Manchester United Rumours Archive July 17 2012

 

Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.


17 Jul 2012 21:56:10
ibrahimovic signing for psg will set of a few transfers now expect berbatov to go to ac Milan and united to get lewandowski ad he's already told Dortmund he want to go united

Craigy

Believable11 Unbelievable17

17 Jul 2012 21:09:52
Manchester United have made a third offer of 41m for Lucas Moura after there 38m offer was rejected. - Sporto de Brasil


RamoN 19

Believable15 Unbelievable15

Doubt United would pay that much. Martinez Is available for 40 so i don't see why Fergie wouldn't go for him Instead.
James

Agree0 Disagree0

I hope we do get Lucas moura he,s got the skill and potential already to be better than cristiano ronaldo the guy is class and I for one hope we do get him he,s the type of player we need can win a game with some amazing bit of magic we need that type of get the ball and make something happen type of player that can lift the team in hard matches we ain't had that since ronaldo left. And obviously we need a striker in as well that's my thoughts anyway guys. Mattyboi.

Agree0 Disagree0

I really can't see us spending that much money on a player. I'm almost certain we wont get him.

Agree0 Disagree0

40mill euros = 33mill pounds-ish approx. martinez is 40mill pounds

Agree0 Disagree0

It was reported we bid for hazad and rodriguez so that would make Lucas third choice really let we are willing to pay 41 mill seems a bit strange to me
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Hopefully we get him he is a quility player somthing the yeam needs...

Agree0 Disagree0

This guy is to good to miss out on, an awsome talent. True we need a top class central midfielder but we have done well for seasons saying the same thing and we have just signed powell who could be great. Also expecting a breakthrough season from clevrly too

Agree0 Disagree0

I dont think we are after him! think he is
a smoke screen! united would neva pay
that sort of money for anyone!!
saj

Agree0 Disagree0

Martinez is 40 mill euro
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Millions or Euros???

At present there is difference

Agree0 Disagree0

Jred, perhaps 2nd choice. I think United would prefer Moura to Rodriguez, but perhaps thought they may have been able to get Rodriguez cheaper so went for him first. Would be nice for something like this to happen, I think the fans deserve it.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Syd
i think the whole team is crying out for a player who can really do something different , maybe lucas could be that man.
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

If we get Lucas and a striker Rvp lewandowski or falcao then were on for our best squad and season in ages we will be challenging for everything this season our team needs this and we fans definitely deserve it let's just hope it happens hey guys. Mattyboi

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 19:14:04
Manchester United FC have cut all interests in Lucas Moura after €38m bid was rejected,they say it was their last bid they made for Moura......,Oooh thank you we can now concentrate on real CMs like Eriksen and Moutinho for the €38 m we were ready to pay for Moura can buy 2 göod players for us like 1) Christian Eriksen(£20m).....,(2) Oviedo/Izzaguire (£9m).....What do you think Ed...?

Believable11 Unbelievable13

With respect, good players dont cut it, world class players do. Its the difference from 1st and 2nd place.

Agree0 Disagree0

Not going to happen. think about it kagawa and moura for the majority of the season will bring success. fergie wants to win the bpl not finsh second or below

Agree0 Disagree0

If we did bid 38m and walked away we will not buy anyone else of quality IMO

Pardoe

Agree0 Disagree0

Pardoe - I don't think they would actually.

Uniteds biggest weakness last season was central midfield. We can attack, we can defend, but any decent midfield can dominate us easily. We need someone who can reverse that.

I was always against Modric as he offers sod all in winning back the ball, but he'd still help us dominate simply by keeping and controlling possesion. What we really need though is someone who can pass and has the technical skill and composure to help keep the ball, but can also make the tackles and interceptions to win back the ball.

Martinez or Moutinho would be ideal, alternatively Cabaye, Fellaini (a little lighter on the technical side, but adds aerial strength) or Strootman (has been overhyped, but he'd still improve us, albeit not as much as the others).

Thorne

Agree0 Disagree0

If we buy this guy, we don't need anyone else Quality (maybe a cheap LB)

Agree0 Disagree0

Wouldnt get eriksen for that cheap either

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 20:24:22
Eds, do you believe that a left back(baines) will be the only signing that we will make? {Ed007's Note - No, I'm not even convinced Baines will sign.}

Believable6 Unbelievable10

I hope your right! Ive never seen Baines as Utd quality. But then was Irwin when he was at Oldham? we got him and he become maybe one of the top 3 LB we ever had.

Agree0 Disagree0

Strange. Baines doesn't seem to make sense, yet everyone seems to think it's inevitable.

G.A.G.U.S

Agree0 Disagree0

Me and Jred don't;) lol.

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 18:19:50
Sao Paulo director of football Adalberto Baptist has confirmed they rejected another offer of 38 million euros from MUFC for Lucas Moura. The club didn't give any value in which MUFC needed to meet to secure his services.

So then, Lucas Moura stories are true. 2 bids rejected. Will Sir Alex go one further and get his man?

30 million is a lot for a Brazillian teenager, I don't know much of him so I couldn't tell you if he's worth it or not.

Connor.

Believable7 Unbelievable11

I read the full article in Globo Esporte and there was not a single source.

also they are the exact words used to dismiss inters bid as well
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Quick question... Why is everything in Euros, when we don't use them and nor do Brazil. Seems strange that quotes are in that currency.

Sambo {Ed007's Note - The South American sides have been dealing in euros recently due to (a) much of their business being done in the Eurozone and (b) issues with the US$ which was used traditionally as the currency of choice - and still is for many transactions.}

Agree0 Disagree0

He'll end up in Italy with some dodgy part ownership thing going on for half the price

Dustbin

Agree0 Disagree0

Tell them to stuff it. Nowhere near a 40million euro player. When was the last time a South American settled into this country and played to potential. Stupid gamble.....if true.

Agree0 Disagree0

We are wasting time on this deal. Why not pull out and bring Eriksen. The guy wants to come. IMO I think he can do a good job in our midfield. That's where we need to tighten up. If we don't, Yaya will destroy us again.

Agree0 Disagree0

Watch the videos on you tube, look at the spanish debate about the player on you time. This player looks better than Ronaldo at 19. He is imply awesome. Given the fact the Euro is weak versus the pound at the moment we should do what we can. The problem is they don't really want to sell.

Agree0 Disagree0

If your wondering how much he is worth Youtube him. Im impressed with him (I know they are highlights from his good games) but he is fast, nimble on his feet, and is very strong with both feet. I completely agree that 38Mill is a bit steep, but risks need to be taken in a business and lets face it MUFC is a business! He could be the next Ronaldo, then again he could be the next Kléberson too!

Agree0 Disagree0

I could agree with moura at 30 or 32m, but at 40m u have to think there are better alternatives. I can understand if we are looking for someone to challenge eventually for the ballon d'or, but 40m can buy someone more experienced that wouldnt be too far off the very top level already. An example for would be aguero i suppose. bought for 45m, and now is worth 50+
Bale?

