Manchester United Rumours Member Posts


Herrera's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

Herrera's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Herrera's Posts



To Herrera's last 5 rumours posts


To Herrera's last 5 banter posts


To Herrera's last 5 rumour replies


To Herrera's last 5 banter replies


Herrera's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Herrera's rumours posts


04 Oct 2020 01:28:36
People say Cavani will score goals. Playing where ? As things stands our trident up front is untouchable, there is no place uo to debate.
Unless you give up on martial is not a good move. With 10 millions to his manager, a big sighning on fee and big wages the expectations are to start games. So he will start in expense of who ?


1.) 04 Oct 2020 03:06:14
The phrase it’s a squad game springs to mind.

2.) 04 Oct 2020 04:11:06
Herrera, if that is how things worked, Ole wouldn't have played 1 game for United as he was also mostly used as a sub.

There should be no untouchables in the team no matter who you are as that creates complacency and your performance level drops.
Cavani will be here for short term and will create that competitive atmosphere and will keep Martial on his toes. Martial last scored in the QF against LASK and yet he plays every game.

Cavani as i read will be on lesser wages than Sancho would have been plus no 110m to Dortmund so i don't see that as too much of an issue.

I still feel we will get Telles with Dalot gone now. Sancho, i don't know but i do think a winger might come, Sarr may be.

3.) 04 Oct 2020 04:56:03
You do realize that this season is very congested with most weekends and midweek being matchday for 1 comp or other. Also with the little known thing called C.V. players might miss some games due to positive test or quarantine.

Maybe you can take a look at Liverpool right now. They signed Jota to be a backup. Right now Sadio Mane is out with C. V. So while Mane is self isolating, Jota willm fill in for him.

Also we didn't have a single forward on the sub bench against Brighton in the PL.

If there has ever been a season when having a good option to cover, its this season. No matter who we see as first choice, the chances are they will miss a few games due to one factor or another.

4.) 04 Oct 2020 07:00:43
Cavani probably = Sanchez Mk2.

5.) 04 Oct 2020 07:14:34
I think he will rotate with the other 3.

6.) 04 Oct 2020 07:45:10
Sanchez never wanted to come to United in the first place so i don't see how it could be similar.

7.) 04 Oct 2020 08:06:05
Disagree. We desperately needed a centre forward to:

A) put pressure on Martial, who sometimes plays as if he has no competition for his place.

B) fill in for Martial, especially with the upcoming Tues/ Weds/ Sat/ Sun set of fixtures. Ighalo couldn’t have done this well enough.

C) be on the bench for when we need a plan B.

D) show our three excellent young forwards how to score ‘scruffy’ goals.

Cavani will do all four far, far better than Ighalo. For a combined 25 (ish) million over two years inclusive of wages and agent fees.

Absolute no brainer for me.

Now for a RW, LB and CB. 😂.

8.) 04 Oct 2020 08:57:16
We need another forward, we will play around 60 games this season and in a shorter time period than a normal season.

Radical idea: Why don’t we wait a few months to see how things pan out rather than doom Cavani to failure before he’s even signed a contract.

9.) 04 Oct 2020 10:10:32
I like Cavani, he'll provide different options for the squad across the front. Rashford and Greenwood can all play on the right. Why not for a season or two. Sancho is an excellent player but I'd much prefer to see a decent centre back brought in with some of the money that would of been spent on him.

Separate issue here, but does anybody think Wan Bissaka could possibly play in the centre back position? I'm not saying he should or shouldn't, I'm just wondering what other, more knowledgeable posters think.

Have a great weekend everyone, fingers crossed for three points today.

10.) 04 Oct 2020 11:19:31
Martial is nowhere near consistent enough to be leading the line for Manchester United. Even if it's for one or two seasons Cavani could have an impact similar to Ibrahimovic, which although did have injured spells was still a decent period for the club. I'm in!

11.) 04 Oct 2020 11:25:49
If he can stay for, its an astute signing. Classy, winner, worker, professiona, he could have an impact.

