
06 Nov 2026 07:39:01
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Liverpool v Arsenal - A Quick Liverpool Perspective
Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.

06 Nov 2026 07:39:01
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Liverpool v Arsenal - A Quick Liverpool Perspective

05 Nov 2026 20:48:04
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Liverpool v Arsenal - A Quick Liverpool Perspective
06 Nov 2026 02:28:43
Good analysis Ed001. I enjoyed the match, it was a good, high intensity game with Liverpool showing their press and attacking intent, although with little end product, and Arsenal excellent defending. I am impressed with how well drilled Arsenal are, not only against Liverpool but against Bayern etc. Their ability to shoot a game down is second to none. I liked Liverpool too, for large part of the game you were the best team, although part of this is Arsenal giving you the ball and trying to defend.
The part i disagree is about stats from Opta, and the stats in general. There are going to be some mistakes maybe, but they don't lie as you say. McAlister's shoot i am not sure it was a shoot, it seems nore of a very bad pass than a shoot to me.
The way he had his body and the weight he tried to put in the pass, suggest that he tried to loop the ball over the last defender, to find Isak who did (half) a move. Then Van Dijks header I am not sure if he tried to make a pass with his head or even if his header was going outside. In this one i am not sure because in our channel we had no replay.
Opta do make mistakes, some times make mistakes and after one hour make correction. For example counting a shoot as 0, 30 xg instead of 0, 25, they will reassess after the match and make the correction. I think in no way they lie.
{Ed001's Note - they 100% lie. I am sure of it for the betting markets. They were 100% shots. Mac Allister's was certainly not a pass, it was a weak shot but it was defo a shot. I am sorry but Opta are bullshit artists. Van Dijk's header was saved but Raya was listed as making no saves, that can't even be argued that Raya saved it. Those stats are not mistakes, they were outright wrong and it is clear to see so no reason to not correct them, but they haven't.}
06 Nov 2026 11:47:01
Mac Allister had a great chance to score with his head.
Watching here in the US I saw that shirt pull and was astonished that it wasn't called. The commentary team missed it until much later. The only explanation I can think of is that maybe it was so weak. that Isak himself didn't notice it and was unaffected by it, or why else didn't he complain? Did any other Liverpool player.
Good game though. Although Arsenal's lack of enterprise in the second half, made that period less enjoyable. A draw would have been a fairer result.
{Ed001's Note - Isak did notice and turned and had a go at Timber at the time. I am astonished he never said anything to the ref though. It clearly did affect him, it pulled him back, you can see it when you watch it that his forward momentum is arrested and then he ends up missing the ball.}
06 Nov 2026 12:27:37
I've maintained for a while that one of the biggest reasons players go to ground so easily is because, if they stay on their feet, they often don't get the foul. This Isak incident is a perfect example of that.
It's exactly why VAR was introduced, or at least should be used, to distinguish between genuine contact and players going down to win a penalty. The irony is that VAR seems to have reinforced the very behaviour it's supposed to discourage. Players are almost being told to believe that unless they hit the deck, they won't get the decision. Stay on your feet and play through the contact, and you risk getting absolutely nothing. We're effectively rewarding players for going down rather than rewarding them for trying to stay on their feet.
{Ed001's Note - it is very sad and very much to the detriment of the game.}
06 Nov 2026 13:00:34
One sometimes wonder whether the VAR team are not paying any attention whatsoever.
The reality is that where humans are involved errors will be made. VAR can't fix that.
{Ed001's Note - no, but nobody minds errors that are understandable, like missing something in real time. Footie was better without VAR.}
05 Nov 2026 15:30:51
Some delightful words from avram glazer floating about the media sphere today. To say I hate and despise this family would be the understatement of the decade. Their attitude to the club, fans and everyone who loves this great institution is why we are where we are.
05 Nov 2026 19:16:43
The thing is the status of EPL football teams is not protected by a franchise system. The NFL is a revenue sharing collective, so the minimum a franchise can bring in is $450m without selling a ticket, a hot dog or winning a game. It's basically guaranteed income which underpins the economic value of the franchise, which in the Bics case Is more than United.
