Manchester United banter 5
Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.
08 Nov 2026 23:00:46
I just watched the highlights. It looked like overall we by far the more threatening team. 25 shots v 8. However some of the shots were low % and scorned passing to players in better positions.
The weakness is clearly in the defense for which the club is solely responsible. But, praising Dalot, after he gave away the penalty, was beaten for the first goal, and almost conceded another when he was outpaced by Goretzka, is just nuts.
Clearly Lammens is in a bad mental place since his error at the World Cup , and maybe he should be benched for a while. The second goal in particular was indefensible. Never mind putting it out for a corner, which would have been the easy safe option, but that was not a hard shot at a difficult height. It should have been caught.
08 Nov 2026 23:07:32
Lammens def feeling fragile but I would keep playing him to give him confidence if poss. The problem is he is getting such little protection from the defence.
I don't get the hate for Dalot. For sure he is not playing well but he is not the only one. Putting him on the left is unfair as he is right footed and it's not his natural position but he doesn't complain and plays. He hasn't played well in his natural right back position either but like the whole team he is suffering from a lack of defensive coaching.
I would love Carrick to stay and succeed but if he can't coach the players defensively we need someone who can. The team can't keep getting out of jail game after game.
09 Nov 2026 00:06:04
I think Lammens needs dropping for a few games. Mainly just to protect his progression whilst he is in a bad patch.
SAF did it with De Gea a couple of times when he made high profile errors, and he bounced back to be one of our greatest. Darlow is a very competent keeper and probably deserves a few games.
09 Nov 2026 00:08:45
We are very much IN jail. See EPL table for reference.
09 Nov 2026 02:03:22
The best way to protect Lammens is defend better.
09 Nov 2026 04:00:50
I have said it before and I shall say it again. For the money they are paid and analysis available to teams every player should be able to use both feet proficiently at this level. Sure favour one over the other perhaps but should be able to play on either side of the park in their chosen area of the park.
09 Nov 2026 10:52:42
Lammens is our best form of attack. Fox in the box! It's his fault Carrick is still here today.
08 Nov 2026 22:18:02
Poch now bookies fave tonight. Seems it may be happening.
08 Nov 2026 22:26:30
Isn't he under contract with USA? therefore compensation due so no chance that happens.
08 Nov 2026 22:27:56
Which bookies? Still Eddie Howe with skybet.
08 Nov 2026 21:47:41
Even more embarassing is the fact that palace who are just below us are sacking their manager for poor performances and failure to meet expectations. They are 1 point behind us, meanwhile we are seemingly happy to carry on cos we might win a game sometime this year.
08 Nov 2026 21:17:31
Let's get it straight. We get an equaliser in the last minute, at home, to a team 10th in the league, lifting us from 19th to 18th and some are arguing that might be enough to save Carrick's job. Good lord
08 Nov 2026 21:22:09
Beating a team 9 places above us sounds impressive ?.
08 Nov 2026 22:07:30
Winning any league game right now would be great.
08 Nov 2026 20:45:02
Not sure a new manager can improve that defence. I have said give Yoro and Heaven time together, but full backs are so bad. I don't see anyone talking or organising at the back, the keeper should be roaring out orders too, all the play is in front of him, its part of his job. De ligt might help if we went back 3, maybe Dorgu as the left wingback, he very well when he came on. Of course that back to RA's system ?. Not saying this is ideal, but at least until we buy some fullbacks. I think defence is much more important now than a CF, we are conceding so many goals its just shocking, he has to address it now. Just can't understand how this squad and Manager were so good last season and are s**** now. Think this board are going to gamble on Carrick for another while ???
08 Nov 2026 20:55:32
If carrick stays another month then we are relegated. It's amazing how he and the board now have us believing it's a success now for us to just stay up. Unbeleivable.
08 Nov 2026 20:13:16
Resign yourself to the fact that carrick is staying. Gauging his reaction after the game and that of Wilcox and berrada it doesn’t look like the plan on making a change.
08 Nov 2026 20:25:18
It looked like Carrick was losing his cool in post match interviews. The positive is that he has been given zero public backing. On the other hand, this club is so poorly run that I wouldn't be surprised if they dithered again.
08 Nov 2026 21:25:04
If United didn't get their penalty, then I think Villa would have gone onto batter Utd. That penalty woke them up and they actually fought, and looked good and really put Villa under pressure.
It is worrying how poor defensively United are. Dalot and Maz should be dropped.
08 Nov 2026 21:33:57
Carricks just been singing the praises of Dalot in an interview. Standards are through the floor at this club, my god!
08 Nov 2026 19:52:33
The defence is clearly the problem. I like Carrick a lot but he is obviously not coaching the defence properly.
Yes individual mistakes are something he can't be blamed for but the way we are so open in defence is just plain bad coaching. Put Conte in charge and defensively at least you will soon see the difference.
There is a nervousness which is understandable but there is also a desire by the players to do well. Two comebacks like we have seen this week shows they do have spirit.
Just get a manager or top defensive coach to show them how to defend better. I so wish we had Rio there to show them. We have two weeks til the next match. There should be a real improvement in the defensive play by then if there is decent coaching.
08 Nov 2026 20:16:14
What has Rio Ferdinand done to make you think he's a good coach?
