Manchester United banter 6
Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.
08 Nov 2026 12:31:02
It's very strange that this run of form has not resulted in a sacking. Even those of us who find Carrick uninspiring could not have predicted our current league position and if we had, surely he would have been.dismissed. Yet here we are.
I know we've done it to death but the incompetence at the top has been staggering, ETH contract then sacking him, the Amorim recruitment and then telling him how to play, and then the Carrick apppointment. And now dithering after what has been a sustained period of awfulness.
Carrick lookms ost and changr is coming, but does anyone have any confidence in the next appointment?
08 Nov 2026 14:43:39
Not really. It's probably Howe and it'll end the same way as all the others.
Until half of our first-team squad come from the academy, there's a clear style of play from top to bottom across the entire club, we can recruit a reasonable mix of high-potential and elite-level players and get rid of players who are no longer good enough, then no manager/head coach is going to be able to achieve the success that's expected and they'll be the ones to take the fall.
08 Nov 2026 11:02:59
{Ed's Note - The fox has posted a new article entitled, Manchester United After the SJR Investment
07 Nov 2026 20:32:37
The band on the Titanic was one of the most enduring stories of heroism from the disaster. They continued to play as the ship sank.
The fans that sing the song about “Carrick” tomorrow need to remember that situation as we sit in the relegation zone.
07 Nov 2026 22:19:40
Ole had us playing miles better football than the dross carrick is serving up and his was murdered on here
The fact Amorim and ten hag we're blasted weekly in the media and by fans and yet we sit 18th and he's still in a job ?
It is baffling how he is still manager
The players are crap yes but he is not getting a tune from them and it needs to change quick
We will be 2 points off safety after tomorrow ?.
07 Nov 2026 18:38:50
Looks like we r heading into tomorrows game in the bottom 3…massive focus now on the players so it will be interesting to see how they respond to a completely different sort of pressure. Last game before another international break so we need a positive performance and result cos immediately after that is a trip to anfield!’ Yikes!
07 Nov 2026 19:19:22
Its looking bleak. these players don't seem to have the stomach for it. Badly need a win, but its blind hope.
07 Nov 2026 17:08:05
Does anyone have contact details for the fans organising the protests? I have been thinking about ways that would be more effective then walking out of a game you've already brought a ticket from and want to float some ideas.
07 Nov 2026 18:21:16
No idea
But, I would start by encouraging the fans to not buy from the in stadium bars, turn their backs to the pitch at an agreed minute.
07 Nov 2026 21:01:24
That'll do it????.
08 Nov 2026 07:35:18
I know Ken, it won't make any difference.
08 Nov 2026 13:04:58
Im not sure that will help us win points.
We could just support the team.
07 Nov 2026 16:57:25
I'm not defending Michael Carrick here but I do think he's not been blessed with the greatest luck.
1. Having to take Rashford back, probably preempting the signing of a back up striker. And maybe forcing the club to keep Zirkzee.
2. The long term injury to Sesko, leaving us with no CF.
3. The predictable injury to Shaw, who is our only decent LB.
4. Injury to Dorgu, who showed last season that he's capable of scoring.
5. The downturn in Bruno's form.
6. Injuries to Mainoo, Baleba and now Baleba again.
7. The long term injury to Ugarte making it impossible to sell him.
8. Martinez's erratic play.
9. Amad becoming entirely pathetic.
07 Nov 2026 17:33:48
@Red Man, I got this.
All of these things are Carrick's fault, he is clearly out of his depth. A proper Manager would have prevented all those injuries, he's a disgrace.
07 Nov 2026 18:38:05
Sarcasm AJH
1. Having to take Rashford back. No, if Carrick had cohones he would have done what Amorim did and insist he was sold or would spend the season separate to the squad
2. Sesko, Shaw. If Carrick had cohones he would have resigned or threatened to, if he wasn't given the necessary players. Amorim showed the passion.
3. The downturn in Bruno's form. Why did that happen? He doesn't believe in Carricks tactics and management, we know that for a fact.
4. Martinez's erratic play. See Bruno answer
5. Amad becoming entirely pathetic. Yet Carrick would not give Lacey time.
Yes, Carrick is out of his depth, he even thought the first half against Roma was ok, that the Glazers are good owners. As I write we are in the relegation zone. It's not about the injuries but that he can't coach what he has got to perform at a level to keep us out of the relegation zone.