Agree0 Disagree0

All u people on this site say Brazilian as if brazilians no matter who they are would never make it in the prem tht just stupid wa does it matter where some one is from

Dio

Agree0 Disagree0

Why would it be in euro's? brazil is not in europe so would not use euro's {Ed007's Note - RTFP.}

Agree0 Disagree0

We wont be getting Lucas if much more is needed, we were in for Pato before Milan got him but the price was too high for someone of his age, Fergie said this publicly years back. Sao Paulo want to get the most they can for him, and Lucas gets around 20% of any fee paid for him, in August this will rise to around 30%, Fergie and Gill want the deal done this week, Sao Paulo will be wanting to sell before Lucas' cut of the fee rises to avoid losing money. I think this is the Hazard money, and I doubt we have much more too spend on top of this, we have just signed Kagawa, so a central rather than attacking midfielder should be our first priority now.

Agree0 Disagree0

Dio, name me one Brazilian who has been successful in the premiership and I'll name you ten who've flopped.

Andrew B

Agree0 Disagree0

Juniniho was a good player in prem !!

sparkyred

Agree0 Disagree0

Andrew b - Juninho Paulista. Now let's hear the 10

Agree0 Disagree0

Youtube Jermaine Pennant he looks pretty good too
Invisible STuey

Agree0 Disagree0

This could be the 10:
Jo, Robinho, Branco, Roque Junior, Baptista, Kleberson, Anderson, Gilberto, Afonso Alves, Jardel

Steffen

Agree0 Disagree0

I love this name 1 brazilian who has played well in the prem league the best brazilian that has played in the league was Robinho no Carlos,Ronaldo,Kaka,Ronaldonho none of the big names want to sign for a prem league club get the same offers from Spainish and Italian clubs with the big teams the good locations and the better weather forget the clubs where would you rather live Manchester or Madrid?? Lucas looks good on youtube but so does nani and we all know he can go missing cant be expected to pay 40m but then again still cheaper than Carroll {Ed001's Note - Juninho, Emerson Thome.}

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 17:51:45
If has been quoted we've bid 38m euros for and Sao Paolo are holding out for 40 then surely this kid is OT-bound?

As for Baines - SAF looks to have walked away from that one given Everton outpricing their prized leftback out of a move.

Modric to Real and Moutinho to Spurs look the most likely moves so still leaves the small matter of central midfield to resolve. But is Uncle Fergie thinking of either a deeper-lying Kagawa or Powell could play that role ?

And with Berbatov on the way out seemingly then is that because we have another striker waiting in the wings ?

Halesini

Believable13 Unbelievable8

Easy sollution very very easy solution. Powell already in berba out striker for striker. Then bring in FELLAINI, this man is what are midfield is missing and has been missing for seasons.

Agree0 Disagree0

Powell will be deployed in the center of the midfield, not as a trequartista or a support striker. Kagawa will have that role.

Agree0 Disagree0

Still think there is something in the Eriksen story myself.

if we signed Moura (which is not certain) and Berb goes i don't see us signing a striker.

Playing Kagawa deeper would be a mistake and a waste.

Mort.

Agree0 Disagree0

Why would there be another striker on the way with Rooney leading the line supported by Kagawa with Hernandez and Welbeck as back-up?

Agree0 Disagree0

If fergie is looking to modernize the squad, then the old model of 4 strikers may no longer hold. hernandez and welbeck as the up top forwards, rooney, young and kagawa as CAMs, lucas? nani as wingers/free floating CAMs (maybe Young here too) and valencia as a true touch line winger. I'd be quite happy w that.

Pepe

Agree0 Disagree0

Rooney in the hole would be a waste.

How about Rooney up front, free to drop back like he does, with Kagawa behind him ready to push forwards and lead the line when Rooney drops back, plus 2 of Young, Cleverly and Nani as wider AM with freedom to rove. That's a very potent, very fluid attacking force, kind of a United take on the modern fluid football we've seen so much of recently.

Thorne

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 17:02:45
why is rooney not mentioned in the pre-season tour, i can take a cheeky guess thinking he might be sold outside england and new striker and mid fielder might be brought in.----- anything is possible in football

*Reddy {Ed007's Note - Or he could be on an extended holiday because he was at the Euros.}

Believable4 Unbelievable27

Really? i suppose Young Jones and Welbeck are also being sold as they aren't there either.

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

Why do people come out wit the same bull every season about Rooney, Rooney will be going nowhere! obviously anyone playing at Euros wont be playing on this tour!!

Agree0 Disagree0

By your theory all the players who aren't on tour are being sold, we may be in trouble! "/

TM

Agree0 Disagree0

Man Utd are playing Cork City July 25th he could be involved in that

Agree0 Disagree0

Hmmm Im not sure whether to believe Ed007 or Reddy on this one haha!

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

Extended break coz of euro's

Agree0 Disagree0

Lol added 2+2 and got 456, good effort.

GDS

Agree0 Disagree0

With off field problems. Sale of Rooney would have massive implications on the pitch and more important financially . Glazers have too much riding on the image and profitability to let that happen. Crazy notions should be thought and not said MANDY

Agree0 Disagree0

All players who played in the euros are joining up second leg of the tour as to get a decent rest



Dwright

Agree0 Disagree0

I hope your right about Young Shappy! It'd be nice to get our money back on him and get someone more consistant!
(maybe a bit bold for a newish poster)

Patzi

Agree0 Disagree0

Patzi, are you crazy? Young had a very consistent and great first season with us! Nani is the inconsistent one! he has a greatgame every 10 games, and the other he's anonymus in!
as for you Reddy, you clearly need to start reading up on United as you don't have a clue what is going on, next you'll think Heskey has signed for us!

Jake

Agree0 Disagree0

Using the IP address, Ed07 can you please find the nearest asylum for Reddy to be admitted to immediately? I'm afraid he might be in danger of hurting himself or others, or just being dumb....thanks. -KG

Agree0 Disagree0

Did Rooney actually play football at the Euros? Plus Sir Alex has a long memory, He remembers Rooneys I want to leave! (or pay me more) bribe last year.

Agree0 Disagree0

"Did Rooney actually play football at the Euros? Plus Sir Alex has a long memory, He remembers Rooneys I want to leave! (or pay me more) bribe last year"

LOL 1) yes he did 2) certainly played more than Jones who is also 'rested' from the tour 3) the club knew about Rooney's 'I want to leave bribe' before giving him his massive new contract, so why would SAF remember that now rather than taking action at the time?

Strange noname, I think you're just looking for negativity TBH! Perhaps not a United fan?

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 16:57:22
Reported in the press but I have also been told that a second bid of £30 million has been rejected for Lucas Moura. Will bring more news when I get it.

fearny

Believable6 Unbelievable10

You clearly saw this on a few sites just like everyone else posting it, no special information in this.

At that price, I'm not so sure I'll take notice of it.

TM

Agree0 Disagree0

Very decent of you fearny give my best wishes to David Gill and I trust he has had a great holiday
ARB

Agree0 Disagree0

Fearny
the reports are all from 1 Brazilian newspaper this is the article below if you are interested
Manchester United decided to open the safe to take Luke 's Sao Paulo. After offering 33 million (U.S. $ 82.4 million) last week, a figure which was not accepted by President Juvenal Juvencio, the English club made ​​a new offer: 38 million (U.S. $ 96 million) to take the athlete after the dispute between the London Olympics. And just like at the first offer, the answer tricolor was the same: no.
Note that the second proposal reaches the requested initial Morumbi club. Until the 1st of August, the Tricolor has 80% of the economic rights of the athlete, and confided a second person connected to the board, the club would be willing to release the 7 shirt is free to receive 30 million ($ 75 million), what would happen now. Thus, the club would get the asking price and Luke, which is 20%, would receive 7.4 million (U.S. $ 18.5 million).
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Daily Fail by any chance? They are the most unreliable of all! But if true I expect us to pull out.

