Manchester United Banter 3
Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.
18 Nov 2026 00:24:01
In order to view all of today's posts, you may have to visit our Manchester United Discussion pages and our Manchester United match posts pages.
12 Nov 2026 17:46:39
Doesn't matter if you agree with or not with Michael Carrick sacking
They way the club has handle the whole situation has been an utter disgrace
We used to stand for something
Now just tasteless and no class
12 Nov 2026 18:33:49
I don't think there is a good way to sack someone, especially a club legend, and especially when you aren't sure on being able to secure a replacement.
I'm not happy about it, but I'm also not sure what they could have done hugely different. We also don't know what conversations were going on behind the scenes, what has been said/agreed etc.
12 Nov 2026 19:12:08
Let's see how they handle the sacking of Poch in 6 months😂.
12 Nov 2026 19:26:56
Shappy you have made a good point. I was always told to judge if possible after you hear both sides of a dispute.
We as fans only have vvv limited information.
12 Nov 2026 19:34:56
Three sides to every story. Two opinions and the truth. Not sure we will ever know but we move on with another manager.
I hope above everything that INEOS have learnt their lesson and actually stump up with their promises and give Poch what he needs to operate with.
I remain unconvinced with the appointment so wait with bated breath to be proven wrong. Huge bowl of humble pie awaiting consumption.
12 Nov 2026 16:02:33
Very poor from the club, I'm surprised they didn't have Carrick show Poch around, and have him help pick out a new office chair, before they kicked him out.
12 Nov 2026 16:25:56
I don't have any sympathy for Carrick. He couldn't win games. Van Gaal won the FA cup and was sacked. Now Neville and all media saying how poorly he's treated. He got a job he didn't deserve and has been sacked because we are in the bottom three. Liverpool sacked Slot after winning the league. That's the way it goes.
12 Nov 2026 16:41:08
Regardless of how you feel about Carrick banjoe he should of gone Monday morning it's a reflection of how bad the club is run that he was still in charge.
12 Nov 2026 18:39:38
If carrick felt bad enough or humiluated he would have resigned.
He knew he was going to be fired.
So he did the job he was being paid to do until the end.
Ive no idea where all this carrick is being treated badly comes from.
Neville his mate is just up stirring it up.
Carrick took trading on wed i'm not sure who was there to train from his usual squad only a few.
He was fired today so won't take training tomorrow.
No different to how any other manager is sacked really.
I've a strong suspision that Carrick has known for a bit that he was going to be relieved of his duties and well before the news that poch had agreed to come broke.
I don't know that for sure no more than anybody knows the oppisite is true.
The king is dead long live the new king.
Imo carrick is a very good man. Has handled himself well. He was a brilliant interim and did a really good job. He was offered the role and he didn't live up to expectations. He can leave with his head held high. Despite leaving us in the relegation zone.
12 Nov 2026 18:48:30
I think if the owners treated him with some respect and handled this differently he would have walked away. But they treated him like crap and so he stuck around for his payday, fair play to him.
12 Nov 2026 18:53:49
That's it TW, I have nothing against Carrick and he did well last year but I don't see how he's treated any unfairer than many other managers or some players who got sacked or sold. At some point i think some fans are going to have to decide if they're to be angry with the board and owners all the time or try to help bring some joy and unite the club, because the owners and board are going nowhere and if they're replaced the new ones might be no better or worse.
12 Nov 2026 21:58:08
Spot on banjoe.
There are people here who are just angry and frustrated and i get that.
12 Nov 2026 09:50:19
Potch will fail, it’s almost a certainty. Not because he’s a bad manager or coach, he’s quite obviously an outstanding coach (his managerial tactical decisions are dubious) but there are scores of players who complement his coaching.
Potch is coming into a failing environment, the environment is lead by the CEO and Director of football, under the constraints of the ownership.
We as a club have allowed the creators of the environment to pick the next addition. We essentially let them make a pick to save their skin. Potch is a fairly compliant manager who’s desperate to get back to the prem, he’s perfect for Wilcox and Berrada.
The decision to sign him in the international break is a stupid, the fact we are paying a sizeable fee when there are better options for free tells you all you need to know about why they picked Potch.
Conte/Nagglesman would cause Wilcox problems, the Turkey was never voting for Christmas.
Until the wider issues are sorted, the manager will fail. This is on INEOS exclusively, they’ll happily fire 300 staff but won’t deal with the larger structural issue and give the DoF…….. madness
12 Nov 2026 10:25:51
It's Poch, and you need to define failure.
