Manchester United Rumours Member Posts


BIG V's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing

No Profile Picture uploaded

Team: Manchester United

Where from: Cheshire

Favourite player: Paul scholes

Best team moment: 1999 Treble as a young lad!

Interests: Mufc
Old trafford

Timezone: (GMT) Western Europe Time, London, Lisbon, Casablanca

BIG V's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To BIG V's Posts



To BIG V's last 5 rumours posts


To BIG V's last 5 banter posts


To BIG V's last 5 rumour replies


To BIG V's last 5 banter replies


BIG V's rumours posts with other poster's replies to BIG V's rumours posts


17 Jul 2021 21:45:53
We are signing a young player from liverpool's academy, Imagine it will be announced sooner rather than later.




16 Mar 2021 12:39:47
Hey ed,

Do we have any interest in milenkovic from Fiorentina,

I have seen the Italian papers linking mufc with him.

Thanks in advance.


{Ed002's Note - Try searching.}



13 Mar 2021 17:50:58
Ed, do we know anymore regarding lingard and west ham?

I would like to think they want him and he wants to move, but I have a feeling he will be priced out of the move.


{Ed002's Note - Jesse Lingard (AM) not out of contract but options are reducing. Nice interest has gone as they wanted a loan in January and that option was withdrawn. Atletico Madrid were given a report on the player that caused them to step back. Prior interest of Roma and Real Sociedad switched to a different player. That leaves options in the Premier League with I suspect the player not wanting to move to Newcastle, Leicester City or Sheffield United and wanting to stay on at West Ham United - or are keen he joins permanently. Manchester United may offer to extend to save money on purchases but it won't suit the player.}

1.) 14 Mar 2021 03:18:03
Ed do you think West Ham would have any willingness to make a deal including Rice? Or is that not possible.

{Ed002's Note - No that won't be possible.}

2.) 14 Mar 2021 14:43:27
Surely if Rice goes anywhere it will be to join his good friend Mason Mount at Chelsea.

{Ed077's Note - Chelsea were never really after him. The interest was from Lampard and left with him, at least for now

3.) 14 Mar 2021 15:44:02
That was my understanding, that Chelsea aren’t pursuing him anymore. Would it not be possible because he wouldn’t go to United or because west ham won’t sell?



29 Sep 2020 16:24:30
Looks like the club is enquiring about anyone who is available,

Ed's is cavani available and of interest or has he agreed to go elsewhere,

I wouldn't mind taking him for a year.


{Ed002's Note - Cavani is a Free Agent and the clubs interested don't see the value.}

1.) 29 Sep 2020 18:40:34
wiggy is on his way back.

2.) 29 Sep 2020 18:54:47
Sorry dazw I'm way past it now.

3.) 29 Sep 2020 19:29:47
No bid yet, intermediate parties discussing, we will only bid once an agreement is found.

4.) 29 Sep 2020 19:57:23
me to wiggy.



23 Aug 2020 11:07:04
Hey ed,

I seen a while back there was reports we was looking to bring in Ricky jade jones from Peterborough,

Was it just paper nonsense or is there real interest.


{Ed002's Note - Try searching - I told you there was interest.}




BIG V's banter posts with other poster's replies to BIG V's banter posts


22 Jun 2021 15:46:34
After seeing the financial results in detail, not much has changed for us,

Money is there to spend, just hope the club is sensible with there deals and stop over paying for players.

Sancho for starters they should walk away at that price.


1.) 22 Jun 2021 16:51:44
To be honest i am absolutely sick of hearing about the Sancho thing, there are other areas that we need to strengthen much more than right wing like two new central midfielders, a centre back and a forward. We have plenty of cover on the right in Greenwood, Amad, Mata etc.

2.) 22 Jun 2021 17:04:06
Forget Mata, he needs to be released a d stopping blocking the path of the youngsters who are ready for first team football.

3.) 22 Jun 2021 22:50:50
I don't get the Sancho love to be honest, we need to go after a fast paced right winger who can put the ball in the box.

4.) 23 Jun 2021 09:32:24
Sancho as a player is clearly talented and he fits what we need in terms of skills on the pitch.

He also fits the club's "ideal" signing criteria, i. e. young (under 25), high profile, British etc.

Which means he is one of the rarer cases of a player that the team needs AND he works well from a branding/ marketing perspective.

That said there needs to be a balance between putting our efforts into signing a player like Sancho and making sure we aren't putting all our eggs in one basket.

I'm 95% confident that we will sign Sancho this summer. My concern is that the sheer cost in terms of money AND time spent sorting the deal will be detrimental to other possible signings.

If someone offered you Sancho and Varane or Raphinha, Varane and Rice which option do you think strengthens us more?

5.) 23 Jun 2021 13:11:12
Shappy, tbh I would take Varane, Raphinha and Rice and we get sorted in all positions of need.



20 Jun 2021 15:58:45
How good has f1 been this season, really competitive.

Its the last year before all the changes take place, I hope that Ferrari get there act together and become competitive again.


1.) 20 Jun 2021 19:24:00
Fabulous race. Edge of the seat stuff.



18 May 2021 16:39:07
If Leicester don't get top 4 I'd like us to have a go at getting ndidi.

There are a few players in the prem that could be really good players for the top 6

Saint maxim from Newcastle
Pereira from west Brom
Bissouna from Brighton.

Not first team players but could replace


Anyway silly season is not long away and I hope everyone shows the Ed's some respect with the news they share.


1.) 18 May 2021 16:47:18
Bissouma is very good Big V. Not sold on the other two. ASM just looks a proper show pony with very little end product.

2.) 18 May 2021 17:12:18
Personally I prefer to sign players from within the league or even in the Championship. Players who are settled in England, understand the style of play and can cope and thrive in it. While fancy names from foreign leagues get most fans pluses going, they more often than not fail to deliver on the hype.

Currently in the EPL there is:
Grealish, Watkins and Konsa at Villa.
Saka, Smith-Rowe, Gabriel, Tierney and Partey at Arsenal.
Bissouma, Dunk and Lamptey from Brighton.
Mee and McNeil at Burnley.
Zaha and Eze at Palace.
DCL, Godfrey, Richarlison, Digne and Allan at Everton.
Anguissa and Andersen at Fulham.
Ndidi, Barnes, Maddison, Justin, Fofana and Tielemans at Leicester.
Wilson at Newcastle.
Ward-Prowse, Bednarek, and Adams at Southampton.
Kane, Son, Hojbjerg, Bergwjin, Lo Celso, and Reguilon at Spurs.
Rice, Soucek, Diop, and Coufal at West Ham.
Neto, Jimenez, Neves, and Podence at Wolves.

There are 46 players off the top of my head that would improve our squad, with many of them more than capable of stepping into our first 11 and improving it immediately. I have deliberately not included players at Liverpool, City and Chelsea who just won't sell players to us.

3.) 18 May 2021 18:46:14
The fancy names from foreign leagues that city sign seem to do the job more often than not.

4.) 18 May 2021 18:56:59
DDG which ones? Walker? Sterling? Mahrez? Ake? Stones?

5.) 18 May 2021 19:23:28
But they have a proper coach dsg.
Shappy chelsea have often sold players to us.

6.) 18 May 2021 20:17:29
Shappy, just one word - Ruben Dias. What a revelation he has been.
Ferran Torres is another wonderful player.

7.) 18 May 2021 20:26:39
That's 2 words . Ruben dias.

{Ed014's Note - alright picky! 🤣

8.) 18 May 2021 21:20:15
I remember Ed 2 saying ferran Torres had been recommended to us as a cheaper alternative to Sancho last summer. He would have made a difference although I am sure he has benefited from better coaching than he would have received at united.

9.) 18 May 2021 21:29:37
TrueRedDevil, there are always great players who come in from abroad and do well.

The best teams have often bought 3 or 4 of the best players from their own league to build a great side.

Liverpool won the league last year with only Alisson, Fabinho, Salah and Firmino as regulars in their starting 11 who were signed from sides outside big the UK. Of which Salah has previous EPL experience. Mane, Henderson, VvD, Milner, Robertson, Wijnaldum, Lovern, Gomez all signed from EPL or Championship sides. While TAA came through their own academy.

While Dias has been great, I would argue that Stones has been every bit as impressive for City this season. While Walker, Sterling and Mahrez have also been vital for City in their title win.

Signing the best players from your own league is less of a gamble, and they weaken your opponents. It's a win win situation, and something we should be looking to do more.

10.) 18 May 2021 21:38:06
I don't trust our amateur recruitment Shapps.
For example, we signed Maguire from our league rivals to make them stronger.

It was a win-win situation for them and not us lol :)

11.) 18 May 2021 21:52:53
Shappy if you are arguing stones was every bit as impressive as Dias then your talking absolute and complete bolloxollogy.
We have signed maguire who you keep telling us we can't win a league with. Shaw 1 very good season in 6. Mata Chelsea player of year. Schniderlin. James. Awb. Sanchez. None have propelled us forward in fact some have taken us backwards.
Not too many win wins there.
No guarantees from the epl either. Liverppol signed plenty of duds from epl teams prior to klopp.
Salah never played in epl
Any signing being a success is down to a huge variety of things least of them is what league you played in prior. Most important is the coach and team you are moving to.

12.) 18 May 2021 20:47:08
No seriously take a look back at all the players shappy has suggested this season from outside the epl 🤣
Trd we need more like we got from epl and efl sides the last 8 years. Mata schiederlin lukaku SANCHEZ James grant Shaw maguire awb.
There is no guarantee on any player regardless of where he comes from.
Mata was winning leagues champion leagues fa cups leagus cups feckin World cups before we got him.
There have also been big successes but none in the last 8 years from the epl. Shaw is here 6 years and had 1 very good season.
Its a daft argument as there are no guarantees. Rvn japp stam big Pete no epl experience rvn Yorke Cole all had.
Cantona 12 months epl experience.
Bruno had none.
Get the right characters in and while there is merit in being comfortable with the language and culture its not a pure requisite imo.

13.) 19 May 2021 10:01:46
Shappy sometimes I just have to nod my head at some stuff you come out with stones as good as dias? you really do worry me at times. just to add gundogan, jesus, aguero, laporte, rodri, kevin de bruyne, bernando silva, ferran torres, mendy, cancelo, ederson I would argue these players had a far bigger impact on citys season than most of the players bought from the league, I get what yours saying buying within the league but when the good players go to city and liverpool we are left with second rate players in the league like some of the lads posted further up it made us worse by buying within the league since fergy left.



04 May 2021 17:18:00
The glazers won't be selling.

Although I don't think them putting debt onto the club is right, they have spent on players each year.

The stadium and training ground and surrounding areas need work.

The fans forum should be working for them to modernise the club and not trying to force them out.

Be very careful they don't strip the club to bare bones and sell everything off and leave us in a right mess because they have the power to do so and these tactics could really back fire.


1.) 04 May 2021 17:31:58
Thats a good post BIG V. They accuse them of taking dividends, previous shareholders didn't get dividends?

2.) 04 May 2021 17:52:41
I don't know why it's half the post. I mean the problem with Glazers os the stadium. I have no problem for them to leave but only if better owners arrive.

3.) 04 May 2021 18:21:27

4.) 04 May 2021 20:57:40
I wouldn't live with that fear Big V. What could they do? Sell the stadium and make us play at the cliff?

Sell all our players (something we're woeful at by the way) and then see us drop down the league?

These are guys that if they could, they wouldn't spend a penny. There's a fine balance between minimum investment and no investment.

If they decided to strip the club bare, how far would they get? That's not what will happen.

Once their bottom line takes a hit they will sell. Try and make an exit strategy and sell the club for circa £4 billion. Or try and sell everything peice meal and be left with a fraction if that amount?

They will try and wait out the storm. It could be possible of course. But IF sponsors start worrying, the value of the club will start to fall. That's when they will weigh up their options and see what the best solution will be.

Don't be afraid of what might be around the corner. If you're in a poor relationship you should try and get out and improve it. It may not work, but scaremongering isn't the way.

If they are hit in their pocket they will leave. There's a few family members getting a slice of this cheese. As the value drops, like the rats they are, they'll leave with the biggest slice they can get.