Patzi

Agree0 Disagree0

Dont bother,think we can all read just like you,seriously its getting a bit ridiculous now all this itk crup.
mick the red fireman

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 16:48:10
If the rumours are true about a €38m bid rejected for Lucas Moura as Sao Paulo are holding out for €40m then it shows how much Fergie rates this lad. If this is true it seems we will get our man...

However, I personally can't see this story being true and don't believe we are in for him at all tbh...and certainly not at the prices being quoted.

MPez

Believable8 Unbelievable8

I doubt the difference would only be 2m. What difference would 2m make to them?

G.A.G.U.S

Agree0 Disagree0

There is no chance United will bid 40mil Euro on a 19 yr, that is unproven in the EPL. This is pure bs that the press in portugal and brazil always conjure up, in order to raise the ACTUAL price. I wouldnt hold my breath on this 1.

Patzi

Agree0 Disagree0

G.A.G.U.S - are you having a laugh!?!?

What difference does £2million make!? Ask anyone that question and see what the response is. Rich or poor £2million means a lot to people

Agree0 Disagree0

Where did I mention what 2m meant to someone like me? 2m is not that much when you could already be getting 38m is it? Why would they want an extra 2m? Are you having a laugh?

G.A.G.U.S

Agree0 Disagree0

G.A.G.U.S

I get what you mean but it might be 2m to the mininum price the brazilian club want to sell for. For example they may have wanted 45m euros or more but would exept 40m as a minimum. Clubs will always have a certain amount of flexibility for negotiation but the minimum will almost definately be set in stone, especially when in such a strong position as Sao Paulo, so 2m can make a big diffence.

Red Joe

Agree0 Disagree0

18 Jul 2012 01:16:06
Sao Paulo have already confirmed they had rejected a 26m offer from ourselves

Agree0 Disagree0

Ed002, can you confirm a second bid? Thanks.

Sydney! {Ed002's Note - I'll check this evening Syd to see if I can find out any detail.}

Agree0 Disagree0

Missing the point again G.A.G.U.S. £2mill is a lot to a football club. They are a business and it may be the difference of recruiting an extra player. Me, you, rich person, wealthy football club. £2million is a lot

Agree0 Disagree0

Thanks Ed, I do appreciate it.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 16:18:30
According to reports in Brazil we have had a bid rejected of a staggering €38 Million for Lucas Moura. I personally find this hard to believe as we have enough attacking Midfielders. Unless were offloading anyone i.e Nani.

RedMUFC

Believable6 Unbelievable12

If that's the case, why don't we bid that amount for Martinez?

CRMike

Agree0 Disagree0

Thats about £29.78M

jr-red

Agree0 Disagree0

If he is bidding hugh Bucks for this lad ( which I doubt he is ) obviously he has a great chance of being the next superstar, if he's that good go for him!

Agree0 Disagree0

"If that's the case, why don't we bid that amount for Martinez?"
Because the pot is empty. Welcome to United 2012.
Red Snapper

Agree0 Disagree0

Whilst whoever ends up signing him will have to pay a lot of money, remember:
a) that his image rights will ballon in value if he signs for United and this is probably being used as a bargaining point (assuming we are in for him at all).
b) shirt sales in S america alone could make Moura a cheap signing overall - remember how Real Madrid crowed about how cheap a signing Becks was because of the stuff he sold for them.

OLE4EVRA

Agree0 Disagree0

He's brilliant to be fair I really hope we stretch out a little more to get him. He will be superstar most skillful and best at taking on a man I have ever seen and I'm not exageerating

Agree0 Disagree0

REDMUFC - Why when we are linked with a winger, do folk like yourself, always suggest Nani would be the one to leave. Young has hardly set Old Trafford alight, with his 4 league goals and 5 assists. Nani, who was injured at least as much as Young, had 8 goals and 10 assists. The difference in their quality ,was reflected in the Euros for all to see.
I would like Moura, he's the nuts, but our central midfield is in a poor old state. If we really have offered 30m for Lucas, Hazard etc and 12m for Baines, I think we should mend the worst part of our team. Get shot of Anderson add 12m to it and get Witsel. With the change go for Fellaini and Cissoko. When England played Belgium, their midfield looked quality. I would settle with 2 of Dembale, Fellaini or Witsel. You say we have a lot of attacking midfielders, well we do have a couple of good wingers, but apart from Kagawa, who will play just off the front and Carrick who plays just in front of the back 4, we don't have any midfielder who can last a game every few days. We have the 2 legends whose best days have past them by 3 or 4 years ago. We have fat injury prone Anderson, whose way beneath the class we are used to and we have the other eternal patient Cleverly. Even when he is fit, which is usually for a month or two per season, he isn't that good either - the word "average" springs to mind and "at best" to follow it. If you can see any good midfielders, you must mean potentially good midfielders, like Powell and Petrucci. they may come good and so may Jones, but probably not this season. Our midfield is a true worry, the worst midfield in SAF reign and the worse central midfield in the top half of the EPL. Now you can keep your blinkers on and pretend the club you love are in good health, or get real. More importantly I hope SAF, DG and the Glazers get real and buy us a f*****g midfield.
Mik

Agree0 Disagree0

Anderson is better than all the midfielders you suggest dumping him for Mik. They are all good but average players. Anderson has been dissapointing, bar his first season, as he has said this is a "make or break season" for him. Personally I would rather give Anderson that season than sign any of the midfielders you mention to replace him with, not just because I still rate Anderson highly but more so because I dont rate highyl any of the players you mention although they are alll good
Invisible STuey

Agree0 Disagree0

There's M'vila, Eriksen, Fellaini, Martinez, Dembale, Marvin Martin, Cabaye, Tiote, Strootman, Tiago, Ganso, and many more midfielder price between 10 -40m who are all light years ahead of Anderson. he is unfit,none to bright on or off the pitch, has weight problems and is always injured. I watch all Uni teds games and have only seen Anderson play really well half dozen times. Ask yourself " what top champion leagues team would want him, outside of Portugal" Even Benfica would pay less than 10m pounds for him. I think we need 2 midfielders, or City, Chelsea and maybe Spurs will cause us long time problems.
Whatever else, we'll agree that we want to see United with a winning team this season.
Mik

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 16:05:58
Just a thought on Lucas Moura, Man Utd delegation has been sent over. Inter Milan have dropped out of the running due to the price, the president of the club has said man utd will have to cough up more if they want to sign him. Obv this means a bid has been made, fergie has not mentioned anything about Moura in interviews. He has stated that they are looking into one or two more signings, normally if Man Utd have no interest in a player they come out and say it. I'm just saying that there is more than a big chance he will signed, I know Ed will dissagree saying about the ownership rights but I believe Moura will be signed and we may possibly lose Nani...

Believable7 Unbelievable9

Very interesting article today about the significance of dates coming up in terms of hikes to Moura's salary and also the percentages his family will get of any deal which seems to be pushing up the overall price. I think August 1 was the key date so maybe something will happen soon.

Agree0 Disagree0

I think Sao Paolo would be willing to sell at the price quoted, but they have until August 1st to sell before the player gains an additional 10% of his ownership. They'll play hardball until July 31st.....

Agree0 Disagree0

Inter president has said today inter are still trying to sign him
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Yes but it's all just paper talk?