This team is far better than current performances, we may not be title winning material but a proper coach, with proper tactics, who can improve and motivate players, and give youngsters a chance, will have an impact. I still believe we are a top 4 team despite our current predicament.
12 Nov 2026 11:10:39
I'll settle for a defined system, clear tactics and style of play and some organisation. Go from there.
12 Nov 2026 12:08:57
Wilcox out!
12 Nov 2026 12:59:58
POCH OUT!
12 Nov 2026 13:17:17
Realistically i think Poch could easily be a success and by success i mean establish a floor for the club that we don't go below.
Our last five league finishes have been 3rd, 15th, 8th, 3rd and 6th. That is too volatile for a top club in any league and means we can't recruit consistently as we are not consistently in the champions league and do not have stable revenues as a result.
If Poch can come in and get us consistently finishing in the champions league, have a consistent way of playing on the front foot and bring through some young players, we can at least be in a stable enough position to attract the very best managers (currently Enrique, could be someone else then).
12 Nov 2026 13:23:32
It was going fine under Amorim and Poch's style of play is pretty similar. Carrick obviously took advantage of the coaching he inherited and the players benefited in the short term from a relaxing in some aspects, but mainly - as the stats show - carried on a wave of good fortune.
The main point is that Poch is much more of a direct continuity from Amorim, so I think we could get back to a decent level prettty quickly. The appointment came months later than it should have, but it's a really excellent one.
12 Nov 2026 12:50:18
I find it interesting that all the media sources suggested that Wilcox wanted Eddie Howe, and Vivell wanted Nagelsman. Both were available for free, but the club spent 7m getting Pochettino, so there must be a reason why they are prepared to pay for him when others (also good candidates) were available for free.
I wonder what that means. Did they speak with Howe and Nagelsman and decided it wouldn't work or at least had some serious concerns. Is Pochettino the compromise with neither Wilcox or Vivell getting their preferred choice. How did they come to the conclusion that Pochettino was the right candidate. What does this appointment suggest about the long term future of Wilcox and Vivell.
Ultimately I agree, that unless things change behind the scenes any new manager will struggle. While personally I think that doesn't happen while Wilcox keeps his job. He is a control freak, and has put many people's noses out of place with his micro-managing.
I did say yesterday that maybe replacing Wilcox with Paul Mitchell could be a very shrewd move. I also find it interesting that the club hierarchy met in Monaco, somewhere Paul Mitchell still has a home and spends a lot of time there. His partnership with Pochettino both at Southampton and Spurs showed how well they work together and can get the best out of eachother.
I can't imagine the club would go for a clean sweep and replace the manager and the DoF at the same time. It does make more sense to replace the manager now, while working on an exit strategy for Wilcox over the coming months. They could easily work with Paul Mitchell in a consultancy capacity to aid a smooth transition. Maybe with him taking the role in January.
12 Nov 2026 14:38:41
We can only hope Shaps.
12 Nov 2026 14:41:45
DonRed, not sure why you think they play similar styles. I disagree but I asked AI for a view.
While both Mauricio Pochettino and Ruben Amorim demand high physical fitness, aggressive pressing, and vertical attacking play, their teams differ noticeably in structural rigidity, defensive shapes, and how they create width. Pochettino relies on flexible back-four systems where full-backs provide width, whereas Amorim is defined by a structured back-three setup powered by wing-backs and dual inverted playmakers.
Not that similar.
12 Nov 2026 17:02:13
AJH they are similar. Poch's team transition very often to 3 at the back in a very similar set up to Amorim. The usage of inside forwards is much more similar to Amorim, which suits Mbeumo and Cunha better. Poch effectively attacks with double up wide players, identical to Amorims set up.
As you'll recall I found all this stuff about rigidity with RA to be completely misguided. And whatever analysis AI did doesn't reflect the reality.
12 Nov 2026 17:05:57
After the above AJH I tried out AI on Google myself. Not sure what you asked but this is the response I got just now:
AI Overview
While Ruben Amorim and Mauricio Pochettino favor different base formations, their tactical styles share significant core principles centered on high physical intensity, aggressive pressing, and attacking width provided by flying full-backs. Both managers demand elite fitness levels to sustain front-foot, vertical football.
Shared Tactical Principles
• Relentless Physical Intensity. Both coaches prioritize supreme athletic conditioning and endurance so their squads can outwork opponents. Players must execute repeated high-intensity sprints to close spaces quickly and transition immediately from defense to attack.
• Narrow Inside Forwards and Wide Defenders. In attack, both managers instruct their wide forwards or wingers to tuck inside into the half-spaces. This central overload opens the flanks for ultra-aggressive wing-backs (Amorim) or overlapping full-backs (Pochettino) to provide the team's primary width.
