Manchester United Rumours Archive October 30 2012

30 Oct 2012 23:11:51
Right time for some controversy.... IF we were to sell Rooney for £60 million and we had the money put straight back into the team guaranteed every penny..... What would you do with it and before you slate the post I am just mentioning it I wouldnt want it to happen but if selling him meant midfielders coming in I believe we have enough up front in RVP, Welbeck, Hernandez, Henriquez and then people like Kagawa playing off them. I would play this team.

______________DDG
Rafael____Small_____Papa____Baines
______________Vidal______________
______Cleverley_____Sheeraway____
_____________Kagawa____________
_________Chico____RVP___________


I would sell Vidic, Nani, Ferdinand, Evra, Anderson, and some youngsters.

For gods sake we will not sell Rooney! Cant believe people want to, he has only had a few games this season and usually takes at least 10 games to be firing on all cylinders. Without him and Valencia last season we wouldn't have even got a European spot. Vidal isn't coming end of, it's El Shaarway and he would be ineffective in a midfield diamond instead of on the left in a 4-2-3-1 and Viktor Fischer is cheaper plus will be better. Baines is very very unlikely even if we were interested and we have Fabio and Buttner already. The only way I would sell Vidic is if we got Hummels in to replace him because otherwise no matter what we do our defense will be worse off.
For me we should get Wanyama with Anderson and Nani going out in January, that would add something to our team.

Dan

Thought i was playing fifa for a minute when i was looking at that line up.

Ozwald

Rooney brings so much commercialy that he is much more valuable to us than 60m and would be to any other club particularly if they are English.

No to rooney, but agree with others plus some. too much dead weight in the squad these days.

Firstly no one will pay sixty million for Rooney. And if we were to get someone stupid enough to pay that, how is popu and sheraawy money well spend. For 60 million you buy Goetze, Vidal, Varrane/Hummels and yes we would be a better team and Cleverly not good enough as a long term midfield solution.

Then ship Nani/Anderson/Evra/ 4 or 5 out of the academy and giggs/scholes/ferdinand off the books and wages.

Then we buy a proper left back and Munian and this team would beat our current team 10 out of 10 times.

He is not god at people make him out here.

All these Young guys sheraawy/sterling all all hyped up because they play for very average teams. If anybody watched the Liv/Everton game Baines gave young sterling a wake up call going both ways.

Shahram

Why sell anderson?
He has impressed everytime he has played this season unlike Nani.
He's very strong in midfield and the only player in our midfield that runs with ball.

Rooneys worth is way more than 60 m he is the best english player by a mile and no player in the world that is available could come close to filling his boots he is our main commercial poster boy and is not going anywere we dont need to sell to improve this team we need key players back from injury fletcher smalling fully fit vidic kagawa and jones back from there current injurys and maybe add a powerhouse midfielder in jan strootman or big vic from celtic if we must sell to get one of these guys in then nani is after to much money here let him go to anhzi or zenit they got bags of money but please dont even consider selling our best player it is just madness unless were getting messi or ronaldo on a long contract and that aint happening either lol

Sterling was brilliant against everton and is a really top player

30 Oct 2012 22:43:13
Eds?? This has completely nothing to do with Man United but my friend is a life long AC Milan supporter and he told me there was rumours of a buy out of the Serie A team.... Is there any truth to this thanks

Legion

30 Oct 2012 22:15:52
Looks like Arsenal are going to have some tired little legs, i'm feeling another cricket score for the weekend!?

Andy S

Ahh! The joys of that 8-2 rout :)

19-20 MUFC

They changed their entire 11

Will be a totally different team on Saturday, hopefully we can get a win again though!

GDS

As only Koscielny and possibly Walcott will start on Saturday, I doubt that somehow.

30 Oct 2012 20:09:58
i would lik syd or any of the ed's views on arda turan from atlico mad looks a good player
i also would like to hav sven bender over strootman

"i also would like to hav sven bender over strootman". Sorry that made me chuckle slightly

30 Oct 2012 11:29:56
1. Who is the most likely reserves player to be in 1st team in 1yr. (1 player)

2. Who is the most likely academy player to be in the 1st team in 2-3 yrs. (1 player)

1) hopefully tunnicliffe or Petrucci
2) daehli or januajz

Caolán.

Hmmmm it is tough to forecast someone's potential as some fulfill some fail and some come out of nowhere but.... Januzaj and Daehli both look class I just hope we can keep them long enough for us to reap the benefits.

Scott Wootton will be fits team player

1.) Lingard

2.) There are quite a lot talents that could make it. It´s really hard to judge them now. Petrucci was the bee's knees when he joined our academy but lots of bad luck with injury cost him so much time.

If most of them have luck with injuries i think Daehli, Januzaj, Rothwell, Pearson and Wilson have the best chance to make it at United. (Maybe Ioannou too)

1) Powell / Henriquez

2) Januzaj / Daehli

Sydney!

Petrucci

1)Tunnicliffe/Henriquez/Lingard
2)Januzaj/Daehli/Pereira/Wilson

Thanks everyone.. Benoit