If United were relegated and then condemned to lower division football for an extended period, there's no way the value of the club could be maintained, and it's unlikely they could generate enough income to service the debt.
Woodward used to come up with the same garbage, probably reiterating his masters voice. I get it: relegation could be a long term disaster, and it might not get rid of the Glazers anyway. But it's really difficult year after year to spend som micuch time and energy hating the owners of our club.
05 Nov 2026 21:48:38
Alternatively, he might just be saying these things to attract investors and protect his asset for a sale. Might have been a sales pitch saying you'll basically make cash even when we're crap on the pitch.
05 Nov 2026 22:54:56
We all view things from the standpoint of supporters and people who love the club and football in general.
The Glazers view their ownership as a well excuted once in a lifetime business acquisition. Why do fans expect them to love the club like they do? It's irrational and unrealistic. For the Glazers it's simply a business transaction.
Do I hate what they have done to the fabric of the club because they lack a love of football and /or the club.. absolutely yes. but I don't hate them
The people responsible for this are the football authorities who allowed the oligarchs and Nation States to plunder our national game for their monetary gain and /or prestige.
Secondly I blame also the management team running the club who have made such bad recruitment decisions of managers and playing staff and laid off hard working longstanding members of staff in the name of making economies. I actually dislike them much more than the Glazers. They are supposed to be football people.
05 Nov 2026 23:54:21
With apparently a 120, 000 long waiting list you can see why Glazer isn't concerned at all about selling seats, and also why they're remaining committed to the new stadium. For them that's where the money is. Most football clubs don't make any or much money. They don't care about the football.
06 Nov 2026 08:29:09
I seem to recall that Gill said something along the same lines many years ago.
05 Nov 2026 14:56:24
So looks like JJ might be off to Real.
I think we are well rid of that family to be honest. Wish him well, but worry that without a strong mentor to take care of him at this young age he could struggle.
Trying to get too much too fast, and thinking he's bigger than the club. Massive massive step to uproute and go to Spain. Likely delay his introduction to the first team further while he adjusts.
Runours were that he didn't show up for U21 pre season this year because it was beneath him, he came a week later with the first team. Tells you everything you need to know about him if true. He could have got an extra week of training in and been ahead of the first team.
We are well rid of him.
05 Nov 2026 19:12:37
He's a child.
But frankly I'd sign for Real Madrid over us. We're a basket case.
05 Nov 2026 20:48:39
Can't wait for his dad to tell Jose to pick him.
05 Nov 2026 22:58:14
He is a young man and being advised by his father. Most youngsters his age would naturally be influenced by a parent.
I don't wish him ill. If he can fulfill the talent that he is said to have then wherever he plays it will be a pleasure to watch him albeit with a fair degree of regret if he isn't playing for us
The one caveat I have is that how many young players were toured as generational stars and ultimately failed to live up to the hype.
05 Nov 2026 22:36:35
It takes a lot more than talent to make it as a professional footballer, I wish him the best of luck, I really do. Because with family like his, he doesn't need any enemies.
He will find it infinitely harder to break into the first team at Real Madrid. Expect him to be sent out on loan as soon as he is legally allowed, and to probably spend several years out on loan, probably before being sold for a modest amount with a buy back and/or sell on clause.
06 Nov 2026 10:17:30
So he supposedly can't see a route into our first team, ahead of the players we have and even though he was going to be called up for the League Cup game, but he's happy to play for Castilla in the Spanish third division in the hope that in god knows how many years, he'll force his way past the Real Madrid players?
Aye, dead on.
05 Nov 2026 16:29:40
Did you see Avram Glazer's comments? Sporting success isn't required to maintain "their" commercial power.
I'll double down on my view from last that we need Manchester United to be relegated in order to financially cripple this Glazer Corporation.
I would rather watch Manchester United in the Championship than continue on this path.
05 Nov 2026 16:45:58
I disagree. Relegation might hurt the club commercially in the short term, but it won't necessarily financially cripple the Glazers. In fact, I think you're giving them far too much credit for being emotionally invested in the club's sporting success.
They've already demonstrated that their priority is extracting commercial and financial value, not winning trophies. Relegation wouldn't suddenly change that mindset. They could cut costs, sell players, restructure the club and continue to protect their own interests.
Who do you think suffers most? The supporters, the staff, the players, the local community and the club's long-term future.
I'm not sure destroying Manchester United in the hope it hurts the Glazers is the best result. We need to get the Glazers out so Manchester United can be rebuilt properly whilst being in the top league and still having some pull.
Why should the supporters sacrifice the club they've loved all their lives to punish owners who have already shown how little they care about its sporting fortunes?
05 Nov 2026 16:51:18
United were relegated only to become the first club to do the treble. It may have taken some time, but it's in the club's DNA to overcome tragedy and adversity. That includes the Glazer's.
I agree with the OP. If that's what it takes it is a very small price to pay. Hey - let's have the Manchester derby on the Championship next season.
05 Nov 2026 17:44:28
Surely these comments of mindset of the glazers go against fit and proper. l mean their lack of awareness is off the scale. How they'vemanage not to have a serious kicking by now is unbelievable. Frightening who owns United and it was allowed to happen by most probably corrupt government officials.
05 Nov 2026 18:10:36
Lunacy to say want them relegated, it would hurt supporters more than Glazers and non guarantee would even come straight back up
Besides we will finish mid table whatever or if nothing even changes
Be careful what you wish for.
05 Nov 2026 19:10:44
There would be no money for they to extract after relegation. They have no reason to own the club and couldn't pay the debts. They would have to sell.
The supporters have been suffering. And will suffer until they are gone.
Nothing short of getting rid of them will be enough. Otherwise its just rearranging the chairs on the Titanic.
05 Nov 2026 19:46:08
Ive been accused of being on glazers pay roll??
This is what I've been saying all along. The glazers own United to make money primarily they are not chasing trophies. Commercial success comes before on field success.
Nobody has to like it but that's the way it is. They have not done anything against the law. They are business men not football fans. The club will be here and will flourish again long after they are gone or maybe while they are here who knows.
But no point at all in moaning they won't clear debt or invest their money.
Only a minute percentage of business owners of a company this size puts a penny of their own personal money in. Most start ups raise funds from outside their own pocket for heavens sake.
They have their agenda it doesn't match ours but that's business.
It awful is unfair on the fans because it could have been very different.
Im happy to support the team win or lose. I've had a lot more losing seasons than winning ones over the last 60 years.
Things will change in time, how long is anyone's guess but until it does crying about it won't help.
05 Nov 2026 22:43:57
The clubs value will never cripple the Glazers. If they sold the club for £1 that would all be profit. They literally haven't put a penny of their own money into the club and have taken out dividends every year for the best part of two decades.
Hell they could probably pay some 100m to take the club off their hands and still be net positive over their ownership.
One of the concerns over the Glazers ownership initially was they had a track record as asset strippers.
If we get relegated, they'll sell off the players to balance the books, and could sell off Old Trafford, Carrington, and all the land the club has recently acquired for the best part of 1bn, pocket all the money, and then sell the club to someone else for 500-800m even as a Championship club without a stadium.
We'd be rid of them, but homeless, and with nothing but a name and a history, and with no way of getting back to where we want to be.
Relegation might get rid of the Glazers, but it would also likely be the end of us for another 20 years, unless we hike up our skirt for some sugar daddy. If we're lucky.
06 Nov 2026 08:33:24
Oh yes, let's 'do a Leeds' and totally screw ourselves into a spiral of bankruptcy. Anybody who believes relegation will be good for the club is insane.
BRD, a very different landscape back then.
05 Nov 2026 11:00:30
Ronaldo retires from international duty, great player for his country but long overdue. Least common sense has prevailed eventually!
05 Nov 2026 12:26:27
Common sense at last. What they really needed was to have a sit down before all this silly stuff happened, and have a serious conversation about how Ronaldo should retire, allow him to go out on his terms, by explaining to him that the team needs to move on and that they are thankful for everything he's done, but the national team needs to refresh.