12.) 04 Oct 2020 12:00:18
The question for me is why did they wait until now to get Cavani? He has been available for months, why didn’t we get him at the beginning of the season? Have they suddenly realised Martial is inconsistent and Ighalo is someone who really wasn’t good enough for the Premier League?

I think Cavani is a useful addition if he stays fit, we needed a striker, but it doesn’t look part of a plan. Personally I would have gone for Jovic at Madrid. Let’s see how Cavani does, but what plan was it part of?

13.) 04 Oct 2020 12:43:40
Herrera iur front 3 can't start every game. Assuming they start 30 league games each which would be a first for any of them then cavaini has 24 starts. It makes sense to me. i'd rather have cavaini starting those 24 than lingard or james but that's just me.
We need strength in depth up there and we get it and you are unhappy?
Could be a very astute signing. We are desperately short of experience consistency and know how in our front line.
A bit like if we had signed grealish i'm hopeful but not over expectant.

14.) 04 Oct 2020 13:31:52
Ken if its 40+ millions for two years for a squad player with injuries problems that's a problem. 10 millions a year to player, 10 to manager and 10 sighning on fee maybe.

I want options upfront because it is a squad game but i would prefer someone cheaper and a lot younger with legs who can understand his squad role better than Cavani. And if i would buy an older it would be Zirou to have a different option because his hold up play is excellent.

Its not like we buyed a class player who is technically excellent and its not a problem if he legs has gone because he has other attributes. Cavani did use his legs, his strength was his legs, his runs. He was never was excellent finisher, he was never was excellent with the ball and he was never was technically excellent.

He scored a lot because he run a lot, have a decent finishing (usually) and involved in many chances) . So if his legs have gone he is half the player he was because psishicallity was his numper one strength. This and the fact that with the money involved he must play no matter how bad he is, he is a risk not worth taking.

15.) 04 Oct 2020 14:06:33
I think we can all agree that we shouldn’t be too concerned about the exact financial details as both - we don’t know them exactly (at least till next financial reports) and we don’t really know if it really hurts us that much financially

From a football player perspective, it looks like your assessment is off in terms not being a good finisher and only about running. Like many have said, waiting all summer to do this (Cavani reduced his demand too now) seems desperate but also - would we rather not have him now in the position we are in today? If the club does sign him, I hope we can give the player a chance before writing him off.

16.) 04 Oct 2020 14:56:08
Have his legs gone?

17.) 04 Oct 2020 15:52:56

Don’t think so, 3 seasons ago he scored 49 goals in all competitions, just had a few injuries last season, PSG fans wanted him to stay from what I’ve read, works hard for the team and scored goals.

18.) 04 Oct 2020 16:23:29
One season ago Sanchez was one of the best players in Premier League too. But in some cases especially at 30 the downfall is a matter of 2-3 injuries. Our own Giggs would never have played until 40 so well if he had injuries problems at 32-33.
People say he only had injurie problems the previous two season like it is a coincidence. The truth is that for because he is the wrong side of 30 the injuries started for good.

19.) 04 Oct 2020 17:57:16

Terrible example, Giggs had a lot of injuries at 32-33.

20.) 05 Oct 2020 10:45:14
Cavani is a good signing. Ighalo isn't good enough and he goes in January and he poses no threat to Martial's position. It may give Martial a kick up the arse now his position is properly under threat.

21.) 05 Oct 2020 22:22:17
Whatever Manchester United’s transfer strategy was this summer, it didn’t involve signing a 33-year-old free agent at the last minute.

22.) 05 Oct 2020 22:23:25
Untouchable? They struggled to score against Palace. They won't get a sniff today either, hardly untouchable.



13 Apr 2020 14:24:28
Hi Ed002. In another page you said that Madrid will likely bid for Haaland. Do we still have interest in player ? And although i don't believe it, has Raiola put a release clause of 75 million in his contract ?


{Ed002's Note - There is no chance of him moving to Manchester United I am afraid. I am not sure why yoo mention a release clause.}

1.) 13 Apr 2020 15:25:27
I guess it was my fault Ed002 i asked about a release clause. Thanks for quick response.