Modric had 'signed' for United weeks ago according to papers, so I wouldn't believe all you read about Moura just yet

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

`Fergie has sent the scout that convinced Chicharito to join! He could be doing negotiations and getting back to SAF.. You dont have to be there to be ongoing in negotiations, he will be focusing on pre-season is my guess.
-Newton Heath 1878

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 16:01:59
'Manchester United have been named the world's most valuable sports team - ahead of Real Madrid, Barcelona and Arsenal.
Sir Alex Ferguson's team, bought by the Glazer family for $1.47billion in 2005, are now worth $2.23billion according to Forbes magazine. Four football teams breach the top 10 most valuable sports franchises, with United and Real Madrid occupying first and second spots.'- Sorry for the copy n paste.

BBR

Believable3 Unbelievable5

Great to see all our money going into the family's hands. We should have the best squad in the world, but instead we're shopping mid range. United fans are going to look back at this five years as the period we lost. Just hope we're not left behind.

Agree0 Disagree0

Well said that man. Everyone wake up to this fact. We can all sit there saying we are top of the pile but investment will bring you European cups and the premier league. But let's tow the party line and insist that there is no value in the market!
Red Snapper

Agree0 Disagree0

Guess what David Conn (city fan) the sport financial journalist who is quick to blog about the debt/ipo and how the Glazers have ruined our club has not done a piece on this in the guardian today surprise surprise !
Poor business men are those Glazers!!
Tiger2

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 15:51:49
Having seen Sir Alex's recent press confrence i think a few things have been made clear. First off that he very much see's Evra as a very important mamber of our team.

" Patrice, in the last five years has played an average of 45-50 games. It's phenomenal. I don't know if anybody else has achieved that. He's still a fit lad and has the same drive and ambition. He's a fighter. "

This to me shows how highly Sir Alex thinks of Evra. This is why IMO i don't see us signing a first choice LB. I say first choice as i could see us signing someone to be Evra's understudy, but with Fabio Blackett and possibly Brady i could understand if we didn't bring one in. Bearing in mind that Evans and Giggs can do a job at LB as well.

This is the reason i doubt someone like Baines will join as i just can't see him being happy to be Evra's understudy at the age of 27. And as much as i'd like to see Evra replaced in our team, it appears that Sir Alex still rates him very highly. So IMO the only way we'll see a LB come in this summer is if Brady and Blackett show that they aren't upto being Evra's understudy and then i feel we'll sign someone who's talented with potential to become better but someone who won't demand a starting place. Players like Bryan Oviedo or Martin Olsson would be good shouts i think.

Shappy

Believable18 Unbelievable2

This probably will be Evra's last season though, Baines would not be an instant replacement, he'd have a season to bed himself in - so I don't see the problem with Baines coming in. Im sure he'd be happy to wait if he knew he'd be first choice next year.

RedDevil19

Agree0 Disagree0

"it appears that Sir Alex still rates him very highly"

Appears being the operative word. Do you believe everything our manager says? Do you not think his interviews are cleverly planned and thought out? Do you think he would diss Evra to the public? Here's a biggy, if you, I and the neighbours cat can see Evra's flaws, are you saying our manager can't? Isn't that pretty insulting? I have no doubt a LB will be signed just like I was saying yesterday, I also believe Baines will be our number one LB next season with Evra as his understudy (unless he is sold of course), but I think that will be the summer of 2013. We will know soon enough I guess.

I think the interview was a message to Moyes and Kenright saying we have Evra, we have Fabio, Blackett & Brady at the club so we will not be held to ransom over Baines.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

I don't think he would he'll be approaching 29 at the start of next season. I just don't see us signing Baines unless Evra was leaving which i just don't see happening.

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

He didn't have to mention Evra at all but he did. Maybe he is send subliminal messages out and only you are picking up on them Syd mate.

I know Sir Alex won't knock a player in the press as that would be shocking man management but he didn't need to publicly back Evra either.

I'm sure he has some idea what he wants to say in these things but considering he is asked questions i don't think they can be planned out quite as well as you think. Unless Sir Alex knows what questions he is gonna be asked by independant members of the press.

It seems you are a lost cause though Syd mate, I agree that we MAY sign a LB but you seem so hopeless lost in the idea that you can't see any circumstance that we won't sign one. You say you have no doubt, but then you must have been told by someone important at the club that it's a done deal otherwise there is always a chance that it won't happen. The reason you say you have no doubt is because you want it so badly that you've convinced yourself it will happen. You come across like a paranoid person who is so convinced someone is out to get him your seeing murders on every corner.

You seem unable to look at this situation without bias because you WANT a new LB. Everything said or done by the club or anyone connected with the club seem to be saying that we are signing Baines. This just isn't the case.

If your so sure would you put all the money you have on Baines being a United player by september 1st?

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

I understand your point Shappy and actually I'm undecided on the LB issue. I have thought all along that Baines is coming in with Evra being phased out over the season - makes sense to me - but I wouldn't be amazed if we didn't sign a LB at all, given SAF's stubborness and admiration for Evra

However 2 points directly related to the SAF quote on Evra:
1. He wouldn't diss Evra (as Syd said) or say he was looking for a replacement even if he is, would he?
2. To me that statement just says "he's still a fit lad and has the same drive and ambition. he's a fighter". That doesn't say to me that Evra will be our first choice LB next season. SAF could have been very clear on that if he wanted too, given this opportunity

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

Shaps, we will know soon enough mate. You have got to love our differences of opinions, it makes the site more interesting and at least you do not get all moody because my opinion is different to yours like others on this site ;)

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Paranoid? No I just have immense trust in Sir Alex and I trust his expertise in management. If me, you, jred and everyone else can see Evra's flaws, then why do you think our manager can't?

I am not certain Baines with be signed, but I am certain a LB will be signed. Perhaps I was a little hasty with my last post which hasn't been posted yet.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Oh and I guess you didn't know the manager has a list of the questions being asked beforehand. He even gets to pick which journalists get to ask him the questions. If a journalist asks a rogue question the question will be intercepted by one of the club's legal reps. Just like all of the IPO questions have been intercepted and blocked. I guess you learn something new every day. The press conferences and interviews especially are scripted. What the manager says in interviews will be carefully planned by him and I genuinely believe the quotes today were for the Everton officials. It happens all of the time in football and our manager is the king at this. Jose isn't too bad either.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Syd mate I like the fact that everyone has different opinions otherwise it'd be very boring. Like you said we'll find out who's right soon enough.

Gav, of course Sir Alex wouldn't diss Evra as that would be poor man management. On the other side he can't say that anyone is garenteed a place as thats not the name of the game. But this backing from the boss shows how highly he thinks of Evra.

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 14:57:53
Quick question for anyone who mite be able to answer a united 11 are coming over to Ireland to play cork city I got my ticket and all but was wondering what players wud b coming I'm not expecting and of de regulars but if anyone knows I'd like to no cheers


Cork red

Believable5 Unbelievable1

I got my ticket too and realised CR%P, we are playing Shenji Shanghai the same day!! My guess is the 22 man squad travelling on the DHL tour is a fairly young and inexperienced in places so, dont be dissapointed if you see a United U18 IX..
-Fellow Cork Red

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 13:41:38
Berbatov to AC Milan

Mega Amazing Man

Believable12 Unbelievable13

If this is true then good luck to Berbatov. I think he is an absolutely brilliant player and it is a shame that for whatever reason it just didn't work out at Utd.

