Manchester United banter 8

 

Use our rumours form to send us manchester united transfer rumours.


 
Matchday 9 - Quick Round Up

04 Nov 2026 07:39:02
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Matchday 9 - Quick Round Up

03 Nov 2026 23:15:43
Have said before I want to see Lacy getting more opportunities, his cameo tonight was impressive.

The ball to Cunha for third goal was excellent and shows the difference between him and Amad in terms of creativity at the business end. He needs to be playing more.

Thought Yoro was again our best defender, not much competition I know, but despite not playing his proper position he has applied himself well over recent times.

I still think Heaven has a good future, but he must stop being rash and lunging into tackles.

The difference second half was passion, commitment and pace. These have to be fundamental basic qualities and not optional extras.

Such a shame for Baleba, does not look good, could be out for a while.

Was good to get the blood pumping second half again, it was enjoyable to watch.

04 Nov 2026 11:07:17
I agree I want to see more of Lacey, he's clearly a super talented lad, but more than that you can see that he really wants to play for the team, and that kind of enthusiasm is infectious.

Amad I think is having a tougher run of form right now, but he's still got so much ability. Over the previous two seasons only Bruno was creating more chances per 90 minutes than Amad. He will be fine, I think the injuries, disruption to pre-season and the poor form of the rest of the team are having an impact on his current form.

The real challenge will come once Sesko (or another striker is signed) returns and Mbeumo is moved back to the right. Giving us Mbeumo, Amad and Lacey all fighting it out for one starting spot. Unbelievable depth.

Cunha's fighting spirit and passion are things that will make him a fan favourite. It's great to see and we need a couple more players with that sort of attitude. Again it can be infectious to the other players around them.

Yoro has been surprisingly good at RB, and I think he should get an extended run there. It's a good position for him to gain experience in with less pressure than you get at CB. In the past we've seen players like Wes Brown and John O'Shea get game time when they were less experienced in the fullback positions to great effect.

Heaven desperately need more experience around him, he's got talent and the ability, but he just makes the errors of youth and inexperience. Having someone alongside him who can talk him though the game and reduce those errors is needed. I wonder if we can get MdL back fully fit whether he'd work well alongside Heaven.

I really feel for Baleba, such an unfortunate injury. I hope he gets the chance to fully recover, and we don't rush him back. Hamstrings can be tricky things, and a second tear could put him out for quite a while. One of the often not discussed things around injuries is how the body often tries to compensate for an injury or issue in one part of the body; Which can then cause greater tension or stress in another part of the body, increasing the risk of injury in that area. This is obviously a bigger issue for professional sportsmen as they tend to push their bodies to the limit, which increases the chance of injuries if their body is compensating an injury elsewhere.

I thought having Mainoo back also made a big difference, he was clearly a little rusty in the first half, but he is by far our best midfielder so far this season.

While we have been all doom and gloom on here recently, and rightly so given the performances and results. There are actually quite a few promising players within this group of players.

Players like Lammens, Yoro, Heaven, Dorgu, Mainoo, Baleba, Amad, Cunha, Mbeumo, Sesko and Lacey have all shown real quality and potential. I also think Andrey Santos has been okay so far, with a few bright moments. I think he will turn out to be a good signing in time.

The problem is that we still have too many players who have over time shown themselves to either not be good enough, or lack the mental fortitude to perform when things get tough.

Players like Maguire, Shaw, Dalot, and Mount have consistently underperformed. While the likes of Rashford, Bruno and Martinez have at times performed well (amazingly in Bruno's case), but have shown they maybe lack the mentality when the chips are down. We also still have the likes of Bayindir, Onana, Mazraoui, Ugarte, and Zirkzee still part of the first team squad, all of which need to be moved on as they aren't good enough.

That's 11/12 players who are potentially good enough (most still very young and developing), and 12 players we need to move on as they aren't good enough or lack the right attitude.

When you consider that most of the more senior/stronger characters in the dressing room are in the latter group that needs to be moved on, while the former group is mostly younger, more impressionable, and easier led players; you can see why it's so challenging for a manager to get a consistent tune out of this squad.

You're left in a situation where you either don't play the players that need to be moved on, which will upset the apple cart and they probably bring the mood and performances down for the whole squad. Or you play them to keep the squad harmony, but they have consistently proven they aren't good enough, meaning you fall short of where you need to be. As well as not developing the ones who might actually have a future at the club.

This is a problem that cannot be solved by the manager, and can only be solved by those above him, by moving on those that need to be weeded out and bringing in more suitable replacements.

04 Nov 2026 12:51:49
It i'd time to sell Amad. He is often injured and is quite an inconsistent. With him being at the club for over 5.5 years, he would be classed a pure profit.