Herrera's banter posts with other poster's replies to Herrera's banter posts


12 Feb 2022 23:20:49
I don't think we were magnificent but i don't understand some negativity. This was an average performance yet we created 3 goals. Yes we had 3 expected goals in this match, we had nearly 2 against Burnley and 4 against Boro. Its clearly a matter of putting the ball in the back of the net, yet only few criticise Ronaldo.
To put some perspective last year we had 5 expected goal and won 9-0. The difference is last year Soton weren't on form and played with 10 players-and then with 9.

But the short term view see only the results and say wow if you win. And then we can go on another cycle. Personally i am excited with i see. Its the only time in the last 5-6 years we look like a bit like a proactive team like the top dogs play


1.) 13 Feb 2022 00:13:07

Love the positivity, but look at the game. We dominated for 30 mins (again) and then our true colours came through.

Players are not fit enough, not putting enough effort in. They visibly stop working and running. After 30 mins you get the half hearted effort runs, the ones that look like you care but you are really only running 85%.

Has anyone noticed how Ronaldo and Rashford duck under every long ball instead of heading it? Drives me crazy.

Pogba played very well. Looked great in a midfield 2. Must be coming to the end of his contract or something?

It is like the team have gone to sleep, they need a rocket up them.

And every single goal scored against us, there is a shot of Ronny and Fernandes standing upfront gesturing at how crap the defense is. This squad is broke and I can't wait until this season is over and some of these mercenaries leave our club.

2.) 13 Feb 2022 00:27:31
Dodgy all are true. But its also true that last 3-4 weeks we are seeing a much better and more proactive team. Ofcourse that not lasts more than 45 minutes, but why you are all forgetting that this is the start and we are far from perfect?
Three matches in a row with 60+ shoots and 10 expected goals but we only scored 3. Why don't you blame the forwards?
Today we wad 4 clear cut chances to zero and 3 expected goals. And that was not our best day and that's show how far we have gone.

3.) 13 Feb 2022 02:06:45
I am blaming the forwards.

Just seen Ralf Hass Comments. Just let that sink in for a minute. He is a rival coach saying it is well known that utd don't bother to track back. Unbelievable. The minimum we as fans can expect is that the team put in maximum effort and work hard. And it is actually in both directions, they are not pushing hard enough going forwards either.

4.) 13 Feb 2022 05:59:23
When you are not playing well and confidence is low, the minimum you should expect is a team to work hard, but at the moment a team with lesser talented players can turn up, out work our team and get their just rewards.
A new coach coming in has to look at this lot and think, a decent offer for any of them and they must go.

5.) 13 Feb 2022 09:07:56
The players have shown time and time again that they don't care. The club chose not to bring in any new players in January. This isn't RR fault.

You can only p1$$ with the c0ck you've got.

6.) 13 Feb 2022 12:04:00
Really surprised Utd didn't sign anybody in January but then again lots of people here (and Ralf himself) stated that Utd shouldn't be signing 3-4th choice targets if the first isn't available. It doesn't help us now though, a new DM could really have helped out.

7.) 13 Feb 2022 12:16:32
Dodgy I don't say we ate perfect. What Hassenhutl says we all know is true but that's above the manager for the moment and not a quick fix. that's the reason i don't understand the comments about Ralf. Ralf playing his part and he is playing it really well.



11 Jan 2022 19:41:21
A bit different here. I don't think we were that bad. In the first half we were good and could and must have scored more.
Second half they took possession but except from a couple of chances De Gea had an easier night compares to previous matches. They outnumbered us in the centre and Ralf should make the changes earlier.
Overall not very good but i think a lot better than in previous matches and have in mind that we had a very good midfield three against us.


1.) 11 Jan 2022 20:10:33
I thought the first half was ok too, the second was dreadful though, we were horribly outplayed. Small steps I guess.

2.) 11 Jan 2022 20:44:26
AJH i think they outnumbered us. There were moments that MacFred were against 4 oppositions or five. The thing with pressing is that every time it fails then you have problem and i think similar problem Liverpool had against them when they conceded 6. They weren't prepared enough because of C.V. and the pressing didn't work so the "runners" of Villa made their job.
But first half was very good and the second best after the Palace game. *Far from perfect but very good.