I wish him well and think that he will shine for AC Milan.

Agree0 Disagree0

Didn't work out? He was top scorer season before last!
Uniteds style is changing..... Berbs is a top pro good luck to the geezer
Q

Agree0 Disagree0

Mega Amazing Man?! Lol!

DodgyBanter

Agree0 Disagree0

I do think Berba will leave but can't personally see him going to AC. Could be wrong though. Good luck to him wherever he ends up

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 14:17:13
Is there any reported interest from united on Federico Balzaretti? would be decent cover for Evra if SAF is really in the market such a player? still would prefer funds to be invested in a box-to-box CM beforehand though!

KmD

Believable1 Unbelievable13

Balzaretti apparently has it heart set on a big wage at PSG. Very little chance of coming here.

RedDevil19

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 13:52:55
When is the game on today and where can I watch thanks in advance

Coombesy

Believable0 Unbelievable10

It's tomorrow at 4pm UK time

fearny

Agree0 Disagree0

It's tomorrow if I'm not mistaken, KO at 19:00 BST..

Don't think we can post links of where to watch? But most of us are fine it's on MUTV and MUTV Online

TM {Ed007's Note - I can't recommend any sites but I am happy to post any that are sent in.}

Agree0 Disagree0

It's tomorrow, 8pm, MUTV.

GDS

Agree0 Disagree0

It not on today, tomorrow at 7 mutv or first row sports

phil

Agree0 Disagree0

It is tomorrow.. 20:00 local time.

Steffen

Agree0 Disagree0

Its on tomorrow i think mate, and firstrowsports :)

tarrant77

Agree0 Disagree0

Well there you have it its on at 4 7 and 8 so ya shouldnt miss it no matter what !

Devil Dust.

Agree0 Disagree0

Thanks everybody and ED

Coombesy {Ed007's Note - No probs mate.}

Agree0 Disagree0

It tomorrow half six on mutv

Agree0 Disagree0

Coombesy where you from?

Agree0 Disagree0

Hiya coombesy
Its on tomorrow evening at 6:45 on MUTV .
fozzy58

Agree0 Disagree0

Friendly Match


18th Jul 2012
KO 00:00
Ground: Moses Mabhida Stadium

Agree0 Disagree0

Its 2mro night prob get it from myp2p..
Sorry if this is spam or not allowed..
Could also pay for MUFC Tv but nobody is that stupid :)
- Newton Heath 1878

Agree0 Disagree0

I'm from Salford mate

Coombesy

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 13:19:24
Robert lewandoski (spelling) has said he would like to play in the premier leauge
"This (the Premier League) is a league in which I would like to play and I hope to manage that at some point,"
Sorry for cut and paste.
Do the eds or anyone know if united are still interested in lewandoski?

Caolán.

Believable4 Unbelievable11

United have expressed an interest in Lewandowski (along with many other clubs), but whether United make a move for him is another matter, as it would largely depend on the outgoings during this window. I expect to see him compete another season in the Bundesliga with Dortmund, but then again a surprise bid late in the window would not shock me.

Sydney's Mother!

Agree0 Disagree0

I know that SAF did say the 40million asking price was far too much
- Newton Heath 1878

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 12:34:45
Ed07.... what is Victor Wanyama like....

seen the odd rumour that city, liverpool, newcastle and Juv are interested in him......

how many mid fielders do juv need ??? {Ed007's Note - Wanyama is an absolutely fantastic player. I know I am biased but I fully expect him to go on and become one of the best DMs in the world and he is also very comfortable at CB. I honestly rate him higher than M'Vila and thought Man Utd had done the best piece of business last summer in signing Phil Jones until I saw Wanyama playing and he only cost £900k. He seems to have everything, strong, quick, good in the tackle, good in the air and very rarely wastes a pass. If any EPL team had signed him last summer the whole of England and big European clubs would be looking at him this year. All the talk of any interest seems to be coming from his agent though and CFC are not keen to sell him, but money talks up here.}

Believable9 Unbelievable4

Thanks ed07,i knew that you would know.... need to get fergie to get him and izzy then... how much would you say for the 2 of them?

oxred (forgot to sign off earlier) {Ed007's Note - I would say £6/7 million for Izaguirre and I would be disappointed if we didn't get £8 -10 million for Wanyama, he really is that good and will only get better.}

Agree0 Disagree0

Wow, I've never seen him play but now I really want United to sign him just based on that glowing endorsement by Ed007 haha! I'm not being sarcy either : )

Cheers for the info. Ed I will be looking out to watch him in future. I'm guessing whoever does manage to bag him will have a right deal on their hands but then Celtic will stand to make a huge profit too (although I'm sure they'd like to keep him)

Gav {Ed007's Note - Definitely Gav, we won't keep him for long up here and he is what English people call 'a beast' of a player.}

Agree0 Disagree0

I reacon a joint bid of around 6m and a few deepfried mars bars should seal the deal. 4m for Izzy and 2m for Wanyama. I think Bond you need to be sensible with prices now that the SPL is only a one team competition and will be for a few years at least. This will be the end of scottish football....it seems strange saying that as i feel i may have missed the boat by a few years with that comment. lol.

Shappy {Ed007's Note - Well if Ki who can hardly get in our team is worth £7 million what price two important players? Stop being a snob Shappy, if Man Utd bought Wanyama for £8-10 million from the Belgian/French/Swiss league you would be getting a chubby on about how good the Utd scouts were doing etc. Or would you rather sign another Bebe? For his fee you could have bought Izaguirre, Wanyama and Kayal and still had plentychange back. And all three of them would have improved Utd's squad last season.}

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 12:21:47
Does anyone know of any links with us to Jamie Ness of Rangers? I heard we were linked with him a while ago and when I've seen him I thought he was pretty decent. Now they are in the 3rd division, could a move be on the cards?

Sanshine

Believable0 Unbelievable21

He has already signed for Stoke City, Sanshine mate.

TK-Red

Agree0 Disagree0

Didn't he just sign for Stoke?

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Have we fallen that far in the transfer scheme of things that we could only attract him now Rangers have been relegated to the third division. We all seem to be getting pretty desparate for new signings!!
The Word

Agree0 Disagree0

He had one decent game against Celtic when the Celtic midfield didn't show up for some reason, next game he was schooled and hasn't looked too good since

Agree0 Disagree0

He has agreed terms with stoke about 3 weeks ago, pending clearance from FIFA over his contract with rangers being cancelled. Good young player, not nearly good enough for United though!

Agree0 Disagree0

Thanks guys, I thought he might be one that has moved on. Looks a good talent, will be interested to see him play next year.

Sanshine

Agree0 Disagree0

Fair enough, I thought he was pretty young though. Cheers for the info though everyone.

Sanshine

Agree0 Disagree0

We could always put a bid in for his twin brother Loch if anyone can find him
ARB

Agree0 Disagree0

Good shout ARB, we should check out his 3 cousins too - Happy, Good and Bad

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 11:54:33
Hi guys a few points hear,
Sean miginty has gone on loan to Oxford , good luck to him.
The boss has said Robbie Brady and Jessie Lingard will play the first game on tour. SAF has also said that Robbie Brady will play left back. Can he play there?
Finally inter Milan have said they have been priced out of a deal, so this must mean we are the front runners and really the only side with a strong interest although reports are saying we need to up our offer to 34 million from 30.

Caolán.

Believable6 Unbelievable3

If Sean miginty has gone on loan to the U's might have to pop down to the Kassam to take a look at some point....

Oxred

Agree0 Disagree0

I saw this about moura's price aswell but then there are other reports today saying they are holding out for 37 million euros which I THINK is about 29 and a half mill GBP

Agree0 Disagree0

Actually Sean miginty may be included for tonights game v West Ham..... will have to see how he does...

oxred

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 11:21:15
SAF's latest comments seem to dampen the rumours of Baines being bought ? He mentions that we have got Fabio, Robbie Brady and Tyler Blackett coming through in the left back position, behind Evra.

Believable9 Unbelievable2

I 100% disagree, it shows that we are soooo desperate for a LB that Brady (a left winger) is being tried at LB. This only enhances the feeling that a LB is being sought after.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Good, I would be disppointed if he was replacing Evra for the amount being discussed. I really think that we need to replace Evra but I think for 1 more season there are other areas in need of greater attention

Agree0 Disagree0

But it would also imply that we are
a. looking for an understudy to evra
b. possible looking at options with in the club
jred

Agree0 Disagree0

Adding to Sydney, our Loan deal with QPR for Fabio (the top prospect we have to challenge Evra) and the whole Fryers to Spurs (next in line to challenge), leaves us massively exposed in the area from which we leaked the most goals. I (unlike many), still feel Evra is a great LB, and signing Baines (or another of proven quality) will not only give us rotation, it will get the best out of Evra. With regards to Moura I have to say I feel a DM is much more likely, if at all. I feel we enough attacking midfielders. Powell is also being used for a CAM role. I also think a lot of united supporters don't rate him. He is the real deal. I watched him as soon as links were made with us, and was under no illusion. Class. As proved by, not only the goal, but his whole performance in the playoff final. Also, I have a strong feeling Anderson WILL hush a lot of scepticism next season. Expect a new man in pre season. Patzi

Agree0 Disagree0

We need to stop this rubbish about Baines - he's so overated on this site and United will not be buying him. Everyone is speaking about the limited options we have as cover, but there is no way we are getting rid of Evra. Fergie said:

"Patrice, in the last five years has played an average of 45-50 games. It's phenomenal. I don't know if anybody else has achieved that. He's still a fit lad and has the same drive and ambition. He's a fighter."

Fergie is testing out cover with youth, something we should support. Fabio in a year will probably come back and be first choice LB.

Gary

Agree0 Disagree0

Jred, I believe we are looking for possible options within the squad as an understudy to Evra just in-case Baines falls through. I also believe this is a message to Everton that you cannot hold us to ransom as we do have other options.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Patzi, Anderson is good in every preseason, it's his injuries that are the issue. I think he will be sold.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Gary - TBH I think Evra will stay too and will be sold next summer, however, nowhere in that quote does it say that Evra will be 1st choice, or even that he won't be sold. All he does it compliment him, which all manager's do to their own players

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

It makes NO sense in signing Baines! Fabio is only on loan for a season but can be called back if needs be. Also why would we buy Baines who is going to want to start? So as I've questioned before, come the end of this season who are you going to then play if we had Baines, Evra and Fabio?

melwing28

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 11:12:49
The Moura rumours are puzzling... We just don't need another winger, and CAM is now covered by Kagawa and Cleverly (+Rooney).

Fergie isnt stupid. Either it doesnt make sense because its not true, or he knows something we dont - like contract talks with Nani have broken down and he will leave this or next summer....?

Believable9 Unbelievable2

The thing with Lucas is that he is one of those players Fergie feels he cannot afford to miss out on! The same as Rooney and Jones! Fergie was prepared to wait another year for Rooney but then Newcastle started showing an interest so he had to step in. It's te same with Lucas! Ideally Fergie would like to wait a year or 2 but the interest from Inter has forced his hand

Agree0 Disagree0

Or he thinks he has spotted another ronaldo quality player and wants to bring him in before the price tag gets any higher and we cant compete with other clubs for his signature!

tarrant77

Agree0 Disagree0

I believe Lucas would play a free role similar to the one Ronaldo enjoyed. When Ronaldo was at OT, the movement across the midfield was tremendous (and I am talking of the movement without the ball). This was because he was able to occupy any position and our other wingers were able to switch to fill gaps and expose other sides of the pitch. i think this would be the same gameplan to bring the title back (should Lucas actually arrive).

It could OBVIOUSLY come to nothing. But I would love to see Lucas join!

MDJ

Agree0 Disagree0

Tarrant77 hits the nail on the head. Remember back when some established "faces" and pundits labelled Ronaldo as nothing more than a show-pony? He rammed that down their throats and every self-opinionated critic with his progress. He started off as an exceptional talent first though. Perhaps SAF sees the same kind of promise?

I've seen loads of posts on here running Moura down and wanting Utd to sign admittedly good players but perhaps don't have the potential to reach the very top level i.e. Messi, Ronaldo, Eto, Zidane...well the very best.

Utd have a long history of being a fluid and exciting team to watch. Functional was last year. City need not buy anyone but will be stronger and i think the club knows that. Kagawa is a brilliant signing. If he cost 3 times the £12m then i put my house on it being a bargain if he goes out and does his thing for the club on the pitch.

Do i know whether Moura will sign? Of course i don't, but that only lots me in the same boat everyone else is in.

Do i want him to sign? Lets put it this way - if he's interested SAF then he must have something. Yes i know Bebe, Djemba-Djemba, Prunier, et al but i also remember Cantona, RvN, and Ronaldo. When they played i watched, together with everyone else.

Winning its as much about doing it in style as it is about the result with Utd. History and responsibility. The day you forget is when you turn into Liverpool. Who'd have thunk it 20 years ago?

Agree0 Disagree0

This kid has the potential to be the worlds best, fergie knows it, he also knows we could only get 4 to 5 years before real or barca or psg or city come calling with 100mil cash in then find another, just think how malcom glazier looked so much like doctor evil when fergie told him you'll quadrupple your money on this boy

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 09:43:52
With all this talk of Moura and the Fletcher situation being what it is, should we not be looking for more steel in midfield instead of chasing silky Brazilians. We can have the 4 most skillful players in the world in midfield but who is going to win them the ball ? Carrick is not a def mid by any stretch of the imagination. The obvious targets are Strootman, M'Villa, Tiote but we don't seem to be after them. Any chance of a def mid eds?

Sligo Red

Believable20 Unbelievable4

Yes we should and I have no idea why we aren't.

RED_SKY

Agree0 Disagree0

Typical English view.What about Barcelona? Who are their enforcers? Or Madrids?
You cant tackle anymore,it's all about positional play and intercepting the ball in midfield now.Dont't give the ball away so you don't have to get it back

Agree0 Disagree0

I have to say, I completly agree. I wish we could get Martinez, I suppose he is out of reach. Tiote would probably do, but his passing is very poor.

RedDevil19

Agree0 Disagree0

Carrick is completely a defensive midfielder

Agree0 Disagree0

If we are to really become a force again we should do both. 1 "good prospect" ball winner should be signable for 15 to 20 million. 30-35 for a moura type. Thats up to 55m there. With our present signings that would take our spending to 70m. Is that too ambitious for man u? The glazers are feeding off man u, but they are not senseless. The team needs to be strengthened for Man United to remain the profitable business it has been.

We have already seen Man United make a 32m bid for hazard, and ferguson has said we might sign one or two more.