05 Nov 2026 15:40:50
Maybe Ronny, or Beckham could lead up a consortium to buy out Ineos and Glazers, they are both capable with the contacts and exposure they both get maybe wishful thinking though.
05 Nov 2026 22:59:54
Maybe they did try to have that conversation?
05 Nov 2026 09:04:51
Emery in line for a new deal at villa…if so that’s one of the list then. Can’t blame him either, continue his process there and there much more stable than we are.
05 Nov 2026 14:13:38
I don't know why anyone was expecting we would be in the running for Emery.
04 Nov 2026 21:13:18
Emrey committed to new Aston villa contract
04 Nov 2026 22:43:04
Probably signed it the second Cunhas third when in and he realised our incompetent management weren't getting rid of Carrick.
05 Nov 2026 06:47:32
Ken
Don't believe he has signed anything. Press report he is on £15m a year and his present contract runs until 2029. The amount of compensation will probably put our lot off.
Nice cheap Carrick who tells everyone the Glazers are good owners, doesn't complain at poor transfer windows, there is what they want.
05 Nov 2026 11:32:56
He has committed to a new contract redman.
05 Nov 2026 13:47:26
Reports say, Emery has not yet formally committed to or signed a new contract at Aston Villa, but he is on the verge of doing so. It is being finalised in the coming days.
So Ken, hard to see him moving
Next.
05 Nov 2026 15:42:04
He not signed yet but like players will use us to bleed every penny from Villa.
04 Nov 2026 13:50:51
I learnt a new word yesterday: eucatastrophe. A sudden joyous event at the end of a story saving the protagonist from apparent doom. Going by Tolkien.
Yesterday had 2 of them. United and the US mid terms.
But, that first half. Dalot being stranded way upfield when Mainoo loses the ball to the midfield press. Is that what he's been coached to do? And, given that they were pressing so well, why take the risk? And then the second falls entirely on Maguire's pathetic clearance straight to one of their players.
One has to hope the club is committed to shoring up the back in January, whatever it costs. Of course it should have been done over the summer. The effects of Shaw's leg break and propensity to subsequent injury has been well known to the club. To expect him to make it through a 60 game season without injury was dumb.
04 Nov 2026 14:53:14
I feel one of those is ultimately more important than the other.
Unlike USA, Manchester is RED ?.
04 Nov 2026 16:51:35
This has to be Shaw, Martinez and Maguires last season. It makes no sense to offer any of them new contracts.
04 Nov 2026 16:58:22
Big money needs to be spent in January. Which won't happen. And can we really trust those idiots to get the right players.
Dalot is the worst player we have ever had. How he starts every game. Luckily yoro has done well at RB and hopefully shaw being fit we won't have to see dalot much.
CARRICK OUT.
04 Nov 2026 19:43:12
Dalot is nowhere near the worst player we have ever had. Even during Fergies reign we had several much worse signings. Dalot is just suffering from a lack of confidence and lack of playing structure in a team which is all over the place.
04 Nov 2026 20:34:02
I have no doubt Dorgu would be filling in if he was fit. But he's also crocked.
Shaw has to leave in the summer and be replaced. I can understand the club's reticence if they cannot get their first choices until the summer.
04 Nov 2026 21:49:12
Salford in 8 years he had never been a very good player for us.
He had not excelled for any manager really.
He has over stayed his welcome imo.
04 Nov 2026 23:19:13
Salford, dalots problem isn't a lack of confidence, it's lack of a footballing brain. Yes he runs about alot, but he makes the wrong decisions most of the time. worst thing we did was getting rid of wan bissaka and keeping him.
05 Nov 2026 15:43:22
I would have Dalot in before Dorgu and Mazz every day of the week and twice on Sundays.
05 Nov 2026 20:52:21
He's certainly the worst player to play 250 games for the club. He's just laughable now.
04 Nov 2026
New image uploaded to the
Manchester United Player Sightings page entitled,
Click picture for larger image

Manchester United Banter Archives