09 Jan 2022 16:55:49
Ed001, I know i will get pelters from some people but do you think (at least in the last 3-4 years) Ronaldo is hugely overrated ?
I can see the new Real without Ronaldo, they started to find their feet and have no problems in scoring goals. At Juventus i think they scored around 85 the year before he joined and then when he arrived the downfall started. We scored at a good rate too unless he arrived.
I think he doesn't help his team score many goals but the team help him score to continue his legacy. I would say he is a huge problem for us and maybe the main problem on the pitch. And if we were to believe the press he is a bad influence off the pitch too


{Ed001's Note - yes because he doesn't do enough off the ball. Yes he can sometimes pull you out of the fire, but it is not enough in the modern game to be spending 89min playing with a man just watching and waiting for a chance to shoot.}

1.) 09 Jan 2022 18:38:30
We should get rid of him in the summer, he has made us worse.

Players have gone pants all because of him, they csnt defend, can't pass, don't run and don't move.

2.) 09 Jan 2022 19:11:16
And yet RR continues to play him, this player who seems to be the opposite of everything his tactics demand.
I guess you can look at a player's numbers in terms of running, pass % etc, then his actual figures in terms of goals and contributions and deduce that the latter still wins out.

3.) 09 Jan 2022 21:17:44
Hugely overrated is a little mad, he’s coming to the end of his career and isn’t the player he was but he hasn’t been overrated throughout his career, his trophy haul and individual honours say everything.

4.) 09 Jan 2022 20:39:13
Thank you Ed001. I would get rid of him now if i could.

{Ed001's Note - very welcome.}

5.) 10 Jan 2022 00:01:32
He is no longer cut out for the high energy huff and puff of the EPL and what's more. and this is more to the point. he is just the last in a long line of old, crocked, reluctant and/ or short term trophy players United have hired in the hope that they can somehow mask the rot at the core of the club. It started with RVP who at least turned in one great season. Since then we've had Falcao, Di Maria, Pogba, Ibrahimovic and Cavani. From a dressing room point of view It must surely be a demotivating decision to further delay the playing opportunities for young players.

6.) 10 Jan 2022 00:35:35
His trophy haul? Is close enough with Benzema Ramos. Football is a team sport and the legacy don't always match the greatness of a player. Not even his individual records.
He is the definition of overated-a player that is nowhere near as good as he is in theory and he plays with his reputation. Give me a fully fit Cavani any day of the week.

7.) 10 Jan 2022 07:01:12
Shawthing, you forgot Schweinsteiger.

8.) 10 Jan 2022 08:56:53
It's not like we were playing scintillating football before Ronaldo rejoined.

9.) 10 Jan 2022 09:58:41
It's funny how some fans can just change and the drop of a hat.
Back in September he was the best thing since sliced bread.
Everyone was celebrating saying welcome home CR7, welcome back to your spiritual home all this sh*t.

By the way i was never in favour or him coming back but i would never say a bad word about him because of what he has done and achieved in his football career.
It was never going to be the fairy tale ending.
There were so many things that i didn't like about this signing when it happened.

1) His massive ego.
2) The whole team having to change the way they play to accommodate him.
3) I never understood why we needed another forward when we scored more goals last season then anybody else apart from Man City. It was obvious that we were desperate for a midfielder and that should of been the priority.
4) Stumping the growth of the younger talent like Greenwood.

United were bad enough before he joined, this has just added to the of problems that need addressing at the club.
Lets hope that he (Ronaldo) has had enough decides to move in this month.

10.) 10 Jan 2022 10:06:16
It was an unnecessary nostalgia trip at the time and many people on here questioned the wisdom of the transfer so its not revisionism.

It also shows how much Pep and city have rattled us as a club and how much we are in awe of them and what they have achieved in the premier league that as soon as they are linked with a player we get scared and try to pip them without any thought of how we would actually integrate those players into our own team.