5.) 04 May 2021 21:13:10
I mean they could sell the stadium to be knocked down and the land developed, they could then agree to a long term deal to play at the Etihad. Pocket all the cash from the stadium sale, while the fees paid to City to play at their stadium would come out of the clubs operating profit meaning less funds for transfers.

That would be a bit of a kick in the teeth.

6.) 04 May 2021 21:14:30
They haven’t spent a penny!

7.) 04 May 2021 21:15:33
it's in their interest to maintain the asset value that's right mumbles.
If the financial performance suffers then they will review but as long as the cash is rolling in they will sit tight.
But other owners could well deliver a worse set of problems.
I think they will ride this storm and the only way the storm won't pass is if income suffers.
But they will sell the naming rights to the stadium before they go would be my guess.

8.) 04 May 2021 21:38:42
Shappy, you think they're getting planning permission from the council to rip down Old Trafford and build apartments?

Ken, I do think they have a couple of aces up their sleeve in terms of income they could go to. Stadium naming rights is a good shout. And if new owners came in they would want a return on a until billion pound investment. I know the dangers of rolling the dice.

But right now the dice is a 2. We have owners that couldn't care less if we win another thing. I don't expect any owners to not get a return on their investment, but I would like owners who would speculate to accumulate. They're not mutually exclusive. We could have owners that take their slice but also have ambition.

£1.5 billion on a £600 million loan that currently sits at £515 million. That's absolutely criminal. They could have long paid off that loan and invested in their "investment". They're poor business people.

9.) 04 May 2021 21:40:28
Gds2 every single penny that the club generates belongs to them. If they didn't spend it on players and financing they would take it anyway its all their money. Its theirs because they own the club whether we like it or not. Any money generated belongs to them and they can spend it take it reinvest it or take it out just like any company owners anywhere.
We may not like it but legally it is their money. So saying they haven't spent a penny is wrong i understand the sentiment and I understand the frustration with it I understand the leveraging and the finances but its all their money. They own the business and its revenues. They have been supremo supremely clever if you were to put a dream deal and business model together from their point of view its the deal if the century they pulled off.
People need to look at it without emotion and realise that the glazers have done what's best for them and they will continue to do so.
Financial pain is the only way to affect change with them and bring them to the table. No about of chanting will do that. They won't sell imo so we will need to work with the devil imo in the long run.

10.) 04 May 2021 22:05:17
Mumbles at last some sense!

11.) 04 May 2021 22:12:49
Your posts today are very disappointing Ken, worryingly so to be honest as I know how big a fan of the club you are, the lack of understanding is scaring me a bit.

12.) 04 May 2021 22:16:10
I get the playing Devil’s advocate but you must know the things you’re saying are going to rile people up, especially the match going season ticket holder hypocrites.

13.) 04 May 2021 23:24:40
The next owner will make a 4 billion investment. How will he take his money back? that's the reason i say we must be careful.

14.) 04 May 2021 23:47:38
What do you mean gds2?
Do you want to pretend they don't own the club?
I'm not playing devil's advocate.
Who owns the club gds2?

15.) 04 May 2021 23:57:07
but mumbles its not criminal its not very palletable but not criminal.
Its awful and all of us on here would do it differently for the betterment of the club that's for sure but if you don't look at it from both perspectives there is no chance of any sort of alignment.
They want to make money and we want to win prizes and have a club and team to be proud of. They don't have to be mutually exclusive. Changes need to be made so dialogue is needed and if they are not forthcoming then the only way to bring them to that table is to hurt them in the pocket.
Fan power has been seen to great effect over the past few weeks. It can be done it needs coordination.

16.) 05 May 2021 00:11:38
That’s exactly the point Herrera.

£4bn purchase will require some serious return on capital - the Glazers have run the club poorly - but they are more guilty of employing the wrong people to run the club rather than destroying t’s heritage etc. The club has neglected the football side for too long and my hope is they listen in terms of stadium, facilities, football infrastructure.

If the club is sold, it will become even more commercial in my opinion.

17.) 05 May 2021 00:59:19
Ken, me and you are on the same side of the coin on this one. The owners have all the power. They can't be "forced" out but if the fans make it really difficult, they may "want" out.

If new owners did come in, they would obviously want to raise the value of the club. We were attractive to sponsors because we hit the top spot when the Premier League was introduced. It was a perfect storm of new fans, old fans a winning team and club with history. The success on the pitch helped us become the global behemoth we are today. It was through the hard work on the pitch that the boardroom doors to sponsorship swung open.

In theory we were a successful football team who used a corporate approach to achieve greatness on the pitch. Somewhere along the way we turned into a corporation that played football on the weekend.

If new owners come on board after spending 4 billion quid, the best way to get a return on that investment is to bring us back to top of the footballing world. They could milk us even dryer of course. But success on the pitch is and has always been the catalyst to make the money off it.

We could be successful on the pitch, off it, invest in players, improve the stadia and facilities and still let the owners take a slice all while improving the value of the club. The Glazers are slumlord owners.

We could be run successfully on and off the pitch. It is achievable.

DLIB, I post a lot crap, bound to be right eventually mate.

18.) 05 May 2021 07:11:06
are you still scared this morning gds2 or have you realised I have no lack of understanding. A lack of empathy perhaps but no lack of understanding.
Its you that had no perspective and are only looking at one side of the coin.
Glazers own the club all the clubs money is theirs to do with as they please.
Some folk want to take a stand some supporters don't. No lack of understanding there. Some fans are prepared to do what ever it takes to try and force them to the table others are not.
Some fans will continue to moan and do nothing.
So no need to be scared open your eyes and it won't be dark anymore. If you continue to come from a place which denies that they own the club or deny that the money is their money you will be able to shout your Obscenities at the owners but no joy will come of that. Take your head out of the same and take the emotion out of it and start dealing with facts then you can start finding solutions. To say they have not spent a penny is just poppycock.
I'll ask you again. Who owns the business?
Where is my lack of understanding?

19.) 05 May 2021 10:59:36
Whilst I DO NOT agree with the structure of the club and the direction individuals have taken, it really is a remarkable thing that a family can own a 4bn assett without putting a hand in their pockets- sad but non theless remarkable.
If you let that sink in and digest guys, I'm sure you'll realise that these are not flogging fake ugg boots outta a van they are cold hearted businessmen. They have used the system and amassed a huge personal fortune from manutd to add to their portfolio and it won't be easy to shift them .

20.) 05 May 2021 11:17:44
The information and reasons for protest are out there, nothing I say now is going to change your opinion so the argument is pointless. As I said I am disappointed, perhaps you do understand but choose to ignore, which is fine.

I assure you I am looking at both sides of the coin, I realise that there is very little that will happen, the Glazers won't sell the club, but what I said was I understand the protests and I understand what the fans want and agree with it.

I hate the way the Glazers bought the club, I still say and will always say they have not put a penny of their own money in which is true and disgusting but obviously not illegal so not much can be done. I understand they own the club and I hope the protests make them see that the fans are important and they can have dialogue with the fans and explain some of their decisions. Doing nothing will mean nothing happens, getting rid of my season ticket will mean I am miserable and would mean nothing happens, fans protesting can make something happen, so as I said, I agree with what the fans stand for and can see exactly why they are doing it. I am allowed to agree without giving up my hobby.

21.) 05 May 2021 10:53:29
"I get the playing Devil’s advocate but you must know the things you’re saying are going to rile people up, especially the match going season ticket holder hypocrites. " how exactly are match going season ticket holders, hypocites?
Are they not supporters?
Have they not the right to opinion?
Are you a liverpool fan?
Are you a self opinionated idiot who thinks they can class all supporters who are season ticket match goers as hypocrites.
Thought you had more to you than that after reading your posts but to be fair mate that comment has hit a raw nerve.

22.) 05 May 2021 12:35:23
Funky pigeon - You’ve got the wrong end of the stick pal!

It was Ken who suggested that season ticket holders are hypocrites for continuing to attend games whilst protesting against the Glazers. Myself and GDS2 led an impassioned defence of all match going supporters in relation to Ken’s comments yesterday.

I remain very disappointed by Ken’s comments and am astonished that other Utd fans would attack loyal, devoted, match going fans in such a way. It’s scandalous to suggest someone should give up their passion so they can voice an opinion on the Glazers without being labelled as a hypocrite!