This is part of the problem. Carrick has 2 young coaches, Woodgate and Evans in charge of the defence. What is needed is experience. People that have experience coaching at top level clubs. It doesn't matter what a person has achieved in their playing career. Coaching is a completely different skill set and the club need proven coaches to create stability.
08 Nov 2026 20:40:25
Probably as much as Jonny Evans.
08 Nov 2026 18:46:32
No doubt that last 5 minutes will save Carricks job! 8 points from 30 but things are about to turn ??♂️ lol
08 Nov 2026 19:03:46
The Liverpool game will determine whether or not he stays.
08 Nov 2026 19:20:12
We said that before Bournemouth and again before today so why is that game any different. We should have been 3-0 down on Tuesday and today we needed 2 stoppage time goals to rescue 1 point at home.
We are 18th, 8 from 30. All these media and pundits saying he can turn it around?! To what exactly? Mid table. To see our ceo etc going crazy as we scraped a home draw is embarassing.
08 Nov 2026 19:22:22
Surely if a change is to be made, this is the moment.
08 Nov 2026 20:21:30
If Carrick keeps his job it shows that the people running the club haven't a clue.
During the last international break the talk was that the club was giving Carrick the opportunity to turn things around. After Como and Bournemouth it looked like he'd be sacked. The only thing that supposedly saved him was that there wasn't agreement on a successor.
We're in the relegation zone. Carrick hasn't turned things around. All kicking the decision further down the road accomplishes is making it more difficult for the next guy.
08 Nov 2026 16:55:32
I feel sorry for Lammens, his confidence is shot. Having that back 4 in front of you, week in and out will ruin you.
The same thing that happened to DDG, is happening to Lammens.
08 Nov 2026 18:27:11
I feel sorry for all the young players.
People keep blaming Carrick, but he simply doesn't have a defense to work with.
We simply don't have a single seasoned Premier League quality defender, except possibly Shaw and he's injured again and getting on.
What's going to change to stave off relegation? Adriana Lima couldn't get a rise out of this lot. And while we have a transfer window coming up, the best players aren't going to be available.
08 Nov 2026 18:32:49
A different manager lol. Ridiculous thing to say.
08 Nov 2026 18:40:07
A better coach can definitely get more out of this. You don't have to be world class to defend properly. You just need to know your job and be in the right spot more often than not. Most of these players are internationals, they can't be that bad.
08 Nov 2026 18:42:57
I feel sorry for dalots parents, they must be so embarrassed every time he calls himself a footballer. He's not a footballer he's a fraud. I'm buying my mum some boots and dropping her off at Carrington in the morning, she will be starting RB after the international break.
08 Nov 2026 19:13:48
Fallguy, you are right you don't need to be world class to defend, but you need defenders who can defend. We don't have that. Tell me this what team would have dalot or Maguire starting everyweek? Lindelof got ridiculed before he left and he's better than them both.
We have a 1st choice lb that doesn't stay fit unless it's an international year and he still doesn't get picked for England. Yoro and heaven aren't reliable and make mistakes, de ligt may as well be retired as he never plays and an angry midget who doesn't want to be here and has turned into Romero 2.0. That is basically no reliable defenders.
It doesn't matter who the manager is, what tactics you play, with that set of players as your defence your going to struggle.
Maybe we need to throw some youngsters in, it can't be any worse.
08 Nov 2026 19:34:57
Carrick keeps picking them. Dalots been crap for years.
08 Nov 2026 19:41:03
Lindelof was ridiculed at United and thought of as not good enough. But he's now in a team that is coached properly and is playing well.
I think Dalot is awful but he's picked by Portugal. Yoro was picked by France. Maz by morroco. Martinez by Argentina.
If you put Maguire into other teams in the league he would look a lot better.
Please don't misunderstand me, I'm not saying these players are United of old level, but they are definitely better than we are seeing. And the right coaching and setup would show that.
And I don't just mean the defence, they look worse as there's never any help from the midfield.
08 Nov 2026 21:23:55
Yes you are right. Maguire in another team would be a lot better, for United!
08 Nov 2026 15:30:00
Today is going to determine Carrick’s future. Lose and he’s gone, a win and he might keep his job.
The team is coming off their most encouraging half of football, and how he sets them up will speak volumes. The signs are not encouraging. Despite talk of Younger players getting a shot, Amad and Dalot are starting. Lack of energy in the middle too. It feels like Carrick is reverting to type and I think it will cost him his job.
I don’t want to see us lose, but leaving Lacey on the bench feels like a big mistake. He’s a player with energy and hunger. It’s all well and good to trust in experience when it’s working. Sticking with underperforming players, however, is weak.
08 Nov 2026 15:44:21
It's like he wants the sack at this stage. How you can put any faith in Amad and Dalot is beyond me.
The Villa midfield will tear through this team, and Jackson will run past the back line for fun.
08 Nov 2026 16:47:13
1st sign of madness: keep trying the same thing and expect it to turn out different.
Manchester United Banter
Manchester United Banter 2
Manchester United Banter 3
Manchester United Banter 4
Manchester United Banter 6
Manchester United Banter 7
Manchester United Banter 8
Manchester United Banter 9
Manchester United Banter 10
Manchester United Banter Archives