Manchester United Banter 2

 

Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.


 

18 Nov 2026 22:06:01
In order to view all of today's posts, you may have to visit our Manchester United Discussion pages and our Manchester United Match Posts pages.

Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

14 Nov 2026 14:00:05
{Ed's Note - Shappy has posted a new article entitled, Backing Pochettino With a Proper United Rebuild

2


15 Nov 2026 01:50:16
Well I have sat on the fence for all previous incoming managers but for some reason I feel this is an appointment I am uncomfortable with. He is very unlikely to be supported with the right buys. If he is then that itself is an indictment on the owners for throwing previous managers under a bus.

He will therefore ruffle some boys club feathers and be out on his ear sooner than any of us want.

Of course I will support him as the gaffer of my team as I have all previous ones with the possible exception of EtH and hope to be proven totally wrong but I am not confident.

1


14 Nov 2026 09:49:24
I am delighted they saw sense over Carrick, that has to be said. This is a key moment where the club has now been badly bitten twice making the same emotional decision to appoint a loved ex player who then becomes a major wrench to remove. This must never happen again. Knowing, played for or loving the club is not a requirement to being manager. In fact it should be the reason not to appoint one. Never again.

Poch. Massive upgrade on Carrick. To be seen whether he is the long term manager to bring titles, but I do like his passion , style and note he likes to develop youth, something Carrick seemed averse to. Two and a half year contract as Head Coach, not manager is sensible. Gone is the ridiculous 6 year Moyes type deal.

The decision to appoint Poch is interesting. Came very left field. Despite the briefing they all agreed, I can’t help feel that he wasn’t Wilcox or Berradas first choice. From Carrick and the mooting of pliable Eddie Howe to the passion of Poch, it seems distant from what Wilcox showed his previous vision to be. Not least because Wilcox couldn’t control Amorim, I think Poch could be a lot stronger than Amorim, the same South American Latin fire that Martinez showed.

My hope now is for a change in the DOF position, Wilcox first. Ideally soon and someone Poch can work with, someone unlike Wilcox. I have seen Paul Mitchell mentioned. Referring back to the emotional decision making, it shouldn’t be VDS just because he knows the club.

I don’t think anyone thinks sacking Carrick, appointing Poch solves everything. Only new ownership and no debt sets us on that road, and likely that means no Berrada or Wilcox. Let’s hope the sale rumours have some reality. For now we can look forward to games without the emotional garbage of the manager discussions. Good luck Poch.

4


14 Nov 2026 12:11:16
I wouldn't say we should never hire another manager who has played for or who has a connection to the club. What if the best manager in the world is a former player?

I think the lesson to learn from this is that a former player is not the right option to get us back to where we want to be. It's romantic, and we would all love for someone like Ole or Carrick to be the man to get us back to the top, but it wasn't to be.

I think what we need to do is to draw a line under trying to go backwards to move forwards, and instead look at what is needed NOW to be successful rather than what was it we did before to be successful.

I think one of the things we get wrong when looking for a new manager is that we are trying to replace Sir Alex the manager, when in the final decade or more he was more of a DoF and his assistant manager was more of a head coach.

We keep trying to find the next SAF as a manager, but without understanding that he didn't rebuild the club entirely on his own. However, by the time he retired he was the entire management structure at the club. He was our DoF, our manager, our head of recruitment, our academy pathway manager, and we also lost David Gill as our CEO.

We have never adequately replaced that structure, at least not in a coherent way, until INEOS took over.

Now they obviously haven't got everything right, I think they've identified the key roles that are needed, and they have tried to recruit the best available for those roles. But clearly not every hire has been a total success, some could even be considered failures. That happens in every walk of life at every level. No one gets everything 100% right at the first time of asking, in fact they might not ever get everything 100% right.

On paper Barrada was a good option to come in as CEO, and I'm not saying he has been entirely bad in his role. I'm sure there are several things he's done really well. However, his close personal friendship with Wilcox will have certainly caused him to have blind spots and probably make poor decisions because of that.

Dan Ashworth was a very good appointment, probably on paper the best of the bunch. But a combination of others having the ear of key people and them not liking/agreeing with what he said was needed/where we were led to his position becoming untenable.

Jason Wilcox on paper was a very good option, he had big club experience with City and was doing great with Southampton. His role within Cities well run and highly successful academy made him stand out as a candidate for a club that has a history of success from their academy, but which is currently not as strong as it needs to be. However, a combination of Wilcox's personality and him having a close friendship with our new CEO, has led to a blurring of the lines of his remit and his controlling nature meaning he has upset a lot of people at the club and his decision making possibly effected by his need to micro-manage.

