace in key areas then it would probably be a good idea. We have two fantastic wingers, and a few youth ones coming through, I'd be happy with that.
That's how I've rationalised never wanting to see Nani take a freekick again...
Agree0
Disagree0
If I remember rightly we signed CR7 after one good game against us, and it wasnt a knee jerk reaction, i thought the lad looked good playing against other champion league teams in the group stage, no more MOTD than every one saying we should sign Erikson after a decent game against England...
Agree0
Disagree0
Have to agree with the pro-Nani comments. He was our best player last season for me. He has also sorted out a lot of the negative sides of his game like being greedy and diving all the time. He appears to like the club. I would sell Young ahead of him I'm afraid but wouldnt sell either at the minute
Woffsta
Agree0
Disagree0
I think people on here get on a players back far to quickly but if i had a choice Lavezzi, strong,quick and can play up topquality player
Agree0
Disagree0