I present my hard earned cash to the Club every year in the hope that it will be reinvested back into the Club as I’m sure thousands of other match going supporters do. It’s not my fault the Glazers bought the Club, crippled it with debt and decided to run it more as a business than a football Club. The focus should remain on the Glazers and the dangers they present to the growth and competitiveness of our great Club and not loyal fans who are guilty only of supporting the Club.

It’s easy for fans who live hundreds of miles from the stadium to disingenuously suggest they are doing their bit by not attending games when they probably never went in the first place or certainly not on a consistent basis anyway.

We must be Utd against the Glazers and everything they represent and whilst fan protest may not remove them from the Club it certainly helps to highlight the issues and may even deter sponsorship which will hit them harder than a few season ticket holders going to watch Salford for a year as Ken suggested.

I’d be more than happy to sacrifice my season ticket if I believed it would make a discernible difference but this would take an organised and coordinated effort from thousands of fans coming together with no guarantee that others would simply not take our place. For this to be successful there would probably have to be some kind of protest or picket line at every game to put pressure on fans entering the stadium and taking our place. This would pit Utd fan against Utd fan and a divided fan base will never succeed.

Lobbying the government to make legislative changes in how football Clubs operate, continuing to protest and somehow making the Club less attractive to new sponsorship opportunities will hit the Club much harder than me and GDS2 spending a season watching Salford!

23.) 05 May 2021 15:06:48

You have definitely got the wrong end of the stick on that one if you read down the page, I did enjoy the passionate rant though and totally agree, I just wasn't the person to aim it at!

24.) 05 May 2021 17:33:29
Dl1b/ GDS2 - my sincere apologies as I read todays and missed yesterdays. In my defence, It jumped out at me as if it was a statement by GDS2 and not a quote/ or interpretation. Again lads, I apologize especially GDS2 because of my retort.

25.) 05 May 2021 18:48:36
Don’t worry mate, a lot of heated debate going on here and people obviously very passionate about the situation. Like I said, I enjoyed the rant :)



21 Apr 2021 17:45:37
As much as we would all like the glazers to sell I just don't think they ever will.

The stadium needs serious investment and so does the team but they will just sit pretty because of the club valuation.

What's worse is that uefa has given the 6 clubs more money now, they're just as bad.

I'm still deciding if I want to remain interested in football and man utd.





BIG V's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

17 Nov 2019 09:52:05
Thanks Ed, Best hope is to win the Europa then.

Do you think he would cut it in England?


{Ed002's Note - Spurs have put a lot of effort in to scouting him and there was a push from their chief scout to add him to the squad but it never happened. So I would think so.}



Click To View This Thread

24 Oct 2019 15:52:36

I cannot find where you have said the plans have been shelved? Is there a brief reason for this?


{Ed002's Note - THis was all some time ago.}



Click To View This Thread

15 Oct 2019 07:37:48
I would not be surprised if they are selling to family? Maybe someone wants more power?




Click To View This Thread

09 Oct 2019 13:44:19
I asked my self the same question, but then I thought they will be desperate and probably pick the wrong deal.

I'm not sure if he has the ability to make any sort of impact in the premiership.




Click To View This Thread

05 Apr 2019 17:47:27

I like Bergwijn because he is flexible across the front 3, I think he would be ideal for our squad. Have watched him a lot he will need time to settle though.

I just hope we sign him.





BIG V's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

19 Mar 2021 06:56:02
Wow ken are you ok?

A positive post🤭.




Click To View This Thread

16 Mar 2021 14:22:20
I agree shaps, also last season we didn't have a proper pre season to help integrate any youth Into the team and spend some time with them.




Click To View This Thread

14 Oct 2020 13:48:27
I agree Redman,

Ole also apparently refused some back room staff that was suggested to him to help him and the team.

Rejected it, which to me only leads to people above him not having full confidence in him.




Click To View This Thread

02 Oct 2020 12:13:55
Try telling a few of our regulars this, they will blame it all on ole and when the next manager comes in no matter there ability they will pretend the new manager is the problem aswell when it all goes wrong again.




Click To View This Thread

20 Sep 2020 23:01:01
Red man doesn't agree, thinks it's all ole s fault.