Barrada saying we can be challenging for the title again in 2028, came from Wilcox himself, which went against the timeline Ashworth believed was realistically possible. Ratcliffe wanted the club to be back challenging as soon as possible, and when presented with Ashworth saying it will take at least 5 years, while Barrada and Wilcox saying they can be back in 3 created tension.

The fact that after Ashworth left they didn't replace him, but promoted/amalgamated his position with Wilcox's role further highlights the power and influence that Wilcox had, as well as his need to control things.

He has since had several fallouts with Vivell over recruitment, and every time he has gone against Vivell the decision has ultimately always gone the way of Wilcox. Why hire a recruitment expert to then repeatedly ignore their advice.

He has also upset several managers by trying to dictate tactics and team selection to them. While Wilcox was a good coach/manager at youth level, he has never shown himself capable at the highest level, or even senior level. The fact that he thinks he can, and should, overrule managers with actual experience and a track record in senior football at the highest level suggests a level of arrogance that cannot be backed up with evidence from Wilcox.

In short, we got the role and responsibilities right, but hired at least one wrong person for one of those roles. Until they correct that mistake it will be difficult to truly get us back on track. The fortunate thing is that previous managers, and current players have turned the spotlight on Wilcox, which should give our new manager more strength to push back against him, and make sure Wilcox understands his position is weaker now and not to overplay his hand. I would think that if there was a clash between Pochettino and Wilcox over the next year or so that it might (and should) be Wilcox who comes out of it with his P45.

3


14 Nov 2026 13:48:55
Perhaps the club could simply sack or redeploy Wilcox elsewhere and allow Vivell to recruit the players he wants.

However, I do believe Vivell will leave at the end of the season when his contract expires. I can't imagine that he would be too keen staying at. the club, given he how poor thought of he is.

The Paul Mitchell for SD would be a good shout. I'd love for Txiki Bergstein to become the DOF for the club. Wilcox has had very little experience as DOF, and by God does it show. Berrada and Wilcox are akin to Dumb and Dumber - slightly harsh on Berrada.

2


14 Nov 2026 14:18:51
you mean berrada and bergstein who were at city when the dodgy dealings started?

2


15 Nov 2026 08:51:21
Shappy,

Considering it seems like practically all our former players are clogging up television, radio, print, Podcasts, twitter etc giving their views, it seems unlikely any of them will ever torn out to be the best manager in the world.

0


15 Nov 2026 17:26:47
Shappy

"What if the best manager in the world is a former player? You asked.

Well, never is a long time, however, look around at how our ex players are doing in management and none of them are doing anything worth talking about. SAF had 12 years of management before OT and he was a true great.
So if we go with only appointing based on experience and track record and ignoring the emotional ex players choice I think we should be safe for my lifetime

There are rumours Poch won't speak to Wilcox, Wilcox needs sacking.

0


Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

14 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - AJH has posted a new article entitled, Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

3


13 Nov 2026 20:36:49
Welcome Poch

2


13 Nov 2026 22:16:07
Finally someone who knows what he's doing.

1


13 Nov 2026 22:27:16
We've now got to back this guy for a sustained period of time.

4


13 Nov 2026 22:47:39
If they do that's brilliant but they should hang their heads in shame for slaughtering previous incumbents with essentially second rate buys.

I still fear a lot more turmoil before we are back where we should be. I hesitate in saying belong as it's been such a bad ride.

I think, in my very humble uneducated opinion, that Poch will be long gone before that happens,

2


13 Nov 2026 23:36:10
One hopes that Poch has say so regarding transfers and spending commitments built into his contract. If not he will go the way of his predecessors. Fortunately I think the cost of relegation is so steep - a loss of £350m in revenues and no guarantee of quick return to the EPL - that the owners themselves will have already earmarked a substantial January budget.

Assuming relegation doesn't happen, with the enormous debt and servicing costs, how they're ever going to afford to compete with the top clubs for talent remains a mystery.

0


14 Nov 2026 04:26:17
If posh gets us back in ucl spots every year he will have succeeded. Years ago we looked at him and thought he wasn't a winner. Now a bit of 2nd and 3rd would be very good for us.

0


14 Nov 2026 09:04:30
I know there's rumours of Beckham getting involved, but putting his wife in charge seems a stretch.

5


14 Nov 2026 14:07:14
Very good AJH👏
Im not sure how much impact he can have in the next few weeks but hopefully he can click quickly with the players and that they buy into his methods.

