06 Jul 2014 09:42:04
vidal is too expensive at £62 ,this is crazy money for a 27year old def mid ,no I realise he is great but this is what happens when you want a player from a club that doesn't want to sell , think we could be looking att another veron with this one ,how many of you thought he would flop? I would guess none ,for me carvalho for 30 m is the way to go and he will be just as good if not better in few years ,on a separate note I think van gal having the job ,but not actually being there is a huge blessing in disguise ,it means he can be rootless in his decisions as he hasn't meet or bonded or had to face anybody ,so to him it is just a name to get rid of

1.) 06 Jul 2014
First off at £62 he is the bargain of the century.
Second he is box to box.

Do you realise that he is about to hit his playing peak and is also regarded as the best in the world in that position but he is maybe not the right player for us.
Carvalho would also be my choice.

2.) 06 Jul 2014
06 Jul 2014 10:38:12
£62 would be an absolute bargain for Vidal!

3.) 06 Jul 2014
06 Jul 2014 10:41:19
I actually agree. I think its all mischief to get us involved in an auction whether we have interest or not.

I think if we were confident in getting vidal we wouldn't have spent 30 million on Herrera as I don't see us playing with two box to box types. Especially if we do go in for strootman some time in the future.

I think Carvalho being younger makes more sense as van gaal likes young players he can mould.

4.) 06 Jul 2014
06 Jul 2014 11:22:31
Vidal is a physical player which fits right into the Premier League. He is IMO the best all around player in the world. Even for the made up figures being quoted we should try our very best to get him.

Veron flopped because he was not able to deal with how physical the Premier League is not because he was a poor player. His best performances for United were in the CL where the style of play is different. Vidal wouldn't have the same problem.

5.) 06 Jul 2014
Just think trying to deal with a club of a similar size to ours about there best player is going to lead to ridiculous money being spent ,and as some have said he will be wasted as a 6 and herrera is obviously our 8 so this added to the fact he is younger,cheaper and what we actually need makes me believe carvalho is the man for us

6.) 06 Jul 2014
Who knows, maybe we are going for both(I wish).
So "IF" we did get both who would we sell.

7.) 06 Jul 2014
06 Jul 2014 13:34:01
£62m is not a bargain, maybe if you compare it to side show bobs transfer to PSG. He's an incredible player but £50m is more than enough for a 27 year old midfielder playing in Italy.

8.) 06 Jul 2014
£62 mill is way overpriced your right, but £62 IS still a bargain.

9.) 06 Jul 2014
I agree, £62 is too much, £62 + nani is a much fairer deal for us.

10.) 06 Jul 2014
Vidal will be the difference between us winning the league and fighting with the goons for 3rd place pay whatever it takes the new robbo

11.) 06 Jul 2014
Vidal is a player that can take any team up a notch. He is generally considerd as the best midfielder in the world by his peers and most footballing critics. If he were to come in and perform to the same level he has for Juve then we will have a bargain on our hands.