• Central Pressing Traps. Rather than letting opponents play freely through the middle, both systems use narrow attacking shapes to block central passing lanes. They force the opposition toward the touchlines before triggering aggressive, coordinated pressure to win the ball back high up the pitch.
• Brave Build-Up and Verticality. Both managers insist on defenders and goalkeepers who are comfortable playing out from the back to bait the opposition's press. Once the first line of pressure is broken, both teams look to progress the ball vertically and quickly rather than relying on slow, sterile possession.
• Commitment to Youth Development. Beyond pure tactics, both coaches share a philosophy of trusting and developing young players. They rely on the energy, coachability, and hunger of younger squad members to execute their demanding physical systems.
12 Nov 2026 17:21:54
It really depends on the inputs lads. Just argue with your eyes.
12 Nov 2026 17:24:03
I asked Ai again Don and it said:
Pochetino plays fast entertaining football with quick transitions, and uses directness as opposed to long transitions, whereas Amorim is as stubborn as a donkey, welded to a rigid formation, and has only one way of playing, even when losing to a league 2 team or playing against 10 men.
12 Nov 2026 18:50:19
Don and Reuben, up a tree 🎵😁.
12 Nov 2026 19:06:40
Brilliant AjH.
There are some principles that they share but in reality because of the shapes of their set up the flow and pace their teams play at are very different. You would never watch a pochs spurs or southampton side play and say it was similar to amorims sporting or united or now milan (where he is doing fine) in terms of their offensive interplay and areas of attacking intent.
They both play iut very differently from the back also poch likes his teams to progress the ball in as few passes as possible where amorims teams are happy to pass pass pass trying to work through only specific passing lanes. So they are very different in that regard.
Poch is more rounded more experience and a good pair of hands imo for where we find ourselves.
12 Nov 2026 19:46:16
Disagree Ken but that's fine. I don't think AJH we saw eye to eye on Amorim anyway.
12 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Pochettino, United, and the poisoned chalice
12 Nov 2026 08:56:28
Shappy,
Sadly what you say about Mitchell makes too much sense for our current owners to ever consider.
12 Nov 2026 13:33:19
Bilko, that's what I thought while writing it. We do seem to make the most baffling and daft decisions at times.
Although I wonder how much of that comes from Wilcox as our DoF, and whether that changes when they go over his head.
From everything I've heard he is a control freak and micro-manages everything. From being part of the reason behind Ashworth leaving (Ashworth has a close relationship with Dave Brailsford), whereas Wilcox quickly buddied up with Ratcliffe and was rumoured to have Ratcliffe ear over several things that lead to the disagreement that eventually lead to Ashworth's departure). Wilcox is also a close friend of Barrada's, and they rarely disagree on anything. With Barrada backing up Wilcox even on things where he probably shouldn't.
Wilcox has had strong disagreements with Vivell over recruitment, overruling the head of recruitment on signings.
He has fallen out with both EtH and Amorim by trying to dictate to them about tactics and training. Which even if you say we have a head coach and not a manager, that would still be overstepping his position.
For me Wilcox is the biggest problem, while Barrada hasn't covered himself in glory (although I wonder how much of that is down to him being too loyal to a friend).
Until he leaves I think we will continue to struggle.
Paul Mitchell as a replacement just makes too much sense. He has been recommended to the club on several occasions by different people. He's a local lad, and a fan of the club (not the most important thing, but it would certainly make fans feel more comfortable that he has the club's best interests at heart). He has a great track record, has worked well in the Red Bull multi club model. Is available and has worked really well with Pochettino on two occasions already.
Given that supposedly Wilcox wanted Howe, and Vivell wanted Nagelsman, you have to wonder who suggested Pochettino. SAF is a big fan, but I doubt the club are putting too much stock in his suggestions. Ultimately if they have serious questions over Wilcox and Vivell (which given how things are panning out you would have to assume they do if they have any level of competency). Then I can't imagine they would rely too heavily on their input for the next manager. They have also used consultants in the past when they first took over (Vivell was initially a consultant hired to support recruitment). So it wouldn't be a stretch to assume they might speak with one or several consultants about the managers position and potentially options, as well as maybe their views on the issues at the club.
Could Pochettino be the suggestion of a consultant, maybe even Paul Mitchell himself, who is open to consultancy work since leaving Newcastle in 2025. You'd imagine he would be someone he'd strongly recommend.
Maybe I'm adding 2+2 and coming out with 7, because that's what I'd want to see happen. That is normally the case when I speculate to be fair.