Lacey looks livelier, hungrier and more determined than Amad. The question is, does Carrick have the balls to drop him.

03 Nov 2026 22:59:08
Let's hope the players feel that intensity and joy and resolve to carry on in second half mode.

Couple of points

Roma collapsed once we got a goal which definitely helped. Defensively we were still too open and a better team would have punished us. Dalot at left back just cannot defend against decent attackers.

Bruno didn't look overjoyed or even happy after the match and even when he scored there was no smile. He definitely tried and the interplay with Cunha for one of the goals was really good as was his chasing from the start of the second half. But I didn't see any joy and that worries me. All the other players were buoyant at the end.

Cunha showed his class and desire today. His winning goal could only happen when a player has confidence and shows how important confidence is to any team

Shame about Baleeba. You could see how upset he was when he had to come off and I think he will prove to be a good buy for us.

Lacey should play more let Amad and him run themselves into the ground by tracking back to do the defensive work as well as attacking and they can play 45 mins each a game or 60/30

03 Nov 2026 22:10:33
We won a game, it’s Been so long I’ve forgotten what it feels like and how to act lol. Seriously though, good second half and much needed victory.

03 Nov 2026 22:41:04
Proper footy match. Enjoyed it.

03 Nov 2026 23:51:11
I don't know what to say. Where has the fight been before the second half?

03 Nov 2026 21:49:36
I'll preemptively state 'What a turnaround from the lads'!
More of that second half display required, less of the first half.

03 Nov 2026 22:05:09
It was great to see. Finally. But it does make you wonder why they couldn't be bothered in previous games, or even the first half.

03 Nov 2026 22:27:58
About time! Nice to see someone with a bit of balls about them in Cunha. Brilliant second half now let’s crack on.

03 Nov 2026 22:28:55
It looked like the players didn't keep to the tactics set out before the game and played out in the first half. Got in the dressing room at half time, had a shout and decided they didn't want to go out of the competition so let's ignore him and go for it.

I still don't know
1. How Carrick preferred Rashford over Cunha for so long
2. How Lacey doesn't start over Amad
3. How Dalot earns a living at football
4. How Amass doesn't get time at LB in front of Dalot

Heaven help us if one, very welcome, win keeps Carrick in place.

03 Nov 2026 22:38:56
Dalot kills me, yet he'll start again on Sunday. Absolutely woeful. As for Carrick that will keep him a while longer, the second half performance gives the board an excuse to carry on and point to a turn around. Can't see it but they aren't too smart.

03 Nov 2026 22:46:46
Lacey cameo was superb. Proper attitude and what a touch he has.

Despite him getting pelters, I like Cunha. Think he could be a big player for us if we let
Him.

03 Nov 2026 23:33:09
So let me get this right Red Man, if the tactics are wrong it's Carrick, if the tactics are right, they ignored him? Interesting take.

04 Nov 2026 01:47:37
Yeah, that's what happened Red Man ?.

04 Nov 2026 05:47:26
Hi, my name is Red Man, these are my blinkers.

04 Nov 2026 06:17:50
Ah the crew are out who say it's all the players fault, it's not Carrick until we have one half of football that doesn't resemble the managers tactics and win, now it's Carrick the mastermind. I rest my case.

04 Nov 2026 06:30:58
Nobody is saying that Red Man, but you see what you want to see. We have been dreadful, the second half last night was awesome. Carrick gets some credit for that.

04 Nov 2026 06:48:25
AJH
The first half was beyond dreadful, a lack of effort or passion and tactically clueless. Looked to me like the players felt they want to continue to play in this competition no matter who the manager is. Just pleased to see it, but I don't think it was a sudden half time masterclass from Carrick. Carrick still has to go.

04 Nov 2026 06:55:10
Or maybe, being devils advocate, they finally followed what he wanted or he changed his tactics and it worked?

Always three sides to every argument. Two opinions and the facts.

04 Nov 2026 07:18:40
I'm assuming these are the same players that carried out the tactics in the first half v Chelsea and at half time, had a shout and decided they didn't want to run around in the 2nd half?!

04 Nov 2026 08:51:32
The other option is to say well done good comeback. On Sat good 1st half carrick got the blame from you redman at half time in that game. Last night he takes the credit for the 2nd half.

04 Nov 2026 13:56:42
Good comeback

Problem is Ken, some fans spend so much time saying when we lose it isn't the manager, it's the players and no point changing manager. But then we win and it's the manager.
It didn't look tactical last night that changed the second half but they just looked self motivated. The Carrick demeanour hardly changes, can he deliver the SAF half time speech or was it Bruno who reports say was the one shouting and motivating at half time?

04 Nov 2026 17:04:38
Red Man, I don't for one minute think Carrick has shown himself to be good enough. So, no need to throw out sweeping, incorrect generalisations.

C'mon, you're better than that, fella.

But you have to expect a response when you start making up stuff about the dressing room that no-one knows, other than those that were actually present.

03 Nov 2026 20:15:32
I stupidly go into every game with the hope it will start to get better. That this will be the day they turn up. And then i remember the team is full of chancers, lucky to have a job and dismay quickly sets in.

Turns out tonight is not any different. Another game, another defeat likely.

03 Nov 2026 20:24:54
Frankly ridiculous. utd will finish 20th, the defending is pub standard. Its shambolic at the back. ffs carrick actually do something.

03 Nov 2026 20:42:49
If Carrick had Mbappe, Yamal and Haaland on the bench he'd probably still bring on a defender.

03 Nov 2026 22:03:25
Stadler and waldorf.

03 Nov 2026 23:33:45
We won't finish 20th ?.

04 Nov 2026 00:44:51
This aged well!

04 Nov 2026 12:36:54
I'm happy to look a little silly in posting too early if it means United win.

03 Nov 2026 13:57:17
Nearly 20 years ago now Carrick himself scored twice while thrashing Roma 7-1. What's the bets on a repetition tonight?

03 Nov 2026 14:22:08
What 7-1 to Roma ?.

03 Nov 2026 15:06:28
Have we even scored 7 goals all season?

03 Nov 2026 15:24:25
That was one if the best halved of football i have seen, an incredible team goal scored by Alan Smith.

03 Nov 2026 15:25:52
My bet is that we have 20-25 min of intensity in the first half but don't score. Players are shattered by the second half, and Roma win by two. Carrick says there were some encouraging moments, but it's not good enough, he's looking forward to Villa because they lads are great in training.

03 Nov 2026 18:43:33
Danny knows the drill. Next interim.

03 Nov 2026 19:03:36
Danny ???.

03 Nov 2026 11:30:31
Dan Ashworth was sacked because his recommendations of Eddie Howe as manager was underwhelming for Sir Jim.

But Jason Wilcox got a promotion after speaking highly of Russel Martin.

The blind leading the blind.

03 Nov 2026 15:07:39
Dan Ashworth got sacked because he didn't agree with the party line.

03 Nov 2026 15:29:21
Dan Ashworth wasn't sacked. There was a mutual agreement to terminate his contract after his position became untenable. Because a director of that doesn't have the authority to direct footballing decisions, they're not really a director of football.

By the by, Ratcliffe didn't ditch him for not towing the party line. Ashworth's crime was giving honest and realistic appraisals of what a rebuild entails - i. e. doing the job he was hired to do.

03 Nov 2026 22:44:12
And remains the worst decision yet hey Ineos. And they've made some stinkers.

Matchday 9 - Quick Round Up

03 Nov 2026 09:17:47
{Ed's Note - Ed001 has posted a new article entitled, Matchday 9 - Quick Round Up

02 Nov 2026 21:17:31
My observation of Arsenal over the last 10 days alone:
1. They are mentality monsters.

2. They have a great manager who instils a hate for losing not just a match but a dual a header or a tackle losing anything is not acceptable.

3. Arteta is as hated by opposing fans as fergie was. That's good for Arsenal.

4. They have good players. But they have full backs who can't cross too and no decent goal scoring cf.

5. I loved artetas reaction and quotes to young dowmans sending off.

6. Arteta was given time and shown patience by Arsenal board who ignored the fickle know all fans.

7. There are a lot of good candidates do to this job at united we need a board to show faith in the next man ignore our over emotional supporters and don't expect a 5 year job to be done in 2 years.

8. Arsenal are not boring they are a great team to watch really well organised motivated and drilled yes there is a lack of flair but i can appreciate lots of other great things to watch.

Man for man technically a lot of our players are as good as theirs in lots of respects, they are just not organised. What i mean by that is if you put dalot in rb instead of white Dalot would do well or Shaw instead of Hincipie or Baleba for lewis skelly.


Reminds me of that Morcombe and wise sketch. You have all the right notes your just playing them in all the wrong order.

Whomever they get in needs to be allowed time to get it right with zero redline expectations other than relegation for 2 years while he moulds his squad. They need to ignore the fans that get over emotional like the Arsenal board did with Arteta like the United board did with Fergie. Open heart surgery needs doing and it takes time but i don't think a lot of our fans have the stomach for it.

They get teased in work they get 'embarrassed', so they call for managers to be sacked they accuse the players of being fickle and not having the stomach for the fight but a lot of fans don't have the stomach for the fight.

The club will be here long after Bruno long after Carrick long after Wilcox and long after the Glazers.

Yes it's a tough time but I'm happy to stick my chest out and say this is my club the one i support through thick and thin. I'm not embarrassed I'm not happy but I'm not embarrassed. We will get it right again and if we don't before i pop my clogs, ill die believing we will.

03 Nov 2026 01:42:57
Arteta learnt leadership from Pep, in organization, in training methods, expectations, dark arts, lack of toleration for failure to apply 100% effort at all times. Who has Carrick learnt from? Who at United has similar experience of what it means to strive to be the best? Who at United would recognize a player who has what it takes to get to and be at the top. How many players have received the type of coaching particular to a top team?

Had they been inculcated with the right footballing ethos over the years, maybe some of them could slot into a top team but I'm not convinced about the majority of them. There's a reason why none are actually at one and why most of them are not worth much in the transfer market. I do agree however that properly trained and organized this team should be doing better.

03 Nov 2026 02:56:15
You have to find the right one. We need to develop the stomach for the long haul.

I think amorim was that guy. But the change in formations was just too much, which made him inconpatable. Playing bruno in a 2 man midfield was not working, he needed to be braver and sell bruno and get the right 8s and the right wingbacks.

Ten hag could have been a success, but he did get longer and it didn't work. The players he brought in were obviously poor. Anthony alone I think is what did for any belief in him.

I think the manager need to be a dissaplinarian, it needs to be clear that he rules the roost. I honestly only think that will come about from major change. Look at Arteta, all his supposed stars were sold and new players, team players, brought in. I don't believe a manager can come in and be a big success without removing the core of the team that came before.

So the plan would be a strong manager who is tactically similar to how United want to play. Trusts in youth, modern ideas. Is absolutely in charge and expects players to meet his standards or they don't play. No matter what. No interference from above. We should be ball dominant, but not tiki taka, mixing quick offense with game control. Crosses and threaded through balls. I would say the old team needs to be dismantled. So, bruno, McGuire, Martinez, shaw, rashford, dalot all gone in quick succession. So that probably means playing heaven and yoro with 2 new fullbacks. Maybe 433 would work, given more midfield protection to the back 4 and giving good width. Cunha, mainoo and a defensive monster (baleba? ) In a midfield 3. Lacy, sesko, mbuemo in front 3 - but missing that killer 9 to lead the attack. Desperate need for 2 real fullbacks and depth all over the pitch. But with that squad makeup, plus careful additions, I think a manager would gain control of the toxicity in the dressing room. w would be a young team learning on the job and hopefully the fans would have some patience.

It honestly can't be worse than what we have.

03 Nov 2026 09:01:36
1. Wenger walked out the door when he finished unlike Fergie who hung around and stuck his oar into decisions like his replacement, like Ole coming in, like Ronaldo coming back. That has been a major difference.

2. Arsenal are on a much sounder financial footing than us, and have modern stadium etc. This makes it a much better environment for a manager to work in.

3. Arsenal don't have a Big Sir Jim, who's ego will mean he is constantly interfering instead of letting those appointed to roles in charge of club to do their jobs.

03 Nov 2026 11:45:56
So based on that do we just keep Carrick and let him turn things around?

03 Nov 2026 11:59:33
No Eric imo that ship has sailed.
I think he lacks experience and know how as do his coaching team.

03 Nov 2026 13:05:30
He is not demonstrating that he is in charge.

Maybe removing all the senior players would help him with that, but it is a huge risk when I ddint feel he has shown enough to diserve that backing. Maybe if he played a few more younger players and showed that he was improving them. Amad, cunha both look worse under carrick for example.

03 Nov 2026 13:07:59
Imagine if Arsenal had a top striker.

03 Nov 2026 14:28:05
Who says that would make them better ajh. It might ruin the team dynamic. Same as we might be better without bruno.
A team is always built as a sum of its parts not on individuality.

03 Nov 2026 16:32:27
Are you really saying that some of our players can get in the Arsenal team, would you mind sharing who that would be please, I am very intrigued.

03 Nov 2026 22:05:29
Of course, that's not what i said.

 


Manchester United Banter


Manchester United Banter 2


Manchester United Banter 3


Manchester United Banter 4


Manchester United Banter 5


Manchester United Banter 6


Manchester United Banter 7


Manchester United Banter 9


Manchester United Banter 10


Manchester United Banter Archives

Posting / Reply Form

To post you must be logged in with a username. Please Log In or Register for a username.


 

 

 

 

 

Posting / Reply Form

To post you must be logged in with a username. Please Log In or Register for a username.


 

 

 

 

 

 
Log In or Register to post
User
Pass
Change Consent