I wouldn't be surprised to see us sign two more players of quality this window, and then not spend anything for the next 2-4 years, other than odd 5 to 7 million transfers. Im not saying I would approve of it, but I can imagine the glazers thinking this way. Ultimately they need a team with 3 or 4 good players, and 1 or 2 stars to brand and sell Man United abroad. I think they will maintain that level type of level for their own sake. If we reach that level they will stop spending, if we are under it they will make "investments." Its up to our management from there really to make the best of it.

Agree0 Disagree0

No, Carrick is a ball winner. The need for a midfielder with 'steel' is outdated, in my opinion.

MDJ

Agree0 Disagree0

There are so many rumours floating around about CAM and wingers linked with united, but i'd bet non of them are true and Sir Alex have someone in mind that is not in the news......so for me the less said about a player in the news, the more chance there is that we might be talking to him.

Cape Town, SA

Agree0 Disagree0

Why is everyone so hyped up about strootman and m'vila

Agree0 Disagree0

With Chelsea buyin won't b long before city start we need to move quick what do u think our chances are on mvila and muniain

Agree0 Disagree0

Barca & madrid both have strong ball winners..... biscuits & khedira

whilst they are not out and out DM's (destroyers) they do this job whilst being able to play. Carrick is the closet we have to this but unlike these 2 he is not very quick across the ground to break more play up...... and he is not that strong on the ball or a strong runner.....

strootman would be a great shout for this type of player, but even so both m'vila and martinez are technically very very good.... we should be looking at someone of this type to fill in behind the players we already have.

oxred

Agree0 Disagree0

MDJ - Carrick id not a ball winner. Fletch was. Carrick sits deep and passes but thats it.

Unnamed poster - All Barcas midfielders are ball winners. Aggressive, nonstop pressing and they can all tackle pretty well. If you think Iniesta doesn't tackle, try watching him play!

There is a difference between lumpish Parker/Barry style holding midfielders and midfielders who can tackle and intercept passes, which is what we need, and what you see at teams like Madrid and Barca.

Agree0 Disagree0

I personally prefer two holding midfielders, Carrick and Scholes with four flaire players in front of them moura, kagawa, valencia and rooney up front. Is everyone forgeting that we only had scholes for half a season... he was still one of our outstanding players! carrick,scholes,anderson,fletcher and cleverly more than enough central players for me. also not finishing all the chances we created let us down also, thats where i think moura and kagawa will fit in....

Agree0 Disagree0

Agree with first no name and MDJ.

M.D.

Agree0 Disagree0

MDJ - the need for a ball winner is a must in a team like ours.

There aren't many of our players left that we can talk about as being world class.

We just don't keep the ball well enough to do without a combative midfielder.

Agree0 Disagree0

Typical English view.What about Barcelona? Who are their enforcers? Or Madrids?
You cant tackle anymore,it's all about positional play and intercepting the ball in midfield now.Dont't give the ball away so you don't have to get it back" - Busqeuts plays a Makelele type role and can tackle, and Khedira is just one such exampel for Real Madrid. Also neither of these teams play in the premiership which is a very physically demanding league in comparison to the Spanish one. Personally apart from Martinez I just dont see a single central midfielder out there who would be possibly available and good enough. M'Vila looks ok, Strootman looks pretty average at best from what I have seen. Tiote isnt good enough for Man Utd. Do any of these players really improve us bar Martinez who would command a ridiculous fee?
Invisible Stuey

Agree0 Disagree0

Carrick plays deep and his positioning and reading of the game is good, but his mobility is very poor. He works well in a 5man midfield where there are other players that can close opposition down. Our centre midfield is usually 2 players. If neither of them have any mobility - as we saw last season with no fletcher or cleverly, we have a real problem.

Irrespective of controling possession, u still need players that can move so that they can get into the correct positions quickly and maintain the teams shape, aswell as avoid being dribbled too easily. Players like ineista and busquets and even xavi are still very nippy. Last season carrick played well when he was in possession, but players still moved through our midfield like a breeze because theres simply no speed and agility there. Its no wander we conceded goals out of the blue all the time.

I dont like to knock carrick because i like his game. Honest player, with great distribution and decision making, but as an out and out centre mid he is a weakness to us, especially when playing alongside an aging midfielder or when there are inexperienced centre backs behind him.

Agree0 Disagree0

I love how the need for midfielders with steel is outdated when the winners of the English, Spnaish, German and Italian leagues all play with tough physical players in the centre of the park. People aren't saying that we need someone to sit in-front of the defence, what we need is someone with a big physical presence who can boss the midfield.

Lucas will not solve our problems. If he is bought, and that's a big if, Nani will be sold and lucas will play on the wing. What we need is a Toure, Vidal, Martinez, etc who can take the game by the scruff.

Danny Pughnited

Agree0 Disagree0

It maybe an english view but it's a view taken by alot of clubs in and outside of england. To play possession football you need players who can win you possession in the first place. The role of that play has evolved though. No longer can you be like Makelele and just tackle and defend the space between the penalty area and the halfway line. You need to be a proper footballer and be comfortable in possession and a very good passer of the ball, i.e. be a more complete footballer.

90% of the teams we played last season were infact english and in england the game is still much more physical than abroad. As such we need players who can play that much more physical game.

At the moment we only have Carrick who plays in a more defensive way. Jones hasn't the technical ability, Fletcher is unlikely to play again and Scholes can play deeper but he can't play that defensive role for 90 mins. Where as we have Cleverley, Anderson, Scholes, Kagawa, Powell and probably Petrucci who are ball players and can keep and move the ball. If Carrick were to be injured for a few months then we would have no one to hold our midfield together and would in effect be wide open. IMO the signing of Kagawa and the way he plays could mean we need a more mobile box to box player who has a strong defensive ability.

Shappy

Agree0 Disagree0

I think Fergie believes fletch will be back and feels that he will provide the steel we need also Jones can step into that roll if need be he has a year of experience and can only improve but I may be mistaken

Agree0 Disagree0

Will someone please explain the fundamentals of Football to this eejit. What he just said is " I don't want brilliant footballers playing for Man Utd" ....why don't we see if we can get Glenn Whelan from Stoke, would that make you happy.....Grrrrr I love this site but it makes me pull what little hair I have left out of my head sometimes....that is all

Agree0 Disagree0

Moutinho....

All this talk about being able to attack and defend makes me think Moutinho would make an excellent partner for Carrick in CM. We don't need an out and out DM as many have said

Carrick makes interceptions and tracks back, Moutinho would do the same but also enjoys the 'bite' of a challenge - so defensively we'd be sorted. Both are excellent playmakers from midfield - and Mout's can do it at a quicker tempo than Carrick - so we'd be sorted in that sense too. At £25m he could be a great investment! Possibly the perfect fit?

Personally I prefer Modric because of the additional flair he brings but I'm starting to think the slightly cheaper option of Moutinho could be even better because of his ability to defend as well as set up play

Just a shame there don't seem to be strong rumours linking us to the player! : (

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 09:36:06
so munich have confirmed they will not be buying martinez as "bilbao have made it clear it will cost 40 mill euro"
so does this mean martinez is available for 40mill euro and do people think his worth it?
jred {Ed002's Note - If he ends up in Manchester I would not be surprised. Heed the words.}

Believable11 Unbelievable2

Blue or Red 002?

Cban {Ed002's Note - Manchester United of course famously wore blue when winning the European Cup. Blue.}

Agree0 Disagree0

Either pay Bilbao the 40 mil or make Jones our much needed steel in the midfield. Moura may be great, but we have Kagawa, Cleverley, Young, Nani, Valencia, and even Rooney to some extent at his position. Also i read somewhere that Subotic may be looking to move to the PL. Worth the money IMO

Sparty On

Agree0 Disagree0

He is worth every penny. I'd pay it myself if I had the money.

RedDevil19

Agree0 Disagree0

I will say that if Martinez goes to City I'll be gutted but not surprised. Still hoping he is the player we bring in this summer though.

Rjmanutd

Agree0 Disagree0

Can't say I'm very familiar with the player but I read on this forum how people rate him.

If he's as good at what he does as everyone says then IMO we should be spending 40 million euros on him because a top quality player in that position is what we are lacking (and will be even more so once Scholes retires).

We have some good midfielders but they are all a bit lightweight.

Andrew B

Agree0 Disagree0

He is well worth the money and that is the type of player we should be buying he's exactly what we need in midfield he should be the priority

Jamal Sanchez

Agree0 Disagree0

You don't have to have a ball winner in midfield if everyone works hard. having a skillful midfield that can win the ball back and more to the point KEEP THE BALL ie Barcelona is what is needed. Modric tackles back, as does Moura, Scholes is better than you think, he usually does a dodgey tackle when needed hmmm.

Agree0 Disagree0

Ok Ed-en002. Chelsea it is then ;)

TK-Red

Agree0 Disagree0

Ed02... very cryptic.... so you see him going to city then?

any possibility that we could match the signing on fee and he would take less wages to play for united?

oxred {Ed002's Note - Manchester City are probably looking to replace Nigel De Jong in the summer and Javi Garcia and Javi Martinez were the two players they are looking at. I was told a while back that Inter Milan may make a bid for Javi if they decide not to take Juraj Kucka from co-owners Genoa. I am not convinced that Bilboa will want to sell the player any time soon, and if they do they will want 40M euro with Barcelona and Real Madrid being possible destinations. Garcia has signed a new deal at Benfica so I imagine Martinez will become a serious target for Manchester City who may also face interest from Manchester United. I think Manchester City would have the edge.}

Agree0 Disagree0

Martinez is worth every penny our midfield has been crying out for a player like him.

sparkyred

Agree0 Disagree0

"He is well worth the money" - He looks a very good player but you are talking about the fee like its a baargain. When has any central midfielder gone for a fee anything like that? I can only think of Veron for £28m. He was the best young player in Italy probably at that time and looked ideal also. Im not saying Martinez would be a flop, I think he is a superb player when I have seen him but, that is a LOT of money!
Invisible STuey

Agree0 Disagree0

I hope Martinez signs for us but fear he will be playing for City next season. He is allegedly one of City's targets.

Martinez and Muniain would make is competitive again

Red Man

Agree0 Disagree0

Thanks Ed02... as always

will have to wait and see then... just think that if he came in he would add the quality and steel that we crave in the middle and add another option at cb if needed.....

Oxred

Agree0 Disagree0

"You don't have to have a ball winner in midfield if everyone works hard. having a skillful midfield that can win the ball back and more to the point KEEP THE BALL ie Barcelona is what is needed. Modric tackles back, as does Moura, Scholes is better than you think, he usually does a dodgey tackle when needed hmmm"

Noname - I think the massive bonus with Martinez is that he is good in possession - a good passer - AS WELL AS being a great defender. I agree that we don't need an out and out DM but if there is one player who can perform both roles at once it is this guy!

Not many CM's are worth 40m Euro but the above may be the reason why he is.

Only time will tell of course, I can't see him coming to United unfortunately

Gav

Agree0 Disagree0

Oxred, Ed002,

Do you think De Gea would be a big factor in Martinez choosing us if we had the opportunity?

I'm hoping they are close friends and hopefully De Gea will be in his earhole during the Olympics, does anyone know if Spain have any Olympic matches at Old Trafford?

Hopefully they do and we can get in his ear then as well, alththough I must say I am not suggesting we tap him up :

Ports {Ed002's Note - I don't think he would be.}

Agree0 Disagree0

17 Jul 2012 08:05:30
Do any of the eds know if we are showing an interest in Gerard Deulofeu of Barcelona.

Oxred {Ed002's Note - He will not be sold this summer but could go on loan - there has been interest there, but not from MU.}

Believable0 Unbelievable7

17 Jul 2012 01:37:35
Reports that zenit have bid for eriksen and are in talks.

Yet another player targeted and watched by united goes slipping from our fingers.

Fergies good old slow way when coming to transfers.

LUHG

Believable9 Unbelievable11

LUHG - you are such a negative Nancy.

Firstly - this is all media guesswork.
Secondly - Fergie is hardly slow when it comes to buying someone he actually wants (consider Kagawa and Powell).


I've yet to see a post of yours where you're not just moaning, dear god...

Joe

Agree0 Disagree0

But look at all the comments on the Uniteds page - look at Uniteds own website page about who they have been interested in :
All they wanted was Modric, and United have not made one bid? By the time they buy Lucas Moura they would have spent £34M as Daily Mail suggests - enough to clinch Modric.

Agree0 Disagree0

We are a second rate team these days and fergie keeps telling us there is no value! While citeh Real and Barca keep buying all the best players.
The lies will go on and on and the fans are being taken for a ride.

Agree0 Disagree0

If the manager wanted Eriksen he would have signed him by now. Our primary target is Modric, until Modric goes to Madrid he will continue to be our target. When Modric goes to RM we will then move onto the next target. United wouldn't be pushing for Modric if there was no hope in signing him. Eriksen will not join Zenit.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

I don't think we are going to buy any midfielder we have kagawa,powell and scholes.sec we don't have money any more to compete with big teams now days.all this lucas,eriksen are paper talk. i can see us buying a left back that's all.its disappointing to see how madrid and barcelona,chelsea,juventus and munich get stronger and we keeping getting weaker every year.i guess we have to get used to this. i hate glazer's family so much.

ferdcoast

Agree0 Disagree0

Modric isn't good enough anyway not at that price goes missing in big games if we paid 20 mill I feei we r being mugged don't know anything a out this moura ps quite a few spurs fans I met don't rate I'm either ie modric sed they would drive him to it themselves diehard74

Agree0 Disagree0

According to his agent this morning he is staying at Ajax for another season.

Simmo

Agree0 Disagree0

Whos' the next target Syd? Do you not suspect and worry that if Modric (when Modric) joins Madrid, that Fergie just comes out with the usual tripe about the right player not being available? Why are you not concerned, Syd? We looked appalling at times last season, and thus far we've done little to address the main problems.

RED_SKY

Agree0 Disagree0

Eriksen said he wont move from ajax until either united or barca bid for him

Agree0 Disagree0

R_S, I am not worried as we will strengthen and we will be better next season. I heard Moutinho was next on the list, but Porto seem to be holding teams to ransom for all of their players. After that I am not too sure. The same person that said Modric and Moutinho was our targets 1 & 2 does not believe Eriksen is even on the shortlist.

Sydney!

Agree0 Disagree0

Utd are too slow when it comes to signings, always seem to wait for ages, if the scouts have done there job get on with it and get the signings, all the proven talents are being snapped by other clubs while we watch. At this rate we will go another season without silverware.

Agree0 Disagree0