0


13 Nov 2026 13:47:30
Who are the 3 players you think will show significant improvements under poch in next 6 months?
Who are the 3 that were stalwarts under Carrick and amorim that will not do well and get a lot less games time as the season progresses?
My opinions are
Mainoo cuhana and yoro will thrive
and show good improvement
Maguire maz and amad might see less mins as time goes on

1


13 Nov 2026 14:03:11
Mainoo, Dorgu & Diallo.

1


13 Nov 2026 14:27:12
Maz is already seeing less minutes.

0


13 Nov 2026 14:57:36
Not few enough mbd🤣.

1


13 Nov 2026 15:55:40
Mainoo might be in trouble, Poch likes midfield to have legs and work real hard, that's not a description of Mainoo

I think Yoro struggles too because he also likes pace & power and experience

Surprise might be Zirkee for more mins

Cunha who knows Mbuemo who knows.

Dorgu will thrive.

1


13 Nov 2026 17:34:55
I think he might like Santos in midfield.

1


13 Nov 2026 19:32:46
He would put Baleba in front of Santos that's 100%
But doubt he puts Baleba and Mainoo or Santos together

I think Mainoo struggles in a Poch team, not enough legs

He also likes a strong experienced GK that puts Lammens in trouble because he really been poor since World Cup, like I predicted before season kicked off

It's going to be interesting, but he stuck with what he got till January but I see Zirkee starting virtually every game till then and Dorgu and Bruno starts every game, the rest no idea.

1


13 Nov 2026 20:35:29
Mainoo, Lacey and Dorgu think.

0


Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

13 Nov 2026 12:25:52
{Ed's Note - AJH has posted a new article entitled, Chaos at Manchester United Since SAF

2


13 Nov 2026 19:07:10
There have been some recurring issues.

1. Every new manager has effectively been allowed to start again - new tactics, new recruitment priorities, new playing styles and new expectations.

2. Recruitment has been awful. Too many signings have been made to satisfy an immediate managerial requirement rather than build a balanced, sustainable squad.

3. Poor standards in the dressing room, called out by several managers, but never properly addressed.

4. Linked to the first point, we constantly change direction. We appoint a manager, give him a particular mandate, recruit players to support that mandate and then sack him. The next manager arrives and wants something completely different. Rinse and repeat.

I like Poch, but whether he can deliver where so many others have failed remains to be seen.

1


13 Nov 2026 19:37:53
No one could turn this bunch into world beaters, we got bang average GK no defence, the slowest midfield going and added more poor midfielders to it this summer.

We got no proper striker even when Sesko fit
Every defender is poor beyond belief, that's not a job for an elite coach hence why we got Poch, wish him all the best and hopefully he got promises of reinforcements in January because boy does he need them.

Your all moan because he will play McGuire and probably Dalot too.

1


13 Nov 2026 20:49:38
You forgot to change your profile who you're writing as Je suis unite?! 😂.

1


Matchday 10 - Quick Round Up

13 Nov 2026 07:39:03
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Matchday 10 - Quick Round Up

1


13 Nov 2026 07:16:37
I have held out commenting, but thank whatever greater being you look to that one of our worst periods has come to an end.

I hope the Poch has what it takes to lift this sorry squad off the ground and secure a steady climb back up the ladder.

I hope he has what it takes to clear this dross out, starting January.

I hope the board backs him to the hilt.

I hope the upper management is sorted out this summer and the cohesiveness we were promised is evident going forward.

Oh, and I hope Wilcox is fired, he has to be next out the door, before we start signing players again.

5


13 Nov 2026 10:09:56
I find it quite contradictory that you've spent so much time being critical of Carrick, yet the points you're making here are largely the same ones that could have been applied to him.

You talk about lifting a sorry squad, clearing out players who aren't good enough, rebuilding the team, getting the board to provide proper backing and sorting out the upper management. None of those issues suddenly disappear because Pochettino is coming in, and equally, they weren't issues that Carrick could simply have been expected to resolve overnight.

You've previously criticised Carrick for performances and results without seemingly giving enough consideration to the wider problems within the club. Yet now you're quite rightly acknowledging that the problems extend far beyond the manager.

What I'd genuinely like to know is this, if those issues aren't resolved, if Pochettino inherits the same dysfunctional structure, the same recruitment problems and largely the same squad, will you hold him to exactly the same standards you held Carrick? Will he receive the same level of criticism for poor results, or will there suddenly be an understanding that the problems are bigger than the manager and that he needs time and support?

3


13 Nov 2026 15:59:19
I don't think Poch is the answer, but he will be a damnsight more organised and tactically aware then Carrick ever was, so that in itself will have us winning more, which is hardly difficult, plus we will have a style of play and he will give youngsters a chance.

Will he get same useless back up . Probably, will he accept it like Carrick Nope not a chance, so that's a bonus.

2


13 Nov 2026 16:49:56
Ports, with the greatest respect, I zeroed in on being critical of Carrick, purposely to prove a point, because that is what happened with Amorim. I actually stated that was the reason I focused on his win percentages, again because that was the MO of a few on here to chase Amorim out.

