Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
Manchester United Rumours Member Posts
newnameoldideas's Profile
newnameoldideas's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To newnameoldideas's Posts
To newnameoldideas's last 5 banter posts
To newnameoldideas's last 5 rumour replies
To newnameoldideas's last 5 banter replies
newnameoldideas has no Rumours Posts
newnameoldideas's banter posts with other poster's replies to newnameoldideas's banter posts
24 Jun 2025 14:51:00
So, let's say we get to sell Garnacho and Antony and at least loan out Sancho for a decent % of his final contract year cost, loan out Hojlund, and end up keeping a potentially reconciled, more realistic as to his own worth and rejuvenated Rashford with Cunha and Mbuemo coming in as new forwards. how would that work? Rashford may never be the quality of player he seems to have come to think he is in his own mind, but wouldn't that array of forward power (along with Amad) be an improvement on these last couple of years.
1.) 24 Jun 2025 15:28:07
Rashford is as disruptive as Garnacho and Sancho. The manager gave him chances, and he didn’t learn. He needs to be sold for the good of the squad.
{Ed077's Note - the fact that no one has really come running after Rashford, for 2 windows now is an indication enough for me, on him as a player and his current state.
2.) 24 Jun 2025 15:47:59
There are no circumstances that justifies Rashford ever playing for us again. The End.
3.) 24 Jun 2025 15:52:15
If there was any way back for Rashford we wouldn't have loaned him out in January without even considering a replacement lol.
We spent 6 months with absolute dross up front that aren't even fit to lace rashfords boots (not saying Rashford is amazing but Hojlund, Zirkzee and Mount are absolute dross in comparison) .
I think moves will open up for him later in the summer, the club just has to be more realistic with its fee expectations, around £10-£20m. You can’t publicly isolate a player and then expect to get £40-£50m for him especially on his wages.
4.) 24 Jun 2025 17:00:32
I think it's more an indication that no-one can afford to pay him £350k a week. I'm sure he'd otherwise have his suitors.
5.) 24 Jun 2025 15:36:30
We shouldn't even entertain giving Rashford another chance.
Like Danny said he's extremely disruptive and has been given chance after chance. I will be glad to see the back of him.
I think he's actually embarrassing himself hoarding himself out to Barcelona when it's quite clear they don't want him, in fact it looks like we will struggle to get rid of him because nobody seems to be interested.
6.) 24 Jun 2025 15:38:10
Agree Ed 77
Also if we get a good striker in I would keep Hoijlund. With less pressure and better players around him I think he will come good.
{Ed077's Note - Either get a good fee or get him a good loan move. He seemed to be regressing every week. Might be good for him to have a change of scenery
7.) 24 Jun 2025 15:40:11
Plus his ludicrous salary.
8.) 24 Jun 2025 15:42:58
Exactly, Ed. That's my point. It's maybe the dose of reality that Rashford needs in order to get back to work. It may well not happen - I'm skeptical myself - but there remains a possibility that if stops sulking and believes he finally has team mates up front who are not kids with limited potential, and who will make him look better, that he'll get stuck in and finally get his head in the right place to contribute more. Rashford is by no means a great player. He has a limited array of talents, but even then he should be able to contribute 10-20 goals a season plus provide some assists.
{Ed077's Note - we should move past hope and live in reality.
9.) 24 Jun 2025 16:27:50
Exactly Ed, that tells its own story……. with Rashford…kid got problems in his own head.
Same reason I have my concerns over Gyokores no one busting a door down for him, it would seem although different issue than Rashford clearly….
10.) 24 Jun 2025 18:35:25
How do we know who is busting down a door for who? Right now I would imagine many teams are looking at their striker options and trying to work out how to sign someone.
11.) 25 Jun 2025 14:26:44
German what are you talking about, got problems in his own head? WTF do you know? ?
I have no issue with Rashford, he is a good footballer and a good person. I believe he also returned to club training, I haven't seen him put up or say anything negative about the club at any point.
His journey at this club unfortunately ran it's natural conclusion. The club has been a mess for years now and he has been through every manager post fergie barring moyes. The club have let him down more than he every let us down in my opinion.
As for 'no suitors'. It is not an indicator for his footballing abilities and what he can bring to a team but the overall cost. There aren't many clubs out there that can afford someone like Marcus. Those that can had other priorities.
Best of luck to him in his pursuit of another club, he is a fine young man that for some reason rattles people on here big time.
newnameoldideas's rumour replies
10 Jul 2025 21:25:51
Maybe nobody a-calling is the dose of reality Garnacho's big ego needs. There are aspects of his game which are excellent for a younger player.
30 Jun 2025 15:46:41
Shawthing GDS2. For some reason my i'd and password wouldn't work.
29 Jun 2025 20:00:12
Malacia only has one year left on his contract. His NBV is maybe £4m and he's paid about £3m a year. Is he so bad he couldn't command a transfer fee of £6-10m on a lesser salary with United covering the difference and the club at least breaking even?
27 Jun 2025 19:04:45
Cunha and Mbuemo scored 35 goals between them last season, almost as many as our whole team. Maybe Obi or Hojlund, if he's not sold or loaned out, will add a few and then Bruno and Amad will surely contribute some more. A top striker would be a boon but I think we'll score 55+ in the coming season without any further additions up top.
25 Jun 2025 16:46:12
Given that finances have been such a major issue for United for the last few years, it's totally reasonable for us fans to comment on them, even if we have no idea what's really going on, and we're talking a load of bollocks. Never agreed with Ed002 on this point.
newnameoldideas's banter replies
06 Jul 2025 16:11:39
Still nearly 2 months to go in the window. We have known two things before it opened: firstly It won't be easy getting rid of our overpaid players at a satisfactory price, and, secondly, that our budget is limited to £100k+/ - plus whatever we can get in sales. We must also be aware that we finished barely above the relegation zone, so most top players who want to play in Europe are not coming to OT. We're going to end up with players who are buying into Amorim's program and who, no doubt, are also getting a decent wage increase.
Villa themselves have PSR problems so not surprisingly they decided not to sign Rashford. Chelsea not taking up the option on Sancho was another blow but after what was a mediocre loan spell had to be expected, and Antony was always going to be difficult given his book value is still higher than his market value. I still think Garnacho and Malacia will find buyers. Be patient and reserve judgment until the window closes, or at least closer to when it closes. This isn't a computer game.
30 Jun 2025 21:50:16
I can see us selling Malacia, Antony and Garnacho. It would be great to offload Rashford but loans for him and Sancho may be more likely even though Sancho only has one year left on his contract so something might be possible.
30 Jun 2025 15:55:51
Liverpool spent what we (reportedly) have available without sales on one player. They are also the champions, will be in the Champions League and have substantially greater revenues than us, which is to say they are a far more attractive destination for top players. Besides which there are 2 months left in the transfer window, so no need to get ones knickers in a twist yet. Mbuemo is likely after July 1st, and then we will also see some deals being done to loan/ sell some of our roster of undesirables, freeing up some funds for additional purchases. There's simply no point in buying players just for the sake of it.
24 Jun 2025 15:42:58
Exactly, Ed. That's my point. It's maybe the dose of reality that Rashford needs in order to get back to work. It may well not happen - I'm skeptical myself - but there remains a possibility that if stops sulking and believes he finally has team mates up front who are not kids with limited potential, and who will make him look better, that he'll get stuck in and finally get his head in the right place to contribute more. Rashford is by no means a great player. He has a limited array of talents, but even then he should be able to contribute 10-20 goals a season plus provide some assists.
{Ed077's Note - we should move past hope and live in reality.