There you go, AJH sure you were going to tell everyone the above so saved you the job.
07 Nov 2026 18:45:00
He may have had to take Rashford back but it was Carrick's choice to start him ahead of Cunha when the season began.
So he chose pick a player who didn't want to be there over one who did.
07 Nov 2026 20:34:34
Fast forward one year and insert new managers name .
Until the fishes rotten head is removed we will be in a regular cycle. Any new manager will just be a band aid.
Whether Carrick is right or wrong is a moot point until we give any incoming manager the tools to do his job to be fairly judged.
08 Nov 2026 02:11:12
Bruno doesn't believe in Carricks tactics Red Man ; Did he last year when Carricks tactics helped him break the record of assists;
Bruno is responsible for tactics and if don't like he doesn't play good ; Because you excuse him.
I thought his job is to just play football and help the team, as much as he can, and not tactics.
I am not a fan of Carrick, but sometimes the "hate" makes you blinded.
08 Nov 2026 08:06:37
Heaven
I "excuse him"
I openly said, in each of the last two summers, that we should have sold him. Said numerous times he was bad for team shape tactically, pointed out his contract ran out next summer, he is 32 and it was time to sell. Pointed out he is no captain. I see him for what he is, good player, not a great one, not a leader of the team, inconsistent in games. I also said both Bruno (and Martinez) were right in what they said but should be nowhere near the team now. Weak spineless management from Carrick. Yet you think I excuse Bruno. I excuse Bruno, really?
I don't hate Carrick, at all. Carrick is a good decent man, very likeable person, yet is totally incapable of being Manager of this club and only in place because of being an ex playing hero.
08 Nov 2026 10:44:19
So you answered the question. Bruno must have been sold (and i agree) and his drop of form is on him mainly. Carricks tactics has nothing to do with him running around like headless chicken or moaning constantly for misplaced passes etc.
We have so many reasons to beat Carrick, we must stick to the real ones.
06 Nov 2026 12:13:23
Headline in MEN:
Diogo Dalot issues clear demand to Manchester United teammates - "Not good enough".
Apparently he was supposed to head off upfield, and it was just unfortunate that we lost the ball in midfield...... in other words it was somebody else's fault, which is to say, Mainoo's or Carrick's.
One wonders whether Dalot is even remotely aware that it's his poor performances that have been critical to our current position. Or is completely bone headed?
I really don't care what the overall tactical plan was. When the team is working its way through a midfield press it's insane to leave the whole of the left side completely open. Games are ultimately won by players on the field making good decisions. Dalot has no football brain.
06 Nov 2026 13:43:08
Dalot has massively underachieved, always has a mistake in him and switches off.
However, manager after manager has always picked him when fit so he obvioulsy has something.
Does the above mean he can't be right in his statement, he is including himself in the comment too. Ultimately if the players are going to be speaking at least let them be honest rather than the usual rubbish they come out with.
Now let's see a bit of effort at the weekend!
06 Nov 2026 13:52:18
Maybe, but it seemed to me from the article that he was also blaming bad tactics, in other words throwing MC under the bus.
06 Nov 2026 15:44:30
He was saying that he was told to push up. He was implying that the tactics were ar fault.
06 Nov 2026 16:10:42
We all know the tactics are at fault, Carrick and his team of coaches are so far out there depth it's untrue
Every manager in last 8 years and we had a few have picked Dalot so can't be so bad as few armchair fans make out.
06 Nov 2026 16:46:59
I really hope those comments have upset Carrick so much that he's dropped for the rest of the season ??.
06 Nov 2026 16:56:33
You can suggest the tactics were at fault, but there was a moment in the game that sums up my concern perfectly. Cunha had the ball, was looking for Dalot to make a forward run and was visibly encouraging him to go. Dalot didn't make the run, the opportunity disappeared and Cunha was clearly frustrated. This was highlighted in the sky sports analysis. It lead to the first goal.
Now, that might seem like an isolated moment, but it highlights a much bigger issue. That run would have done one of two things: either dragged a defender out of position and created space for Cunha to drive into, or provided a forward passing option that could have turned their defensive line and put us on the front foot. Instead, Dalot offered neither.
Compare that with the second half against Roma. We started seeing those forward runs, players committing themselves to getting beyond the ball, making movements that stretched the opposition and gave the player in possession options. Suddenly, there was more space, more urgency and a much greater attacking threat. The structure looked completely different, not necessarily because the tactics had dramatically changed, but because players were actually making the movements required to make them work.
That is where I think the distinction between tactics and execution is getting lost. Tactics are only as effective as the players' willingness and ability to carry them out. You can have a perfectly good tactical plan, but if players aren't making the movements, taking up the positions or recognising the opportunities that the system requires, it's never going to work.
It's very easy to point at the manager and say there are no tactics when performances are poor. But are there genuinely no tactics, or are we watching players fail to execute what they're being asked to do?
I'm not suggesting Carrick is beyond criticism or that every tactical decision is right. But I do think some of the criticism is overlooking the responsibility of the players. There has to be a level of accountability on their part too.
A manager can only put a structure in place and give players instructions. He can't make Dalot make that run. He can't make players show for the ball, move intelligently or commit to what they're supposed to be doing.
And when those basic movements and responsibilities aren't happening, the whole system starts to look disjointed. Suddenly, it looks like there's no pattern, no structure and no tactical identity.
But sometimes what we're actually seeing isn't an absence of tactics. It's an absence of players consistently buying into and executing them. The second half against Roma showed what can happen when they do. That's why I think it's far too simplistic to put everything down to the manager.
06 Nov 2026 23:18:39
Great post Ports.
I think what is turning me off Carrick is that he sees what you are suggesting, but then plays the same players again next game.
We can all agree we need better players. But once the starters have shown they won't do, try someone else. Put in a younger leftback. Play Lacy and heaven. Earlier in the season he wasn't playing sesko-although maybe that was related to injury.
Yoro at rightback has been a revelation. He is getting good developmental minutes. He is working hard and competing well. One of the few bright spots of the season. Is he good enough as a rightback? No. But he is holding his end down better than dalot was. I wish we coukd see dorgu leftback as an attacking FB, with Dalot RB as a defensive one. Kind of like the wes brown/evra combo that worked well.
You get respect by being straight forward and picking players based on what you expect and demand. Not shouting at them, or belittling them. How many England players will be missing camps going forward? Most will fight to go is my guess.
07 Nov 2026 08:08:36
Yeah I agree Dodgy. I think this is an area carrick let's himself down. He tend a to stick with the "safe" selections if you like. Throw Lacey in, young players very rarely let you down for effort. It's a real shame Dorgu is out because I agree, would be good to see him in this team from LB.
Even stick Heaven out there. When you have 2 right footers on the left, naturally the side is unbalanced and almost predictable.
07 Nov 2026 18:01:25
Dalot give faith to any youngster hoping the be a pro footballer. All you have to do is run about a bit and you could end up playing for Manchester united for 10 years. You don't have to cross, score goals, tackle, have positional awareness or make good passes, just run up and down and you can get 100+k a week.
06 Nov 2026 07:39:01
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Liverpool v Arsenal - A Quick Liverpool Perspective
05 Nov 2026 20:48:04
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Liverpool v Arsenal - A Quick Liverpool Perspective
06 Nov 2026 02:28:43
Good analysis Ed001. I enjoyed the match, it was a good, high intensity game with Liverpool showing their press and attacking intent, although with little end product, and Arsenal excellent defending. I am impressed with how well drilled Arsenal are, not only against Liverpool but against Bayern etc. Their ability to shoot a game down is second to none. I liked Liverpool too, for large part of the game you were the best team, although part of this is Arsenal giving you the ball and trying to defend.
The part i disagree is about stats from Opta, and the stats in general. There are going to be some mistakes maybe, but they don't lie as you say. McAlister's shoot i am not sure it was a shoot, it seems nore of a very bad pass than a shoot to me.
The way he had his body and the weight he tried to put in the pass, suggest that he tried to loop the ball over the last defender, to find Isak who did (half) a move. Then Van Dijks header I am not sure if he tried to make a pass with his head or even if his header was going outside. In this one i am not sure because in our channel we had no replay.
Opta do make mistakes, some times make mistakes and after one hour make correction. For example counting a shoot as 0, 30 xg instead of 0, 25, they will reassess after the match and make the correction. I think in no way they lie.
{Ed001's Note - they 100% lie. I am sure of it for the betting markets. They were 100% shots. Mac Allister's was certainly not a pass, it was a weak shot but it was defo a shot. I am sorry but Opta are bullshit artists. Van Dijk's header was saved but Raya was listed as making no saves, that can't even be argued that Raya saved it. Those stats are not mistakes, they were outright wrong and it is clear to see so no reason to not correct them, but they haven't.}
06 Nov 2026 11:47:01
Mac Allister had a great chance to score with his head.
Watching here in the US I saw that shirt pull and was astonished that it wasn't called. The commentary team missed it until much later. The only explanation I can think of is that maybe it was so weak. that Isak himself didn't notice it and was unaffected by it, or why else didn't he complain? Did any other Liverpool player.
Good game though. Although Arsenal's lack of enterprise in the second half, made that period less enjoyable. A draw would have been a fairer result.
{Ed001's Note - Isak did notice and turned and had a go at Timber at the time. I am astonished he never said anything to the ref though. It clearly did affect him, it pulled him back, you can see it when you watch it that his forward momentum is arrested and then he ends up missing the ball.}
06 Nov 2026 12:27:37
I've maintained for a while that one of the biggest reasons players go to ground so easily is because, if they stay on their feet, they often don't get the foul. This Isak incident is a perfect example of that.
It's exactly why VAR was introduced, or at least should be used, to distinguish between genuine contact and players going down to win a penalty. The irony is that VAR seems to have reinforced the very behaviour it's supposed to discourage. Players are almost being told to believe that unless they hit the deck, they won't get the decision. Stay on your feet and play through the contact, and you risk getting absolutely nothing. We're effectively rewarding players for going down rather than rewarding them for trying to stay on their feet.
{Ed001's Note - it is very sad and very much to the detriment of the game.}
06 Nov 2026 13:00:34
One sometimes wonder whether the VAR team are not paying any attention whatsoever.
The reality is that where humans are involved errors will be made. VAR can't fix that.
{Ed001's Note - no, but nobody minds errors that are understandable, like missing something in real time. Footie was better without VAR.}
05 Nov 2026 15:30:51
Some delightful words from avram glazer floating about the media sphere today. To say I hate and despise this family would be the understatement of the decade. Their attitude to the club, fans and everyone who loves this great institution is why we are where we are.
05 Nov 2026 19:16:43
The thing is the status of EPL football teams is not protected by a franchise system. The NFL is a revenue sharing collective, so the minimum a franchise can bring in is $450m without selling a ticket, a hot dog or winning a game. It's basically guaranteed income which underpins the economic value of the franchise, which in the Bics case Is more than United.
If United were relegated and then condemned to lower division football for an extended period, there's no way the value of the club could be maintained, and it's unlikely they could generate enough income to service the debt.
Woodward used to come up with the same garbage, probably reiterating his masters voice. I get it: relegation could be a long term disaster, and it might not get rid of the Glazers anyway. But it's really difficult year after year to spend som micuch time and energy hating the owners of our club.
05 Nov 2026 21:48:38
Alternatively, he might just be saying these things to attract investors and protect his asset for a sale. Might have been a sales pitch saying you'll basically make cash even when we're crap on the pitch.
05 Nov 2026 22:54:56
We all view things from the standpoint of supporters and people who love the club and football in general.
The Glazers view their ownership as a well excuted once in a lifetime business acquisition. Why do fans expect them to love the club like they do? It's irrational and unrealistic. For the Glazers it's simply a business transaction.
Do I hate what they have done to the fabric of the club because they lack a love of football and /or the club.. absolutely yes. but I don't hate them
The people responsible for this are the football authorities who allowed the oligarchs and Nation States to plunder our national game for their monetary gain and /or prestige.
Secondly I blame also the management team running the club who have made such bad recruitment decisions of managers and playing staff and laid off hard working longstanding members of staff in the name of making economies. I actually dislike them much more than the Glazers. They are supposed to be football people.
05 Nov 2026 23:54:21
With apparently a 120, 000 long waiting list you can see why Glazer isn't concerned at all about selling seats, and also why they're remaining committed to the new stadium. For them that's where the money is. Most football clubs don't make any or much money. They don't care about the football.
06 Nov 2026 08:29:09
I seem to recall that Gill said something along the same lines many years ago.
Manchester United Banter
Manchester United Banter 2
Manchester United Banter 3
Manchester United Banter 4
Manchester United Banter 5
Manchester United Banter 7
Manchester United Banter 8
Manchester United Banter 9
Manchester United Banter 10
Manchester United Banter Archives