There are a lot of other really good options as a DoF, but most os them have limited experience in England, and that seems like something that is high on INEOS's agenda when hiring for key roles. With all of Ashworth, Wilcox, Barrada and Vivell having experience at other EPL clubs before being hired. I don't see them going for a Luis Campos, Micheal Zorc, Simon Rolfes, or Markus Krosche. Despite them all being good candidates for different reasons.
12 Nov 2026 14:27:46
Maybe Fergie had the casting vote and went for his old buddy Poch.
12 Nov 2026 00:13:51
Excuse me for being naive but amongst all the talk about different systems, managers, directors of football and even owners
none of this matters unless the players are
1) properly fit
2) take personal responsibility
3) work for each other & manager
4) have football intelligence
5) have professional pride
6) appreciate the fans
Whether we get Poch or Pep the most important element is the character of the players. Get good characters and that's more than half the battle. Fergie knew it. All successful teams depend on good characters.
12 Nov 2026 00:40:53
Ashley young was saying on goldbridge&rooney this week that the players set the standards for the club in terms of effort and workrate in training. And by the time moyes had left they had lost a lot of it.
Once SAF had set the tone, the dressing room maintained it themselves through the different generations of teams.
12 Nov 2026 07:55:07
I'm actually feeling sorry for Poch that he's coming into a team who don't look up to Premier League fitness standards.
As much as those above Carrick let him down, Carrick also let the team down by not getting them fit during pre-season.
Whether or not he wanted to play a pressing system or a more possession based mid block, they were never going to succeed with out this basic fundamental.
Hope Carrick learns from this at his next job.
12 Nov 2026 08:51:55
Carrick's next gig will probably be a podcast with Jonny Evans where they talk about the old days and slag off the current team.
Seems to be the go to option for ex United players, coaches, scouts etc. these days.
12 Nov 2026 08:56:39
Fitness will be the biggest issue, I just don't see how we get that back especially at this stage of the season. The time for that was preseason but we dropped the ball massively in that aspect and now it's biting us in the backside.
12 Nov 2026 13:00:43
A good manager can bring 1-6 out of them.
12 Nov 2026 13:56:49
You're right, ultimately the reason clubs spend hundreds of millions on players is because the quality of your players is the single biggest factor in terms of team performance.
If we were to break down the impact of different factors for team performance:
Quality of players (Physical, technical, and mental) probably accounts for 70% of your performance.
Managers tactics maybe impact performances by 10%.
Coaching and training maybe impacts it by 10%.
Then the final 10% if down to how the opposition play, as well as marginal things like scheduling (when and where you play, as well as time to recover).
You might have a phenomenal manager, with a fantastic coaching team, and all the stars seem to align for you and all of that combined properly only accounts for 25% of the performance at most. How well you do is still mostly down to your players.
That is why even great managers like Pep have to completely rebuild the squads of the clubs they take over before you really see the impact they can have.
No manager will be able to make Harry Maguire quick and mobile, or keep Shaw fit, or turn Mbeumo into a target man striker.
I get incredibly frustrated with our players, but I genuinely don't think they are bad eggs (with the exception of a few). I just think that the majority of them lack that real killer mentality. I think there are too many sheep who'll blindly follow the loudest voice. They aren't bad players, you could definitely question whether they are top class (most of them aren't), but they aren't bad players. They just seem to lack that elite mentality. When they chips are down they don't have the ability to use that to fire themselves up, they give in to it, accept it, embrace it. Which is why they need a change in manager to come in and change the atmosphere in order for their performances to improve. Because they lack the autonomy to shift their own perspective.
We need to shift out the few bad eggs (Rashford), as well as those who just aren't good enough, and more importantly than signing top players, we need to sign players with that elite mentality and natural leadership.
People talk about Liverpool under Klopp, but the biggest factor in their success was moving Gerrard out and bringing Henderson in. On paper and on the pitch Gerrard was the far more talented player. But his mentality was too self-centred and as such no one else could step out of his shadow and the club relied on him to perform to do well. Henderson on the other hand was an absolute mentality monster, he demanded the best from himself, and he dragged the best out of his teammates. Making Liverpool a better team. They also had players like Milner who was the same.
That is what we are missing, players with the mentality and personalities like Henderson and Milner. And until we get 4 or 5 players into this squad with that mentality then we will struggle to do anything but move between new manager bounce followed by decline until the next new manager bounce.
11 Nov 2026 20:26:48
A bit random but what if Poch turn’s Zirkzee into a new Moussa Dembele?
I’m sure Dembele started as a non scoring forward..
11 Nov 2026 22:20:45
I'll be more impressed if he can turn Dalot into Kyle walker 🤣.
11 Nov 2026 22:24:02
Turn him twords the airport more like.
12 Nov 2026 08:52:37
Dembele didn't start as a non football playing footballer though.
12 Nov 2026 22:29:29
Wouldn't mind Dalot being Kyle Walker *now* let alone then.
11 Nov 2026 15:56:02
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Pochettino, United, and the poisoned chalice
11 Nov 2026 19:06:06
Cue Harry Maguire says "I have always admired Pochettino" press release.
11 Nov 2026 21:43:27
I'm probably most optimistic about Poch than any manager since Mourinho.
I think he'll do fine and develop a lot of what we have and give youth a chance.
12 Nov 2026 04:43:22
It looks like Wilcox has probably dodged the bullet for now doesn't it?
12 Nov 2026 05:46:49
It does look like Wilcox has come away scott free.
It beggars belief that they have thrown 100million away in payments to this point and will waste a lot more before they get it right, and yet still remain in a job.
No visible end to this disaster and a few more months of average results will see them throwing stones internally.
Strap in!
12 Nov 2026 14:08:28
Does it? He took charge of hiring Amorim and Carrick, both were his choices and his preferred options.
Now the club looks set to hire Pochettino, who wasn't Wilcox's choice. He wanted Howe by all accounts.
Not hiring the preferred choice of Wilcox is a break from the last two managers. Which at the very least suggests his stranglehold over the hiring process is not what it was.
That could be an indication that they club is considering a future without Wilcox.
11 Nov 2026 13:30:08
Newnameoldalias how are you paying so much to watch Utd play. If you buy the japan service it will save you a pretty penny. I gave a few other HK sports nbsc etc that provide the service
11 Nov 2026 23:07:24
do please send more details.
11 Nov 2026 13:07:33
Mount has played 4 full games for united in 4 years. 250 grand a week, whoever bought him in should be sacked for that bit of business alone
11 Nov 2026 17:13:01
Is that correct across all competitions Leahy? Wow if so.
11 Nov 2026 19:21:47
Pretty sure that there are few if any of the people who would have had a say in his signing are still at the club.
11 Nov 2026 19:59:09
They are all gone leahy you can relax🤣🤣.
11 Nov 2026 12:38:04
It's a tough job for any manager but I seem to be in the minority that thinks Poch is a good fit. There's a style of play that is entertaining. He seems to improve players. He's prem proven. Has won trophies, although not many. And has the temperament and charisma to be at Utd.
I wanted him when we got Ten Hag. Maybe it's 4/5 years wasted.
Good luck Poch
11 Nov 2026 14:01:25
Great fit will.
11 Nov 2026 14:05:11
I've read a few quotes from ex players who have talked about his demands on fitness, if he still has these standards some of our lot are going to have a much needed shock.
Although this is a very simplistic link, I wouldn't be surprised if we make a move for Robinson of Fulham for LB in January if Poch comes in.
11 Nov 2026 15:58:55
He has a standard that he expects and is prepared to act if players don't meet it. He has enough personality that he won't be quiet if those above him are letting him down. He can handle media. He also has a track record of trusting and developing young players, and players play for him.
Can't honestly think of a better candidate out there right now. Hopefully he makes it a requirement that he gets a new director of football, medical team and recruitment team!
11 Nov 2026 17:17:38
Agreed with all the above. Poch is a great fit. We're very lucky he has wanted the United gig for so long as objectively the leadership team around him is looking extremely incompetent. However we have a decent squad - despite what others here say - and, if we can get at least one fullback in the door in January, he has the tools to rescue the season.
Doing well this season I think is getting a European place of any sort and hopefully a cup run of some sort. Doing average is mid table.
11 Nov 2026 17:56:23
I'll take average at this point DonRed 😂.
11 Nov 2026 18:54:05
I don't think you are in the minority. But I openly admit I am on the unconvinced side of the fence. Part of that is more towards the fact that it looks as though the rotting carcass is still there so he is on a hiding to nothing.
Rinse and repeat is my fear.
I hope he is ready for the fight and drags us into some kind of form.
11 Nov 2026 19:29:00
On another note. Apparently he likes to have lemons in his office. going to need a bigger box!
11 Nov 2026 20:21:06
Whatever happens we have ego give him 3 years and see how he goes.
Anything less is a farce.
I like Poch a lot. Big fan of this appointment.
Manchester United Banter
Manchester United Banter 2
Manchester United Banter 4
Manchester United Banter 5
Manchester United Banter 6
Manchester United Banter 7
Manchester United Banter 8
Manchester United Banter 9
Manchester United Banter 10
Manchester United Banter Archives