Maguire, Fred, Alexis and now a 37 year old Ronaldo. City have pulled our pants down in the transfer market four times now and set the club back years.

11.) 10 Jan 2022 10:50:23
I think several people questioned whether he was a signing we NEEDED to make.

If memory serves I think people felt that the club should make the signing more to stop him going to City than because we were desperate for him.

Also I think only ignorance can stop someone from changing their mind when presented with evidence to the contrary of what they previously thought.

Thinking a player will be a good signing and celebrating that signing is fine.

Yet if afterwards that signing creates problems or doesn't live up to expectations then there is nothing wrong with reversing that previously held belief that he would be a good signing.

When we signed Falcao, Di Maria, Pogba etc the general consensus was they were good signings who'd improve the team.

That isn't how things worked out, only an idiot would say Di Maria was a good signing now.

It's perfectly okay, and even intelligent to say something you tried didn't work and so you're moving on.

Ronaldo individually has done okay, 14 goals in 21 appearances is a solid return.

Yet the stats also say only 10 wins from 21 games in which Ronaldo has played for us.

Last season without Ronaldo the team had a win rate of 66% of our matches.

This season with Ronaldo in the team that drops to around 47%.

Goals scored without Ronaldo in the team is 2.23 per game average.

Goals scored with Ronaldo in the team is 1.48 per game on average.

Goals conceded without Ronaldo in the team 0.89 per game.

Goals conceded with Ronaldo in the team 1.67 per game.

Every single stat you look at when comparing the team before and after Ronaldo joined shows that we performed better WITHOUT him.

Before we were Manchester United, now we are Ronaldo and Manchesterettes.

Simply put the EPL is too strong a league and we are too weak a side to effectively play with 10 men for 89 minutes while those 10 players play to create chances for the one.

We have players who aren't good enough as part of a starting ELEVEN.

Expecting McFred to do the work of 3 players when they struggle to be effective as two players is just a bridge too far.

There is nothing wrong with saying you're a huge fan of Ronaldo, that he holds a special place in your heart from his first spell at the club. But that he is now a one trick pony (scoring) who is a huge distraction and makes the team weaker overall.

12.) 10 Jan 2022 12:39:46
Sorry, is it all Ronaldos fault now or what? ?.

13.) 10 Jan 2022 15:01:35
Nah Angel it's Ole's, oh wait hang on the team is just as bad after he left as they were before.

Ronaldo has disrupted the balance in the dressing room and made more problems than he solves.

That doesn't mean him leaving solves everything, just that the club would have been significantly better off had we let Ronaldo join City and signed that bloody CDM we have known we needed for at least 18 months.

Maybe City would be top by a couple more points, or maybe they'd be worse off. But we'd have 8-10 points more at least.

Signing Ronaldo was akin to putting an extra coat of paint on a house that needs underpinning. We needed to fix the god damn foundations not pretty the place up a bit.

Ronaldo has added a pressure or cast a shadow over the other players resulting in their performances dropping by 10-20%. You can't have most of your team drop their level by 20% and expect them to achieve more.

14.) 10 Jan 2022 15:15:35
I honestly think Ole had no say on bringing him in or not.
He was coming whether Ole liked it or not.
It was down to Ferguson poking his nose in and the Glazers who obviously seen the $$$$ signs.

15.) 10 Jan 2022 16:11:57
shappy them stats are bolloxy mate

what about the percentage of mistakes from players?

the percentage of how far we have ran since last year to now.

how many tackles we put in per game

to say ronaldo is the reason we a rubbish its laughable

guess pogba is lucky he is injured or it would be him getting the blame.

16.) 10 Jan 2022 16:34:52
Bolger, if you removed you head from Ronaldo's posterior then you'd stop staving your brain of oxygen and might be able to see what is clearly in front of you.

Last season we were crap because of the manager, this season we get rid of that manager and we are worse.

The difference is Ronaldo has placed a pressure on the players they can't cope with.

While there could be an argument that maybe players at our club should be able to deal with that pressure. The fact remains that they can't and they are unlikely to be able to learn to deal with it.

Until Ronaldo leaves I can't see us significantly improving. There is a good reason Juventus were desperate to get him off the books last summer and it actually had nothing to do with wages. Juventus scraped top 4 last season on the last day, finishing 1 point above Napoli in 5th.

There is a good chance we don't make top four this year, and I can't see Ronaldo sticking around to play in the Europa League or even worse the Europa conference. I wouldn't be surprised to see him leave in the summer regardless of what happens.

17.) 10 Jan 2022 17:09:40
Last season it was clear that we need a holding to allow us play on front foot. A more proactive manager too. I think WHEN we attacked with numbers we were really good and we must have build on this. We are nowhere near as good as we were with Ronaldo because all are about him and not the team.
Shappy its a loss situation. People can't accept that a player who scores goals, say Lukaku, Zlatan or Ronaldo, can be the main problem.

18.) 10 Jan 2022 18:07:25
Herrera, it's a simple balance problem.

In the past we have struggled because we only attacked down our left. Now all our attacks are focused toward Ronaldo. We are predictable and unfortunately Ronaldo is no longer dynamic enough to make chances for himself consistently.

It's the same problem, we've just shifted it. While the pressure of playing with Ronaldo is too much for most of our players.

19.) 10 Jan 2022 18:33:01
Last year we was crap because of the manager this year because of ronaldo.

Maybe your head should get out the clouds and realise its the other 10 players.

My head ain't uo ronnies behind but he isn't the reason we are what we are.

A surgeon is a pressure job, a paramendic a fireman not playing football with ronaldo ?

We all have opinions and i respect yours but this is my opinion.

20.) 10 Jan 2022 21:56:32
Ronaldo the issue tonight shappy?

That performace tonight was a shambles.

21.) 11 Jan 2022 00:57:07
How can we be blaming Ronaldo for everything?
If City had bought Ronaldo, they would have scored another 20 goals. They have a manager who knows how to play team football and creat chances for all players.
Ronaldo is playing in a side devoid of character, ideas, guts, pride. It's a team game, so all players are to blame.

22.) 11 Jan 2022 07:27:34
Bolger, the first half was the best we have played in 3-4 games if not the best half since the first half against Palace.

The second half we looked tired. Of course there are still problems, and no doubt half the players are learning how to shoot again now they were allowed without having a bollocking off of Ronaldo.

23.) 11 Jan 2022 08:26:46
Riiiiiight Shappy, at least your posts are getting funnier ?

Damn Ronaldo and his high standards, all his fault. If he hadn't been playing against Villa, we would have been much better. Hold on a second.

24.) 11 Jan 2022 08:31:01
Ole has gone now Shappy, he was a huge huge mistake. Ralf has a big job on his hands.

I liken the team to children Shappy,
90% of children perform better when being positive with them, criticise them and they will just not perform.

It's almost like someone's gone in their, not all happy happy, chummy chummy and given them some actual honesty. Ronaldo of course is not going to fix any issues, and I was one that believed he wasn't needed. However, this man has standards way above any other player in the team and if they can't handle a rollicking from him, then they shouldn't be there.

These adults have turned into children.

25.) 11 Jan 2022 09:20:05
AAA, of course Ronaldo isn't the only issue. There is still a lack of quality and character in far too many of the squad.

Ronaldo is a player you add to a top quality squad as a finishing touch. A squad full of strong characters and proven winners who don't feel in awe of Robaldo.

The problem isn't what Ronaldo offers on the pitch as a player, it is the character and status that is the issue.

26.) 11 Jan 2022 09:43:56
Angel, the first half while not great was the best we have played since the first half against Palace. The first half against Palace was the only game in which Ronaldo pressed and worked hard from the front. Coincidence? It's almost like the style we are attempting to play relies on hard working forwards.

I agree I don't think most of this squad are mentally strong enough. They are not mentality strong enough to take constructive criticism and they aren't strong enough to live in Ronaldo's shadow.

While his "standards" tend to only extend to passing him the ball in goalscoring situations.

He's never fully satisfied when someone else scores, or even if the team wins and he isn't on the score sheet.

His standards are about "me, me, me" and not "us or the team".

If we don't qualify for the UCL next season Ronaldo will be off in the summer. He won't "waste" a year of his career not being able to add to his legacy.

He will always be a United great, and will be fondly remembered by all United fans. But he isn't the guy to help drag this team back to the top.

I mean simply we probably need to replace 20 of our 25 man squad either because they aren't good enough or aren't mentally strong enough. That takes at least three years. Meaning Ronaldo would be 39 a few months off of 40 before we even had a squad capable of challenging at the highest level. Let alone have the chemistry as a team to sustain a serious title challenge.

Personally I think Ronaldo should move on in the summer, a one year thanks and chance for those who were too young to remember him to catch a glimpse of him in a United shirt.

This summer though we need to start rebuilding for the future, it will be a rebuild that will be years in the making. Years Ronaldo simply doesn't have. He is a distraction and a link clinging on to the past, when we need clear focus on the future.



27 Sep 2021 15:40:17
So according to Ed001 we have the eleventh best manager in the League. Although i think he is a bit generous.
On a serious note i think he is spot on (as usual) and its worth a read in Liverpool page. I too find Tuchel too negative, Potter maybe should have been our coach, Pep and Klopp are the best two and their teams play the best football. Thank you 001


{Ed001's Note - very welcome mate and thank you.}

1.) 27 Sep 2021 15:53:04
Ole must have bought Ed001 a beer or two to give him 11th …. LOL

Seriously though have to agree Pep and Koop best in league even agree Tuchal is negative but he is clued up and that will win him trophies, so if that’s his style and that wins him trophies fair play to him
Potter I’m still not convinced he could handle the demands of club like United, but surely be better then Ole if that’s what we are measuring by.
Like when Poch had all the youngsters at spurs he could handle them and got good football from them when the ego’s and expectations come along he was caught short, that could repeat itself as PSG, so every manager like player as a level a ceiling.

2.) 27 Sep 2021 18:55:05
Can't seem to find the article anywhere? Help.

{Ed014's Note - it’s not an article mate it was a lengthy reply to a question which had dropped down to the banter 2 page on Liverpool banter.

You’re lucky though mate, Arteta was 20th ??

3.) 27 Sep 2021 21:51:56
Played well yesterday ed. That should have gotten him up to 19th at least.

{Ed014's Note - if only he wasn’t highly likely to revert to type next week he might just have nicked 19th ??



12 Sep 2021 00:40:26
I am totally with 014 . I will wait and judge Varane after a few games. Then if he is at the level of VVD we have a gem in our hands and i would be glad. But although he is a very good player i think he is not close to VVDs level.

The big guy is a different level to anyone, he makes things seem easy and effortless. He came back from a difficult injury and made Lukaku seem like a Sunday League player. Well, that's not so difficult after all cause I don't rate big Rom in big games :)


1.) 12 Sep 2021 14:49:10
I think VVD is on another level. Is there a better, more complete leader and CB in the world? I can't think of one. Even vintage Ramos and Silva in their prime don't reach his level.
But not to take away from Varane. I think he's right up there in the chasing pack.

2.) 12 Sep 2021 15:39:58
I think Varane is a top player, he has been instrumental to the success of Real Madrid and France. His medal haul alone proves he has been a class act.

I agree there is a slight question about whether he can do it in the EPL. I think he can, and he hasn't looked out of place so far.

3.) 12 Sep 2021 15:45:53
He's played 2 games mate, let him get his feet under the table before we judge him.

VVD is the best defender in the world but compare his stats the year they won the league to when Vidic won the league and champions league with us in 08. I don't remember Vidic being heralded as the greatest defender to every grace a pitch.

4.) 12 Sep 2021 15:46:14
VVD is a level above every other CB in the world. He had a long long injury break though, can get back and stay fit as consistently as before? Only time will tell.

But his pre injury level is best in world, no doubt.

5.) 12 Sep 2021 16:11:19
You simply don’t want the medals varane has if you’re not a top player.

6.) 12 Sep 2021 16:12:24
Vintage Ramos and silva don't get close to VvD? Have you heard yourself? vvd is great but I wouldn't go that far.

7.) 12 Sep 2021 16:31:08
Why do you know any better Whiskey? There are only opinions. Those were mine. I'm sure like most others here yours are superior!

8.) 12 Sep 2021 19:19:29
Spenno I have to agree. The only centre half I’ve seen in my time who compares with Van Djik is Rio. I don’t think varane is as good as him, but he’s not a million miles off imo and that’s a huge compliment.

I do also think there’s currently a lack of top centre halves about these days as more emphasis seems to be on what they can do on the ball!

9.) 12 Sep 2021 20:12:42
Van Dijk is a world class CB. But as is Varane. I know whose medal haul I'd prefer to have. let's hope he can continue it at United. Fantastic transfer for us. Shame that Ronaldo bloke looks absolutely knackered and way past it eh.

10.) 13 Sep 2021 11:22:31
VvD made Lukaku look like a school boy? Probably had nothing to do with Liverpool having the numerical strength in that game.
VvD is good, def one of the best in the world and that is where I end it, no need to overhype him.




Herrera's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

19 Jun 2022 01:33:59
So because we pay Ronaldo 30 millions a year we must overpay for De Jong or for everyone? What about Barcelona, who payed Griezman 45 (? ) a year, lowering their demands? Do you think it works this way?




Click To View This Thread

18 Jun 2022 18:48:14
Fireman do you think 15 millions are not a lot of money? Some People want to pay whatever they ask in every transfer. That's no how things work i think.




Click To View This Thread

20 Apr 2022 13:40:23
Thanks Ed002. I think Wirtz has an injury (Achilles? ) and maybe we wright him of for a year.
I am all in for these young hungry players. We need 10 players, not all will be high profile. If we take some of these players i truly expect an instant improvement with more hunger and energy in our team.


{Ed002's Note - He does indeed.}



Click To View This Thread

20 Mar 2022 22:34:50
I don't think Maguire is getting favouritism. Ok maybe he does but i mean for different reasons.
When you make such a big transfer you "marry" the player and stick with him unless he is no longer your player. Southgate rates him very highly so best we can hope is after the WC he takes the Newcastle job and make an 100 million bid for his beloved Maguire ?.




Click To View This Thread

20 Mar 2022 18:05:06
Shappy Kane offer a lot more than Ronaldo. He is more of a team player, defend from the front and he plays the Firmino role, he becomes attacking midfielder and create space. His passes are top class too. I would say Kane is a huge upgrade to Ronaldo.
But i agree its a huge ask because one problem is his injury record and the other that he cost a lot of money.





Herrera's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

11 Jun 2022 22:38:09
Ed004 do you think there is a possibility Kante will come to us?


{Ed004's Note - I think it’s highly unlikely. But with a year left on his contract now might be the time for Chelsea to move him on tbh}



Click To View This Thread

26 Apr 2022 15:24:28
I don't think Alisson with Ederson are close. Alisson is miles better. I would say De Gea is in the top 3 goalkeepers in the League and i would be glad to have a contract offer but only with less wages. I agree his contract might be a problem going forward because he earns too much.




Click To View This Thread

28 Feb 2022 23:57:02
What Shappy says is that unlike, for example, Greenwood, Elanga doesn't seem like a generation talent. A talent that with 90% chance to make it at the top level if he works hard. Although his example with Makeda is false.
I really like Elanga, give us something different and he is much more than a goalscorer (like Makeda) . He is rapid and direct, press and makes the right movements, seems to have the right mentality too. I think Shappy thinks this way too and there is no reason to attack him. For some people like me-maybe Shappy too-this site is our big company. what's wrong with that?




Click To View This Thread

14 Feb 2022 22:17:16
No Amz.




Click To View This Thread

13 Feb 2022 12:16:32
Dodgy I don't say we ate perfect. What Hassenhutl says we all know is true but that's above the manager for the moment and not a quick fix. that's the reason i don't understand the comments about Ralf. Ralf playing his part and he is playing it really well.