However, you touch on a couple of points that Carrick could have solved, or maybe he was the catalyst for them. 1. The sorry squad - Carrick took over a super fit squad and benefitted from Amorim's work ethic, that is a fact, proven by the dramatic drop off a cliff when he had full control over the squad, look how sorry they have become, that's on his head.
2. Players being picked that aren't good enough. Ermmmmm he picks the team sweetheart. He selected Rashford over Cunha, he upset the apple cart. He lost the dressing room.

It is okay to admit he was a worse appointment than Ole, that is ok.

Will I hold Poch in the same vein, yes mate, I will. But he probably won't be anywhere near as crap as Carrick because he is proven, whereas Carrick is, and always will be, at best, a Championship level coach.

Will I still attempt to drive the other items to conclusion, of course, I have been unwavering in those regards.

Get your facts straight lad, or pile down.

1


13 Nov 2026 18:42:28
I think you've just exposed the problem with your argument rather brilliantly. You've openly admitted you deliberately targeted Carrick to prove a point about Amorim. In other words, you weren't interested in objectively assessing Carrick at all; you had an agenda and worked backwards to justify it. That's not consistency, it's hypocrisy.

The fitness argument is laughable. You're presenting Amorim's supposed legacy as fact and Carrick's supposed destruction of it as equally factual, without actually demonstrating either. It's a theory you've convinced yourself is true, not an argument.

And the "he picks the team, sweetheart" line? Is that really the level we're at? You've reduced squad selection to a playground observation, conveniently ignoring the quality of the options available. You can't spend months telling everyone the squad isn't good enough and then blame the manager for selecting players from that same squad. As for losing the dressing room, that's a pretty bold accusation to make without a shred of evidence.

Then there's your Championship-level comment. Brilliant insight. A manager's entire future career assessed and dismissed by someone on an internet forum. Quite the authority you clearly believe yourself to be.

But the real beauty is the contradiction running through your entire post. You admit to deliberately applying selective criticism, make sweeping assumptions, offer speculation as fact, and then finish by telling someone else to get their facts straight.

You haven't proved Carrick was worse than Ole, you haven't proved he lost the dressing room and you certainly haven't proved Amorim was the reason for any fitness levels you claim existed.

You've simply demonstrated that you've already made your mind up and will bend whatever argument you can find to fit it.

Perhaps spend less time telling others to "get their facts straight" and a little more time distinguishing facts from your own opinions. At the moment, you're confusing having a strong opinion with having a strong argument. They're very different things.

P. s "pipe down".

5


14 Nov 2026 09:11:24
I didn't target him. I simply repeated what others did with Amorim, it was as useful as others who did that with Amorim.

I can see with my eyes, that Carrick had zero in game tactical ability, the fitness levels fell off a cliff, the players stopped playing for him, and even called him out publicly.

The facts remain, he is a coach, at best. Not a head coach and certainly not a manager.

He took the job and got the job because he is a yes man.

You realise we have been in the never ending cycle for a while now.

0


Matchday 10 - Quick Round Up

13 Nov 2026 06:26:15
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Matchday 10 - Quick Round Up

1


12 Nov 2026 22:14:00
Hi ed033
Hope you are well.
Can you do a poll please?
Where do you think united will finish this season?
Bottom 3
Bottom half
8th -10
Conf league
Europa league
Cl
Thanks Ed033.

1


https://talksense.uk/uploads/thumb_83465ef516bbaf3fc5d18c1981c94341.jpeg avatar{Ed033's Note - Yes, thanks.


Man Utd PL poll

1


12 Nov 2026 23:29:49
No idea. Depends if we change DOF for someone competent or not. More change is needed than just the coach. Assume we need a whole new coaching staff and DOF minimum.

New players would always take a minute to bed in. Injured players will take a while to come back. So I would assume second half is stronger than first half. We can afford to leak any more oil in next 10 games. We have to basically lose less than 3 games in the next 15 or so games to have a chance of Europe. Tall order.

Wilcox out.
Paul Mitchell / VDS in

Start building for next year and focus on developing players who will still be a part of the team in 12 months.

2


13 Nov 2026 03:29:53
Winners isn't in there..

0


13 Nov 2026 14:58:58
Do winners not finish in a cl position🤦.

0


13 Nov 2026 16:00:19
6-10th . If we make 5th will be fantastic achievement.

0


13 Nov 2026 21:18:06
They do Ken, but as you very well know, there is a difference between winners and also rans.

0


Manchester United Banter


Manchester United Banter 3


Manchester United Banter 4


Manchester United Banter 5


Manchester United Banter 6


Manchester United Banter 7


Manchester United Banter 8


Manchester United Banter 9


Manchester United Banter 10


Manchester United Banter Archives

 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent