Manchester United Banter

 

Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.


 
Text Size Adjuster: 18px
18 Nov 2026 00:24:01
In order to view all of today's banter, you may have to visit our Manchester United banter 2 to Manchester United banter 10 pages linked at the bottom of this page.

17 Nov 2026 20:17:46
Those JJ Gabriel videos are a bit embarrassing.

1


17 Nov 2026 20:53:12
He has a clear path to the real Madrid first team, clearer than at utd, where we were already starting to bring him into the first team fold.

Good luck to him, megastardom incoming apparently.

0


18 Nov 2026 00:19:36
For him I wish him success. For his father I hope he fails spectacularly.

Glad to see the back of him. We have enough cr@p to work through.

0


Manchester United's January Transfer Plans

17 Nov 2026 15:20:29
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Manchester United's January Transfer Plans

3


17 Nov 2026 16:36:32
I agree on tomori and bassey. i'd also go for mateta and raum funds permitting. Think both are out of contract in summer. Mateta gives us physicality up front and raum is a solid option at LB who can play and give time for amass or younger LB to develop.

0


17 Nov 2026 17:33:21
I like Bassey and he's always impressed me at Old Trafford.

I'd say a lot hinges on Martinez and if he turns around under Poch. I'd go for Finn Jeltsch or Ganiou.

LB I think we can get Hall in the summer so it can wait.

I think Mateta would be a mistake. Go big for Alvarez or I'd go for a couple cheaper options like Lankshear and Beljo.

Moving on Rashford, perhaps Amad, Mount, Maguire, Shaw now or in the summer is just as important to overhaul this squad.

1


17 Nov 2026 17:37:30
Martinez never been good enough CB in EPL so hopefully he is gone sooner the better.

3


17 Nov 2026 23:24:46
While you have mentioned some solid names shappy can't help but feel they are all second rate signings and what we really don't need is more average squad players.

1


16 Nov 2026 08:41:27
The game has rules. The game has integrity. Do you agree with me that Poch should not have played Balogen in the next game for USA after he was sent off? Even though Trump and Infantino bent the rules.

1


16 Nov 2026 09:30:05
Welcome to planet patrick everyone. What is the purpose of this post? Every player and every Manager seeks to gain an advantage in every game, appealing for throw ins, fouls, penalties, when they know they are not deserved. Yet here you are bizarrely singling out Poch. Imaging how it would have gone done in the US if he had taken your approach.

11


16 Nov 2026 12:33:29
Were you this outraged when they allowed Ronaldo to play at the World Cup or is this just because the Manager involved in this case is the new United Manager and you see it as a good opportunity to get a dig in on them before they've even been sized up for their new tracksuit?

7


16 Nov 2026 12:36:50
Integrity, AJH.
The world and you don't know the meaning of the word.

0


16 Nov 2026 13:42:05
Ronaldo should not have been allowed to play. Balogen should not have been allowed to play. The rules, for everyone, mean a suspension. Trump and Infantino bent the rules.
I was wondering what Poch would have done? I certainly had no intention of having a dig at at him.

The situation was taken out of his hands. I was just wondering that's all.
It's what us aliens on another planet do. We wonder.
Have a nice day earthlings and be nice to each other!

2


16 Nov 2026 14:03:21
But you're 'wondering' to get a reaction and to make a ridiculous point about our manager.

5


16 Nov 2026 14:05:07
Of course Poch did play him. If he hadn't, would that have been a message for Trump and Infantino? Sorry to keep wondering guys! Perhaps it's just out of my disdain for Trump and Infantino!

0


16 Nov 2026 14:13:59
I'm not sure that was Patrick's intention. Not his usual style and he is not someone who tends to look at the negatives.
No they should not have been permitted to play and i don't think poch was left with any choice but to play him in the circumstances.


If the rules allow them to play which they did then he should play them despite the optics.
He did not change or Bend the rules but was allowed to take advantage of a ruling in his favour. Golfers do it in every round.

1


16 Nov 2026 14:40:30
It's the managers job to pick the best players that are available to him, that suit the system and the team on how he wants to play that game and this player is available, it's not the managers job to get involved in politics, that's totally above his pay grade anyway.

6


16 Nov 2026 14:55:36
But what if they did got involved in politics? What if? And thanks Ken, of course I'm not having a go at. Poch or anyone else! I was just wondering that's all!
What if Poch didn't play him. What message would that say to Trump and to Infantino! And to the football world at large!
This is not about corner flag remonstrations or dives in the penalty area this is about real cheating.

Beyond cheating. I like. Poch and feel that he will get this team fit, structured and playing attacking football. What's not to like!

0


16 Nov 2026 15:24:31
Ah yes that is the only time FIFA has ever done something shady/corrupt. Saint of an organization and no one ever cheats/breaks rules in sports.

Truly changed the outcome of the game as well with Balo coming on in the 66th minute already 4-0 up. What a ludicrous post. "Game has integrity" gave me a good laugh. Not for some time it has not.

2


16 Nov 2026 15:37:34
It's never had. That's the point. But if only.

0


17 Nov 2026 08:10:15
Glad you had a good laugh Incass! Pity you did not understand. My post was not to be taken literally. If Infontino's intervention had been disregarded how would that have affected his standing? But of course Poch had to play him. No reflection on him. It was on Infantino.

0


17 Nov 2026 10:57:33
There is a subtle difference between what the rules allow and what we might perceive as fair or right.

The difference is that the rules are absolute, unbiased, and the same for everyone. Whereas our perception of mortality is less fixed and contextual.

I understand the feeling that maybe on a moral basis Pochettino might have chosen not to play Balogan. However, he is also obligated to do everything within the rules of the game to secure his side winning matches. Would he be doing right by his players, his employers, and the fans by making a decision that potentially impacts their ability to qualify for a major tournament?

I am someone who has a strong sense of justice and fairness (thanks ADHD), but we also have to understand that the world is far more complex than a simple binary right/wrong. That perspective, and context can change a persons opinion on what is right or wrong. We also need to remember it is just our opinions, opinions we are entitled to have, but that only hold limited relevance and are subject to change.

Part of me thinks that maybe he shouldn't have played Balogan in that game, but another part of me understands that he was doing what was best for his players, fans, and employer. Which actually makes me happy that he'll be our new manager, as I know he'll always put the club, the players, and the fans first.

1


Crystal Palace v Liverpool - A Quick Liverpool Perspective

16 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Crystal Palace v Liverpool - A Quick Liverpool Perspective

1


15 Nov 2026 16:35:02
On a non football subject, as a Welshman I have only just come back down to earth after the staggering, stupendous and mind blowing experience of beating the All Blacks at Cardiff in the Rugby Union yesterday, for the first time in 73 years! (Redman was probably in his 20s then).

It was so totally unexpected, the bookies gave us a 3% chance of winning, and the awe inspiring, they shall not pass, defensive performance of the last 20 mins was just the sort of commitment I want to start seeing at O.T.

The best description I can give to the performance is by using the Welsh word ''hwyl'' there is no direct English translation but it means a deep emotional attachment to a communal, national activity and this has certainly had an effect in this country.

If anyone saw the game, the prepared response to the ABs Haka, with them in a darkened stadium under a spotlight was awesome but having the Welsh team bathed in red light surrounded by smoke was spine tingling. That was the Dragons breath.

Finally, don't know if it was just on our local news, but after the game they were interviewing supporters leaving the ground and they spoke to a woman, with her husband. They must of been in their 50s and she said 'It was the best day of her life' Her husband said 'surely not, it was our wedding' she went quiet for a second, looked at him and said 'no, it is today' That's what the day meant.

Sorry to prattle on, but it was a day I never thought I would see in my lifetime and indeed a tear or two fell at full time, although I swore to those I was with it was just an allergy!

6


15 Nov 2026 18:00:32
Ed, Discussions page? Talk about being sent into the hills!

0


https://talksense.uk/uploads/thumb_83465ef516bbaf3fc5d18c1981c94341.jpeg avatar{Ed033's Note - Not football related.

0


16 Nov 2026 12:59:22
You should bask in the glory of a brilliant result for Wales. It brought me great pleasure watching England beat the All Blacks at the last WC.

It was a David Vs Goliath moment for Wales!

1


16 Nov 2026 16:52:13
Thanks for moving it Ed.

0


https://talksense.uk/uploads/thumb_83465ef516bbaf3fc5d18c1981c94341.jpeg avatar{Ed033's Note - ok thanks.

0


Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

15 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

1


14 Nov 2026 14:00:23
I listened to a story today being told by Ricky Lambert from his time under poch.
"On mondays he does running, every monday.
12 horseshoe runs inside 45 seconds for each.
Most the lads could do it but but hated it and a few like me struggled. The english lads just were not used to it. So i told the squad id talk to him. I went in with jos hovland and we told him how we felt as a squad, he was brilliant he really listened to us and we left feeling heard and were happy.
Next monday we came in and we had to do double the programme 24 horse shoe runs each.
He never said a word.
So afterwards the squad got together and decided it was his way or the highway. We improved individually and as a team because we backed him.
If they back him they will all improve."
Alderweild was on the same podcast and said he will run run run them and those who can't do it will be gone.
You need to show him every day that you want to win every dual win every sprint win every 5 a side. If you don't show the desire he won't trust you. You need to be doing extra gym eating right extra finishing or technical practise. He wants you to prove you want it.
Intesting to hear things from their perspective.
Some are in for a bit of a shock and some will thrive under him.
Who falls on each side of the line will be up to themselves. But there are some that we know will struggle.
Interesting 2 months ahead.

10


14 Nov 2026 15:54:30
Interesting Ken.

0


14 Nov 2026 18:11:44
I hope he brings this work ethic but the problem still remains who will want to buy our re rejects and be able to pay their huge wages.

1


14 Nov 2026 18:22:53
A few go in the summer out of contract Salford
Maguire Shaw martinez maybe bruno and you will see a couple or more from mount rashford dalot maz amad zirkzee move on hopefully.
Lots of big hitters on the way out.

2


14 Nov 2026 20:34:35
What we need Ken. Could be the making of mainoo.

2


14 Nov 2026 21:03:24
Amorim literally did all of this already. He also got the team running and pressing - that did not go down well with Mainoo.

8


14 Nov 2026 21:04:16
We can only hope ken, fitness, effort, application is the least we can expect.

2


14 Nov 2026 23:57:27
Ricky is a good lad, for a Scouser anyway 😂.

2


15 Nov 2026 00:13:08
In fact it did go very well with Mainoo. Mainoo benefited from Amorims trainings and last year he was much sharper, more mobile and he was covering the most (or thereabout) ground for our team. Now, as good as he is, he is not as sharp as he was past year.

5


15 Nov 2026 07:00:00
Jesus, RA never played Mainoo, he clearly didn't rate him. Carrick picked him. And after a sluggish start he got better and better. All down to Amorim eh? As for this year, injuries have hampered him, which is why he isn't fully up to speed.

1


15 Nov 2026 07:11:40
I'm with Am14, and not just with Mainoo but the whole squad. The fitness RA had built into the team helped Carrick in his earlier games and we have since got more and more sluggish.

7


15 Nov 2026 11:56:37
Mainoo looked better end of last season than he has this season.

RA was picking bruno ahead of mainoo, which was a disaster. I do think RA's prep and fitness was better for the team, but there were other reasons he was not a good fit.

Mainoo is player who needs to show more, he looks a world beater when he physically imposes himself on a game. But this season he has let games pass him by a little. I just feel poch's demands for fitness and running could work well for him.

2


15 Nov 2026 12:27:10
Agree with you Heaven and Am14. No point in discussing what's blatantly obvious with some here though as they made up their mind that Carrick's team talk before the City and Arsenal games last year were all that mattered and discounted all the underlying stats that pointed towards progress in every facet, or ignored that we saw a steady performance decline that carried through to this year.

Hopefully we've seen the end of people with short termist agendas winning through with their "results now are all that counts" nonsense.

4


15 Nov 2026 12:28:21
Mainoos physical condition last year was down to Amorim ofcourse. Is there a debate;

1


15 Nov 2026 15:29:46
Who cares it's history good riddance to RA and Carrick both not required standard anyway, Milan want rid of RA now, supporters don't like the crap he is serving up. But again who cares he is history

New broom with Poch, but Bruno will stay along with Rashford Poch will want both
Mainoo just might well struggle under Poch, he struggles to cover the ground that Poch wants from his midfielders.

Yoro & Heaven will lack the experience Poch likes from his CBs

Poch also likes a experienced keeper, so Lammens could be in trouble too

Going to be some interesting times ahead but at least he will set an organised front foot pattern. fingers crossed.

2


15 Nov 2026 16:10:31
Milan are in cl place lost 1 game in their 1st 11 won 7 drew 3 and are closer to top 5 points after 11 games than they have been for 8 years and the fans are delighted players are delighted.
It remains to be seen if he can keep it up but he has done well there so far.

4


15 Nov 2026 17:01:51
I care because Mainoos version last year was better. I was surprised with the intensity Mainoo played, i didn't know he had it in him.
Amorim what he said about Mainoo was right, he couldn't play in his system. Its not like he didn't rate him, he simply wasn't ready for such demanding role. Then Mainoo stepped up, worked hard and upped his running stats and intensity.

Carrick benefitted from Amorims work with Kobbe. Ofcourse credit to Mainoo himself who work really hard.
We can all see that this year Mainoos intensity in comparison to lats season is like day and night. So, its ok to not like Amorim. Its not ok to rewrite history.

2


15 Nov 2026 17:49:51
Everybody's fitness was better last year. As for Mainoo, he started the seaosn very strong but has picked up knocks. He will continue to be first choice in the centre.

0


15 Nov 2026 19:10:47
Milan against ferencveros was the as dull as any game I have ever watched. Amorim for me played football that was not enjoyable to watch.

0


15 Nov 2026 20:28:40
JSU your takes are wild. Do you really think Poch will want Rashford. He wants players who will be selfless and work for the team. I cannot think of anyone in the squad who has more to prove on that front than Rashford.

3


16 Nov 2026 05:56:44
lol. Ask fans at Milan if they want RA, even directors want him out, the football is atrocious the crowd are flat, yes he won a few drawn a few, this is Milan . To say he done well is laughable, come over here and see hear and see the thoughts about RA you my change your mind.

Yes there is a good chance that Poch wants Rashford, he may like him like you love RA, no rhyme no reason just plain stupidity but we know it does happen.

1


Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

14 Nov 2026 14:00:05
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

2


15 Nov 2026 01:50:16
Well I have sat on the fence for all previous incoming managers but for some reason I feel this is an appointment I am uncomfortable with. He is very unlikely to be supported with the right buys. If he is then that itself is an indictment on the owners for throwing previous managers under a bus.

He will therefore ruffle some boys club feathers and be out on his ear sooner than any of us want.

Of course I will support him as the gaffer of my team as I have all previous ones with the possible exception of EtH and hope to be proven totally wrong but I am not confident.

1


14 Nov 2026 09:49:24
I am delighted they saw sense over Carrick, that has to be said. This is a key moment where the club has now been badly bitten twice making the same emotional decision to appoint a loved ex player who then becomes a major wrench to remove. This must never happen again. Knowing, played for or loving the club is not a requirement to being manager. In fact it should be the reason not to appoint one. Never again.

Poch. Massive upgrade on Carrick. To be seen whether he is the long term manager to bring titles, but I do like his passion , style and note he likes to develop youth, something Carrick seemed averse to. Two and a half year contract as Head Coach, not manager is sensible. Gone is the ridiculous 6 year Moyes type deal.

The decision to appoint Poch is interesting. Came very left field. Despite the briefing they all agreed, I can’t help feel that he wasn’t Wilcox or Berradas first choice. From Carrick and the mooting of pliable Eddie Howe to the passion of Poch, it seems distant from what Wilcox showed his previous vision to be. Not least because Wilcox couldn’t control Amorim, I think Poch could be a lot stronger than Amorim, the same South American Latin fire that Martinez showed.

My hope now is for a change in the DOF position, Wilcox first. Ideally soon and someone Poch can work with, someone unlike Wilcox. I have seen Paul Mitchell mentioned. Referring back to the emotional decision making, it shouldn’t be VDS just because he knows the club.

I don’t think anyone thinks sacking Carrick, appointing Poch solves everything. Only new ownership and no debt sets us on that road, and likely that means no Berrada or Wilcox. Let’s hope the sale rumours have some reality. For now we can look forward to games without the emotional garbage of the manager discussions. Good luck Poch.

4


14 Nov 2026 12:11:16
I wouldn't say we should never hire another manager who has played for or who has a connection to the club. What if the best manager in the world is a former player?

I think the lesson to learn from this is that a former player is not the right option to get us back to where we want to be. It's romantic, and we would all love for someone like Ole or Carrick to be the man to get us back to the top, but it wasn't to be.

I think what we need to do is to draw a line under trying to go backwards to move forwards, and instead look at what is needed NOW to be successful rather than what was it we did before to be successful.

I think one of the things we get wrong when looking for a new manager is that we are trying to replace Sir Alex the manager, when in the final decade or more he was more of a DoF and his assistant manager was more of a head coach.

We keep trying to find the next SAF as a manager, but without understanding that he didn't rebuild the club entirely on his own. However, by the time he retired he was the entire management structure at the club. He was our DoF, our manager, our head of recruitment, our academy pathway manager, and we also lost David Gill as our CEO.

We have never adequately replaced that structure, at least not in a coherent way, until INEOS took over.

Now they obviously haven't got everything right, I think they've identified the key roles that are needed, and they have tried to recruit the best available for those roles. But clearly not every hire has been a total success, some could even be considered failures. That happens in every walk of life at every level. No one gets everything 100% right at the first time of asking, in fact they might not ever get everything 100% right.

On paper Barrada was a good option to come in as CEO, and I'm not saying he has been entirely bad in his role. I'm sure there are several things he's done really well. However, his close personal friendship with Wilcox will have certainly caused him to have blind spots and probably make poor decisions because of that.

Dan Ashworth was a very good appointment, probably on paper the best of the bunch. But a combination of others having the ear of key people and them not liking/agreeing with what he said was needed/where we were led to his position becoming untenable.

Jason Wilcox on paper was a very good option, he had big club experience with City and was doing great with Southampton. His role within Cities well run and highly successful academy made him stand out as a candidate for a club that has a history of success from their academy, but which is currently not as strong as it needs to be. However, a combination of Wilcox's personality and him having a close friendship with our new CEO, has led to a blurring of the lines of his remit and his controlling nature meaning he has upset a lot of people at the club and his decision making possibly effected by his need to micro-manage.

Barrada saying we can be challenging for the title again in 2028, came from Wilcox himself, which went against the timeline Ashworth believed was realistically possible. Ratcliffe wanted the club to be back challenging as soon as possible, and when presented with Ashworth saying it will take at least 5 years, while Barrada and Wilcox saying they can be back in 3 created tension.

The fact that after Ashworth left they didn't replace him, but promoted/amalgamated his position with Wilcox's role further highlights the power and influence that Wilcox had, as well as his need to control things.

He has since had several fallouts with Vivell over recruitment, and every time he has gone against Vivell the decision has ultimately always gone the way of Wilcox. Why hire a recruitment expert to then repeatedly ignore their advice.

He has also upset several managers by trying to dictate tactics and team selection to them. While Wilcox was a good coach/manager at youth level, he has never shown himself capable at the highest level, or even senior level. The fact that he thinks he can, and should, overrule managers with actual experience and a track record in senior football at the highest level suggests a level of arrogance that cannot be backed up with evidence from Wilcox.

In short, we got the role and responsibilities right, but hired at least one wrong person for one of those roles. Until they correct that mistake it will be difficult to truly get us back on track. The fortunate thing is that previous managers, and current players have turned the spotlight on Wilcox, which should give our new manager more strength to push back against him, and make sure Wilcox understands his position is weaker now and not to overplay his hand. I would think that if there was a clash between Pochettino and Wilcox over the next year or so that it might (and should) be Wilcox who comes out of it with his P45.

3


14 Nov 2026 13:48:55
Perhaps the club could simply sack or redeploy Wilcox elsewhere and allow Vivell to recruit the players he wants.

However, I do believe Vivell will leave at the end of the season when his contract expires. I can't imagine that he would be too keen staying at. the club, given he how poor thought of he is.

The Paul Mitchell for SD would be a good shout. I'd love for Txiki Bergstein to become the DOF for the club. Wilcox has had very little experience as DOF, and by God does it show. Berrada and Wilcox are akin to Dumb and Dumber - slightly harsh on Berrada.

2


14 Nov 2026 14:18:51
you mean berrada and bergstein who were at city when the dodgy dealings started?

2


15 Nov 2026 08:51:21
Shappy,

Considering it seems like practically all our former players are clogging up television, radio, print, Podcasts, twitter etc giving their views, it seems unlikely any of them will ever torn out to be the best manager in the world.

0


15 Nov 2026 17:26:47
Shappy

"What if the best manager in the world is a former player? You asked.

Well, never is a long time, however, look around at how our ex players are doing in management and none of them are doing anything worth talking about. SAF had 12 years of management before OT and he was a true great.
So if we go with only appointing based on experience and track record and ignoring the emotional ex players choice I think we should be safe for my lifetime

There are rumours Poch won't speak to Wilcox, Wilcox needs sacking.

0


Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

14 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - AJH has posted a new article entitled, Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

3



Manchester United Banter 2


Manchester United Banter 3


Manchester United Banter 4


Manchester United Banter 5


Manchester United Banter 6


Manchester United Banter 7


Manchester United Banter 8


Manchester United Banter 9


Manchester United Banter 10


Manchester United Banter Archives


 

 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent